What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

RL independence day arrives - NRL Independent Commission announced for November 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/n...-and-power-games/story-e6frfgbo-1225842565708

A plumber, politics and power games

* Special investigation by Phil Rothfield
* From: The Daily Telegraph
* March 19, 2010 12:00AM

HE IS more used to fixing broken pipes and leaking taps, but 64-year-old Balmain plumber John Chalk can now lay claim to the greatest administration shake-up in the history of rugby league.

It was 2.15pm on Thursday last week when directors of the Australian Rugby League were deadlocked in the boardroom of the NSW Leagues Club in a spirited debate about establishing an independent commission.

Chalk, a plumber by trade, has had enough. He puts forward probably the most historic motion in the game's history, for an in-principal agreement to hand the game over to a commission to run rugby league in this country.

It's seconded by former dual international Mike Cleary and is carried six votes to five on the back of chairman Colin Love's casting vote.

Welcome to the most dramatic management overhaul in 102 years of rugby league.

Veteran official Chalk says he is happy to hand the administration over to the "big end of town". He has been involved in football since managing Balmain's Jersey Flegg teams in the 1970s, before becoming chairman of the Tigers in the '90s.

"I don't have a problem moving on," Chalk said.

"Old people have memories, young people have dreams.

"Our game is in great shape but we're in a very hostile market. The AFL is serious about western Sydney. Look at soccer and their World Cup bid. They've got corporate people like Frank Lowy behind them.

"We've got to park all our egos and get the big end of town involved in the administration of the game."

The ARL had been stalling for months before Chalk, who had been revved up by Roosters boss Nick Politis before the meeting, paved the way for the long-awaited decision to hand over control.

No less than 32 positions on four different boards will be declared redundant by the end of the season as the search begins to find eight business types with no connection to the 16 clubs.

Like Chalk, a number of officials are happy to get out but others will be dragged kicking and screaming, most notably from Queensland.

Some will be handing in their blazers after more than 50 years in various positions in the game - saving rugby league an estimated $1.5 million in board fees, travel and accommodation.

Fees for directors differ on each board, depending on whether they are representing News Limited or the Australian Rugby league.

News Limited pays between $35,000 and $50,000 a year to its directors. Harvey Norman boss Katie Page gets $35,000 but donates it to charity. Stephen Loosley is rumoured to get $50,000.

On the ARL board, Love gets a minimum of $50,000 and the other directors receive $10,000 each.

Politis is paid to be on the NRL partnership board but has his $20,000 cheque sent to the Roosters.

Of the 31 photos on this page, only three will survive - Page, who is considered a certainty for the commission, Love, who has been offered the chair, and David Gallop, who will be offered four years as the CEO.

Roosters boss Politis has been one of the most powerful and influential officials in the game for more than three decades but says he is looking forward to moving on.

"I was hoping the partnership meeting we had last week was going to be my last," he said.

"We've got the NRL structure in place, we've got an in-principal agreement from News and the ARL, so there should be no reason for this to drag on for months.

"I'm looking forward to having a backseat role and just supporting the Roosters from here on."

Try telling that to the Queensland directors, who voted against the commission at an ARL board meeting last week.

"They're struggling to accept reality," one source told The Daily Telegraph.

"Which isn't surprising considering they were originally against the Broncos entering the Sydney com- petition and then the Titans coming into the NRL. They didn't even turn up for the All Stars game on the Gold Coast.

"They'll have to come around eventually because it's going to happen whether they like it or not."
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/commission-needs-time/story-e6frexni-1225842566991

Commission needs time

* By Phil Rothfield
* From: The Daily Telegraph
* March 19, 2010 12:00AM

ROOSTERS boss Nick Politis and his old mate Phil Gould are running a campaign to get the independent commission up and running within weeks. It won't happen.

Gould wrote in his newspaper column last week: "Why can't we start with the implementation of the independent commission immediately?"

I can answer that question. For a start, only one of the eight commissioners has been identified - Harvey Norman boss Katie Page.

Still no agreement has been reached on how premiers Melbourne Storm will be funded for the next six years.

Even David Gallop's job as CEO for four years is being questioned by some ARL officials who are concerned he is too close to News Limited executives.

These are just a few of dozens of issues that need to be sorted before the final sign-off. The commission will happen - but not until the end of the season.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
Even David Gallop's job as CEO for four years is being questioned by some ARL officials who are concerned he is too close to News Limited executives.

yup

cut him loose
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,869
5 out of 11 voted no, hardly a unified decision! Doesn't the QRL have 4 votes? I wonder who else voted against it?

Hopefully they can now start identifying and appointing commisioners and have everything in place for a fresh start at the conclusion of this season.
 

Brutus

Referee
Messages
26,354
Gallop just shouldn't be there.

He is a news lackey and has been from day dot. I know he apparently won't have anything to do with future media neogotiations, but the name Gallop in RL circles is alligned with News. And his style is something the game can do without as we look towards this, hopefully, bright new future.
 

Parra

Referee
Messages
24,900
"BSkyB's vacillation comes as News Ltd is seeking a five-year extension to its ownership of first and last rights to televise NRL matches. The existing rights expire in 2022 but News is demanding an extension to 2027 as a condition of its exit from part ownership of the NRL."

http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...oses-in-war-of-the-screens-20100318-qihp.html



Quoted from Roy Masters article in todays SMH.

This clause just gets swept under the carpet by the commission-at-all-costs brigade. We may as well drop the term 'independent' completely - it is a farce to include it.

The idea of News Ltd being given extras to go early is ridiculous. If anything, there should be some punitive clauses for breaking the deal that was struck.
 

Parra

Referee
Messages
24,900
An independent commission may be pie-in-the-sky, but an independent CEO should not be too much to ask for.
 

m0nty

Juniors
Messages
633
First and last rights aren't that much of an imposition as long as there's comeptition to drive the price up. Which there may well be if the likes of Fetch enter the market.
 
Messages
1,520
First and last rights aren't that much of an imposition as long as there's comeptition to drive the price up. Which there may well be if the likes of Fetch enter the market.

the great thing with REAL uncompromised first and last rights is that if you have them you have the 1st and last opportunity to give the other party EXACTLY what they want.

Before we begin, forget about price for now. Price is important but its not the only thing on which decisions are based. You must have all your needs met. Just like ticking the boxes on a checklist. Consider a situation where news can get in and tick a lot of the boxes for the nrl. They can put forward a strong contract BEFORE anyone else has a go. Right away everyone else is on the back foot. But they are not over the line yet. Because 7 and 9 and 10 all have a go.

It doesnt matter how good those contracts are, or how well negotiations go, how happy the nrl are with the offers....even if all the boxes are ticked for the nrl including national coverage, news ltd has ANOTHER crack at an offer. In the following negotiations all they have to do is make a comparable, if not, better offer.

As you can see its a real ace up their sleeves. They have the advantage to start with and to end - but not the ball game.

For the others, it means they can never have the final say - its like not being allowed to have the final say in an argument....if the other person gets a real good last insult or point in - you have to shut up. If you say one more thing they get another final go.

Its a considerable advantage, and one they no doubt make count. When negotiations are like a game of chess this kind of thing really helps you to edge out your opposition. Its no doubt a finely placed strategy for their own benefit. The of course do not have to exercise their first and last rights agreement. But its there if they want to use it.
 
Last edited:

m0nty

Juniors
Messages
633
It should be pointed out, PBB, that the last AFL rights deal also included first and last rights for Seven. And it turned out pretty good for all concerned, because Nine pushed them all the way.

If Seven pushes Nine all the way this time to produce a big headline figure, it's good news for league as far as I'm concerned, even if all of the smaller boxes aren't ticked. Baby steps.
 
Messages
1,520
It should be pointed out, PBB, that the last AFL rights deal also included first and last rights for Seven. And it turned out pretty good for all concerned, because Nine pushed them all the way.

If Seven pushes Nine all the way this time to produce a big headline figure, it's good news for league as far as I'm concerned, even if all of the smaller boxes aren't ticked. Baby steps.

I agree completely

and all signs point to up
 
Last edited:

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/sport/richo-confirms-sbw-has-return-on-menu-20100320-qn6k.html

GALLOP GIG RAISES EYEBROWS
DAVID GALLOP's four-year appointment by News Limited as the game's CEO in the brave new world of ''independence'' is causing enormous concern in rugby league circles. The question being asked everywhere is, if News has given him the gig, how is he independent? It's a fair question - why have News insisted on him leading the game? Gallop has done a good job but this next step was about breaking free from the past. As it is, Gallop consults News Ltd boss John Hartigan on almost every major decision he makes. Will that change? An example of a test of Gallop's independence will be when the next TV rights deal is negotiated. Gallop has been a tidy leader and he is a fair man. The smartest thing he could do is not accept a four-year deal from News, because he is going to have live with doubts about his motivations - something which has never been brought into question so far.
 

Goddo

Bench
Messages
4,257
Whats the bet there is ongoing "concern" about gallop and he loses the gig, just like love has?
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,869
There should be concern about Gallop, he is a weak CEO. I can live with teh TV deals as he has his hands tied but the weak performance in front of the camera, the running the game down in the media, lack of ability to control the media, poor financial perfomance of teh code, knee jerk reactions to player misbehaviour, inability to keep our stars in the game, lack of expansion strategy etc etc all signal to me he is not the man to take our game to the next level.
 

Green Machine

First Grade
Messages
5,844
I see that Danny Weadler’s gossip column is now on-line. I’ve never heard “enormous concern” about David Gallop for the NRL clubs in the past. Weadler should quotes some names if it is a fact. I see he had his usual garbage pumping up the tyres of Sonny Bill and Mundine. I see that Danny is no longer a fan of Matt Johns now he works for Channel 7. Seems Matt isn’t fan of Danny either. I’ve never been a fan of Matt Johns, but since he told Weadler off, he mightn’t be that bad after all. What wasn’t on-line was a comment that Malaysian billionaire T Ananda Krishnan from Fetch TV being good mates with James Packer. I’m not sure what the significance of that is when Packer’s major media interests these days is with Fox Sports,
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
Last edited:

Green Machine

First Grade
Messages
5,844
what Weidler reported was already know a few days ago as reported by News Ltd http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/commission-needs-time/story-e6frexni-1225842566991

That Phil Rothfield mentions ARL officials not NRL officials.

clubs have been concerned by Gallop for a while

Clubs fear Gallop has sold the game short
I remember when Russell Crowe made that statement. He met with David Gallop shortly after and basically retracted the statement. This is the same Russell Crowe whose big idea was to play state of origin after the grand final.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top