Round 12 v Manly

[OldPanther]

I’d like the strip call explained. He just pulled that one from thin air.

It's obviously not true but such dodgy calls make it seem there was something against us that night.

 

[franklin2323]

Lucky it didn’t cost us the game

Neither did the Kikau one v Tigers. Where it may hurt is if by some miracle we get around that 8th spot the extra 12 points off our differential would be handy

 

[franklin2323]

Even if you accept the ball was not grounded, which it may not have been, the correct restart should have been a penalty to the Panthers for Korasiu not being square and or being offside definitely not restart by means of a play the ball 10 metres out.

If Koroisau isn't offside Kenny scores. Try or 10 in the bin should of been the call

 

[betcats]

It's obviously not true but such dodgy calls make it seem there was something against us that night.

Exactly, there is no way to explain it.

 

[martielang]

If Koroisau isn't offside Kenny scores. Try or 10 in the bin should of been the call

When the ref sent it up I thought he mentioned to look at Api being offside rather than being obstructed, I almost think the video ref misunderstood him.

 

[betcats]

When the ref sent it up I thought he mentioned to look at Api being offside rather than being obstructed, I almost think the video ref misunderstood him.

He said check for obstruction 100 percent.

 

[franklin2323]

When the ref sent it up I thought he mentioned to look at Api being offside rather than being obstructed, I almost think the video ref misunderstood him.

People near me thought it was dropped. Looked messy Live I can see why it was sent up...No idea how it came back penalty to them

 

[franklin2323]

He said check for obstruction 100 percent.

As you would live but on video was smart play

 

[BxTom]

He said check for obstruction 100 percent.

What he said was;
"I have no try. I've been unsighted there. Can you see if the ball gets to the ground? I've got it as being up. I just want to check for obstruction. If he does get the ball to the ground, check for possible obstruction."

Interesting statement where he stated the he had the ball as up considering he says he was unsighted. Just determined to deny Panthers a try.

 

[OldPanther]

What he said was;
"I have no try. I've been unsighted there. Can you see if the ball gets to the ground? I've got it as being up. I just want to check for obstruction. If he does get the ball to the ground, check for possible obstruction."

Interesting statement where he stated the he had the ball as up considering he says he was unsighted. Just determined to deny Panthers a try.

The bias is pretty bad when benefit of the doubt should be to the attacking team.

 

[age.s]

It's Cummins. Nothing should surprise you at this point.