What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

RL independence day arrives - NRL Independent Commission announced for November 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...-stalled-process/story-e6frg7mf-1226079519754
Claims ARL has stalled process

Brent Read
From: The Australian
June 22, 2011 12:00AM

Former Australia player and IT guru John Grant is one of the new commissioners Picture: Adam Smith Source: The Courier-Mail

NRL chairmen are expected to meet in coming days to discuss their concerns over the slow progress of the independent commission, amid suggestions the Australian Rugby League has stalled the process by changing its stance on the appointment of the inaugural eight commissioners.

The Australian understands the four stakeholders involved in selecting commissioners -- News Limited (publisher of The Australian), the ARL, the Queensland Rugby League and the NRL clubs -- had reached agreement on the eight commissioners until a sudden change of mind by the ARL.

The ARL is now insisting on the appointment of prominent western Sydney lawyer Jim Marsden, even though he was vetoed by the other three stakeholders early in the process.

At the time, the ARL had no complaints.

However, ARL chairman John Chalk has championed Marsden in recent weeks, with his presence now placing doubt over the appointment of former Ansett and North Queensland director Mark Williamson.

The remaining seven commissioners are in place -- IT guru John Grant, former Qantas and Billabong chairman Gary Pemberton, Leighton Holdings chief financial officer Peter Gregg, former Australia forward Wayne Pearce, Harris Farm markets founder Catherine Harris, advertising heavy Ian Elliott and CSR director Jeremy Sutcliffe.

The ARL argues that Marsden would give the commission a western Sydney presence.

Yet Pearce is a former captain of Balmain and one-time coach of the Wests Tigers.

Furthermore, Harris and her husband David started their business in the western Sydney suburb of Villawood 40 years ago.

Adding to the frustration is the ARL's tacit approval of Williamson.

At no point in the process did the ARL seek to remove Williamson from the list of candidates. Marsden, on the other hand, had a line put through his name almost from the start.

It is believed the other three parties all objected to his presence on the commission.

The chairmen have been aggressively pursuing the commission's formation, and their meeting will be the first of a series of high-powered talks in coming weeks that will play a significant role in the game's future.

The chief executives of the NRL's 16 clubs will meet on July 21 to develop a unified stance on the game's biggest issues.

While the commission is close to being finalised, its control of the game is expected to be phased in over the remainder of the year. Some issues will fall to the commission, most notably talks over the game's next broadcasting deal.

However, others will remain under the auspices of the NRL and ARL until the commissioners develop a broader knowledge of the game's inner workings.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
70,170
we're letting an Ansett director run the game? Lets hope he didn;t make the financial decisions for Ansett!

The self interest in RL continues to ruin the running of the greatest game in the world. One day we may get a body that can actually take the game to the lofty position it belongs.
 

taipan

Referee
Messages
22,500
we're letting an Ansett director run the game? Lets hope he didn;t make the financial decisions for Ansett!

The self interest in RL continues to ruin the running of the greatest game in the world. One day we may get a body that can actually take the game to the lofty position it belongs.

It could be worse,he could have been the CEO of Compass Airlines.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
70,170
It could be worse,he could have been the CEO of Compass Airlines.
:)

I'm surprised they haven't asked Alan Bond!

Out of interest I can see the reasoning behind the others but I'm struggling to understand the Wayne Pearce appointment. Is it the token ex player or does he have a good executive management level career outside of his commentating?
 
Messages
14,139
This Williamson was a director of Ansett when it was owned by News Ltd. And he was a director at the Cowboys when they were owned by News Ltd. News took over in 2001 and he was appointed to the board in 2002. So that's at least two of the eight who are current or former employees of News. And then we still have Gallop as CEO.
 

BDGS

Bench
Messages
4,102
Out of interest I can see the reasoning behind the others but I'm struggling to understand the Wayne Pearce appointment. Is it the token ex player or does he have a good executive management level career outside of his commentating?

Pearce is a successful businessman.

He is also not the only ex-player on the commission.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...-marsden-and-rebel-option-20110627-1gnrm.html

ARL, News face off over Marsden and rebel option
Brad Walter
June 28, 2011

AN ANTICIPATED showdown between representatives of the ARL and News Ltd could today result in the historic announcement of the eight people to sit on the game's inaugural independent commission - or leave negotiations over its formation in tatters.

Almost three years after Gold Coast CEO Michael Searle and Sydney Roosters boss Nick Politis kicked off talks with News aimed at forming an independent commission to take over the running of the code, only two issues remain unresolved.

Still being disputed are the appointment of former Wests Magpies and Wests Tigers chairman Jim Marsden and the media group's refusal to guarantee it will not form another rebel competition.

The issues were discussed yesterday at a gathering of the Sydney-based NRL club chairmen at Beppi's Restaurant in East Sydney, and they will dominate a scheduled NSWRL board meeting today ahead of a meeting of the independent sub-committee charged with appointing the inaugural commissioners.

ARL officials and club chairmen want Marsden to represent the game's western Sydney heartland on the new body, but News and the QRL favour Ansett executive Mark Williamson, who has ties to both organisations.

The other seven positions are understood to have been agreed by the sub-committee, which comprises News chief operating officer Peter Macourt, ARL chairman John Chalk, QRL director Terry Mackenroth and, for the 16 NRL clubs, South Sydney chairman Nicholas Pappas.

The seven commissioners are:

2000 Sydney Olympics boss Gary Pemberton,

IT guru and former Kangaroo John Grant;

Adman Ian Elliot,

Harris Farm Markets founder Catherine Harris,

Former Qantas chief financial officer Peter Gregg,

CSR executive director Jeremy Sutcliffe, and,

League great Wayne Pearce.

Mackenroth is thought to be siding with Macourt in the selection of candidates after News brokered a deal that assured the QRL responsibility for the code in Queensland, thereby preventing Queensland Cup clubs from forming their own competition and dealing directly with the independent commission over funding.

The NSWRL controls the ARL board by a 6-4 vote, however, and a final decision on the eight commissioners has to be ratified by the ARL and News as joint stakeholders in the NRL, effectively leaving the QRL sidelined.

It is understood that ARL officials and the NRL clubs initially supported NSW Police deputy commissioner Catherine Burn, while News would not accept the appointment of former ARL chief executive John Quayle, who has been working as a global sports consultant since quitting his role during the Super League war to assist the peace process.

However, they are set to insist that Marsden be appointed. NSWRL directors, who include Canterbury chairman Ray Dib and Wests Tigers powerbroker David Trodden, are expected to instruct Chalk not to surrender over his appointment.

Marsden, the senior partner at Marsdens Law Group, comes from one's of Campbelltown's oldest and best-known families and is heavily involved in the local community.

As well as once chairing Wests Magpies and Wests Tigers, he has previously been chairman of the Campbelltown Chamber of Commerce.

If he was appointed, his background would ensure the new commission includes someone with experience in running a football club.

Since the Herald revealed the push to appoint Marsden, he has become the victim of a smear campaign in News publications over his decision to join the advisory board of the AFL's new western Sydney franchise, now the GWS Giants, in 2009.

However, Marsden has told officials he accepted the GWS role only because of the benefits it would bring to Campbelltown and supporters say the fact that the AFL targeted him shows why he is a worthy candidate for the independent commission.

It is unclear what will happen if News does not accept Marsden's appointment at today's meeting.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...se-for-extra-commissioner-20110627-1gnr3.html

Frustrated Mortimer puts the case for extra commissioner
Daniel Lane
June 28, 2011

CANTERBURY great Steve Mortimer urged those overseeing league's independent commission to increase the number of commissioners from eight to nine in order to end the infighting that had stalled the process.

He believes public profile is no criteria for selection on the commission, saying commissioners should be ''faceless'' and judged solely by their actions.

Mortimer, who championed the the commission cause three-and-a-half years ago, was frustrated its implementation had all but halted due to a dispute between the ARL and News Ltd over a late [ARL] push for Campbelltown lawyer Jim Marsden to be appointed ahead of former Ansett executive Mark Williamson. Marsden, the former chairman of the Wests Magpies, has helped AFL in its battle to gain support in Sydney's western suburbs and had reportedly been vetoed by News Ltd. The media company also argued there was an in-principle agreement on the final eight and Marsden's name wasn't on the list.

Mortimer's compromise could require the revamp of the independent commission's constitution.

''Increase the number of commissioners to nine if that is what's needed,'' he said. ''It's simple. Put Jim Marsden and Mark Williamson on the commission. We're at the stage where we have to get things happening, it's important and can't be allowed to drag on. The commission is king now. When you think about it nine is a good number to have [on the commission] because in close votes five would be the majority. If that was too hard to do, make either Marsden or Williamson an advisor to the independent commission.''

While Marsden had helped the AFL expansionary team, the GWS Giants to gain introductions to people of influence in the city's west, Mortimer insisted that made him an asset league needed. "Wouldn't common sense suggest league is far better off to have Jim Marsden on our side than to leave him for the AFL?" he asked.

Daniel Lane
 

Brutus

Referee
Messages
26,355
Wayne Pearce has a gig on Fox Sports and he's expected to make decisions on the next TV deal??

What a joke.
 

Rockin Ronny

Juniors
Messages
1,769
Wayne Pearce has a gig on Fox Sports and he's expected to make decisions on the next TV deal??

What a joke.

David Gallop is a News Limited lackey and he'll be the CEO.

Haven't league fans had enough of being treated like idiots - or do we just accept it because the News Limited papers say he's good.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
he will have to quit if he gets on the commission

don't fret

i'm sure he is not going to try and dud the game and he is only 1 of 8
 

bluesbreaker

Bench
Messages
4,195
Sit the original agreement out and tell news limited to get f**ked.
Break away from the NRL and form a 'rebel competition' again... This time for the people.
 

Rockin Ronny

Juniors
Messages
1,769
Sit the original agreement out and tell news limited to get f**ked.
Break away from the NRL and form a 'rebel competition' again... This time for the people.

Great idea.
News Limited don't ever do anything unless it benefits them.
"independence' is just a bullshit tagline to get the poor DT-reading bastards thinking it's good for the game. The trade-off is that News Limited get control of league's greatest asset - the Tv rights.

Rugby league has always been run by self-interest or club-focussed interests. the AFL has shown what independence should be like.
 

Ray Mosters

Juniors
Messages
237
Patience patience

Its more important to be done right than done soon. Yes its dragging but the people put in now will control the trajectory of the game for the next 10 years.

And the structures put in place now will help determine its trajectory for the next 50.

Just take the time, get things right.
 

yappy

Bench
Messages
4,161
Marsden? :crazy:

FMD digging your heels in over Marsden would be like digging your heels in to have Paul Carige named in Parramatta's Team of the Century.
 

andrew057

First Grade
Messages
7,485
Patience patience

Its more important to be done right than done soon. Yes its dragging but the people put in now will control the trajectory of the game for the next 10 years.

And the structures put in place now will help determine its trajectory for the next 50.

Just take the time, get things right.


Well said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top