What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 11 vs Knights Discussion + Voting

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,125
Bennett doesn't rate Maranta.

He's just a smarter player than Vidot.

The rest of the options aren't any better.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,125
If Newcastle lose the NRL may as well relegate them to NSW Cup.

Brisbane pay the price for Origin...again.
 

League guru

Juniors
Messages
459
you do realise the nrl isn't the only rugby league played in this country don't you.
grow a brain ffs.

But ian,t that what where talking about here. An NRL debut. You can,t rate his performance before he has even played. I am getting tired of trying to explain things to you and your dumb mate. Super Coach Wayne has picked him, against your advice.
 

THE CHAMP

First Grade
Messages
8,359
But ian,t that what where talking about here. An NRL debut. You can,t rate his performance before he has even played. I am getting tired of trying to explain things to you and your dumb mate. Super Coach Wayne has picked him, against your advice.

right so you believe a below average lower grade player can succeed in the nrl.
unless a player plays in first grade you can't have an opinion on their potential.
go back to your room and look at your maranta posters.
oh hang on has one ever been printed??
 

Bronco18

Juniors
Messages
1,072
right so you believe a below average lower grade player can succeed in the nrl.
unless a player plays in first grade you can't have an opinion on their potential.
go back to your room and look at your maranta posters.
oh hang on has one ever been printed??

This is getting beyond pathetic.
 

Dazzat

First Grade
Messages
5,919
Well we'll see what Boyce comes up with won't we.

FYI ... my thoughts on Boyce came from comments from someone on this forum who said they have watched Souths play in the ISC and hadn't even noticed Boyce play.

A Newcastle fan also made a comment that he did nothing in his time down there.

One positive mentioned, is that potentially he's a hard hitter in defence. So let's see.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,125
Boyce isn't anything special.

Wayne is just a fan of his hard work, dedication and toughness.

He wouldn't be getting a shot unless the Broncos are short on backrows.

The only selection that worries me is Joe at lock...

Should have gone with Arrow.
 

Dazzat

First Grade
Messages
5,919
We are also down on front rowers - Gavet, Dodds and Garbett all down with injury - probably forced Bennett's hand with a safe/non flashy option of Boyce. Problem is we already have safe/non flashy in Stagg as well.

If we win against Newcastle, it will be a grind.
 

1qaz

Juniors
Messages
513
Newcastle centre Dane Gagai has revealed just how close he was to moving back to the Brisbane Broncos.
As he prepared to return to the Knights after spending the week with Queensland’s State of Origin team, the talented centre revealed he was keen to continue working under veteran coach Wayne Bennett again.
His release from Queensland’s Origin squad indicates encouraging news for the Maroons who have had a interrupted preparation with injuries to key backs Justin Hodges, Greg Inglis and Billy Slater.
Queensland coach Mal Meninga assured Knights officials Gagai would be released to rejoin his Newcastle clubmates ahead of what is a must-win match-up with his former club tomorrow night.
“It is always a bit different coming up against your former club and I haven’t played many games against Wayne’s teams, so that will be something new too,” Gagai said.
“But everyone (at Newcastle) understands the importance of getting another win after last week. It was really important to snap that losing streak and while we didn’t probably play our best footy, we fought pretty hard.
“Obviously this is a good time to be getting Brisbane … they are missing a lot of guys with Origin duty. But at the same time you only have to look at names like Benny Hunt, Anthony Milford, Jordan Kahu, Adam Blair and Alex Glenn … there is still plenty of class there and I know Wayne will be after a win coming back to Newcastle for the first time.”
Gagai was controversially axed by former Brisbane head coach Anthony Griffin in 2012.
Griffin was accused of taking hardline approach on the centre who was suffering through some personal issues at the time, having recently gone through the breakdown of a long-term relationship.
Without a footballing home, Gagai was thrown a lifeline by Bennett, who was then in the first year of his three-year stint as Newcastle coach.
Upon his return to Brisbane, Bennett made it clear he was desperate to have Gagai join him and opened talks in January, in a bid to lure the Maroons Origin prospect back to Red Hill.
Eventually, however, Gagai opted to remain with the Knights, whose offer reportedly doubled what Brisbane was able to put together.
Even so, Gagai said he had come within a whisker of making the trek back “home”.
“Given my relationship with Wayne and how far back we go, that was always going to be something that came up given I was coming off-contract,” said Gagai, whose father played under Bennett at the Broncos back in the late 1980s.
“I’m not oblivious to the things that were said after I signed on to stay in Newcastle, but to say it was just about money would be wrong.
“I was tossing and turning that whole week before I made the decision. One day I was sure I would stay; the next morning I would wake up and think ‘no, I am going to go’. It was that close.
“Wayne was great through it all. He never put any pressure on me, other than to say he would love me to come back to Brisbane.
“But at the same time I know he cares deeply about the Knights and a lot the boys here. He has a lot of respect for the organisation and he said if I made the choice to stay he would respect and support that.
“In the end I just decided that Newcastle had given me a good opportunity when I needed one and I believe my football has improved and continues to improve down here … so there was probably an element of owing the club something for what they did for me but also knowing that it was also going to be a good decision for my career.”

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/nrl/dane-gagai-released-to-meet-former-club-brisbane-broncos/story-fnca0von-1227367353408


 

League guru

Juniors
Messages
459
Boyce isn't anything special.

Wayne is just a fan of his hard work, dedication and toughness.

He wouldn't be getting a shot unless the Broncos are short on backrows.

The only selection that worries me is Joe at lock...

Should have gone with Arrow.

Isn,t that what footie is all about, taking the opportunity. He has been selected because of origin vacancies, injuries and as you point out lack of depth. Should have gone with Arrow is just your opinion, worth about as much as the opinion of any one else on the forum. Wayne picked him.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,125
Isn,t that what footie is all about, taking the opportunity. He has been selected because of origin vacancies, injuries and as you point out lack of depth. Should have gone with Arrow is just your opinion, worth about as much as the opinion of any one else on the forum. Wayne picked him.

So what?
 

Bronco18

Juniors
Messages
1,072
League Guru: why are you on a discussion forum if you're gonna knock down what anyone says at its just their opinion?
 

League guru

Juniors
Messages
459
League Guru: why are you on a discussion forum if you're gonna knock down what anyone says at its just their opinion?

Why be little people on their selection. Thats my beef. Even if it should have been someone else (as some believe). The player doesn't pick himself.
 
Top