What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 2 vs Sharks

2010

Bench
Messages
3,490
Give up Carlton. Dufty seems to be a protected species on this thread. I am a Quinlan fan and got lambasted when I stuck up for him and he's even smaller than Dufty. Still follow the little guy and pleased to see he got MOTH against Huddersfield yesterday. Fantastic game against the Giants. His defense and attack saw them take out a massive win. 38-6. Guess it could be a coaching issue but for Quinny to stop a 115 kg player crossing the line for a try was pretty damn cool. Pity he didn't the accolades that should have come his way at times. Sure he made mistakes in NRL but he played a better game at a younger age than Dufty. I'm expecting a barrage of insults coming my way but I don't give a shit. Quinny suits ESL and gained so much momentum under JD. Apart from injury last year I think Tim Sheens chose well. JD is still in contact with all his 2016 ISP winners.
We need to get JD back. Looks like he won’t be in the race to replace Bennett
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
Dufty is doing fine. He's 9 games into his FG career and passed a pretty stern test last night. Coming into Shark park after their Round 1 loss was never gonna be easy.

Wind was howling as well and in most part, he handled his job well.

The alternative was paying upwards of 800k to the opposition fullback who again couldn't lead his team to victory.
Sorry, but it wasn't all on Duges. He had a good game except spilling the ball on the line. I'd have him back and some of you guys are really quite disrespectful. Wind had died down 2nd half and running like a crab running in circles didn't do Dufty any favours. I'm not going to sugar coat it like most on here.
 

giboz71

First Grade
Messages
9,687
Sorry, but it wasn't all on Duges. He had a good game except spilling the ball on the line. I'd have him back and some of you guys are really quite disrespectful. Wind had died down 2nd half and running like a crab running in circles didn't do Dufty any favours. I'm not going to sugar coat it like most on here.

Not really fussed on how Duges went. He's a Shark now. and he's 0 and 2, and we're leading the comp.
I'm happy we have Dufty,

In head to head meetings, Dufty 1, Duges 0.
 

Carlton

Juniors
Messages
1,233
Mate I think let’s call it a day you can continue to believe your comments and I mine.
Don’t take offence at the “nobody” comment I’m simply saying on here no one knows who we are... so in reality our identies are null and void
It’s no big deal just the truth

Fair enough Saintm, I'm not saying you did this, I probably just interpreted it this way but I get pissed off when posters try to belittle other posters views.

I like having a logical discussion/argument but comments aimed at trying to make an alternative view irrelevant or naive annoy me.
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
Not really fussed on how Duges went. He's a Shark now. and he's 0 and 2, and we're leading the comp.
I'm happy we have Dufty,

In head to head meetings, Dufty 1, Duges 0.
Glad you're happy. I'm not. Substandard by a country mile. Your KPI's must be minimal. We won't be leading the comp if we continue with this tripe. Stick Mann into the FB [position and we may have a chance. Sorry to disagree with you. I just happen to think that everyone is blowing smoke up Dufty's arse.
 

Crush

Coach
Messages
11,360
Glad you're happy. I'm not. Substandard by a country mile. Your KPI's must be minimal. We won't be leading the comp if we continue with this tripe. Stick Mann into the FB [position and we may have a chance. Sorry to disagree with you. I just happen to think that everyone is blowing smoke up Dufty's arse.
DQ are you drinking heavily again?
Dufty is doing just fine. Perhaps 2 rounds is a bit too soon to be saying sack the bloke?
 

giboz71

First Grade
Messages
9,687
Glad you're happy. I'm not. Substandard by a country mile. Your KPI's must be minimal. We won't be leading the comp if we continue with this tripe. Stick Mann into the FB [position and we may have a chance. Sorry to disagree with you. I just happen to think that everyone is blowing smoke up Dufty's arse.

Nah, my KPI's are just fine. They completed 20/21 sets and had a cyclonic gale behind them. They won the comp just 18 months ago and they were playing at home after a loss. We ran them down after leading by 14 and Dufty was a big part of keeping their lead at a minimum by holding firm at the back.

What exactly was substandard?
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
DQ are you drinking heavily again?
Dufty is doing just fine. Perhaps 2 rounds is a bit too soon to be saying sack the bloke?
Haha no I'm not Crush but there is a glaring weakness in our spine. How can you say he is doing just fine? He's being thrown from pillar to post from the opposition.
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
Nah, my KPI's are just fine. They completed 20/21 sets and had a cyclonic gale behind them. They won the comp just 18 months ago and they were playing at home after a loss. We ran them down after leading by 14 and Dufty was a big part of keeping their lead at a minimum by holding firm at the back.

What exactly was substandard?
Right. So catching a bomb and trying to run around your opposition (without success I should add) is the hallmark of a contributing FB. Got it, but for all intensive purposes he wasn't a big reason we got that win. Not by a stretch of the imagination.
 

giboz71

First Grade
Messages
9,687
Right. So catching a bomb and trying to run around your opposition (without success I should add) is the hallmark of a contributing FB. Got it, but for all intensive purposes he wasn't a big reason we got that win. Not by a stretch of the imagination.

FMD we’re 2-0, beating 2 perennial semi final teams and all you want to do is bag our rookie fullback who’s 9 games into his NRL career?

Yet you lament the loss of Dugan who’s now playing for our most hated rival a year after missing team buses and planes, getting pissed in Origin camp and along with his mate Fergo, is basically a douchebag all round.

Time to get off the meds.
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
Dufty is doing fine. He's 9 games into his FG career and passed a pretty stern test last night. Coming into Shark park after their Round 1 loss was never gonna be easy.

Wind was howling as well and in most part, he handled his job well.

The alternative was paying upwards of 800k to the opposition fullback who again couldn't lead his team to victory.
It's called a team for a reason mate. Fullbacks are only a part of a team, albeit an important part of a team. Guess we got a cheap buy. Let's see how that pays off. Difference of opinion and no hard feelings at all.
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
FMD we’re 2-0, beating 2 perennial semi final teams and all you want to do is bag our rookie fullback who’s 9 games into his NRL career?

Yet you lament the loss of Dugan who’s now playing for our most hated rival a year after missing team buses and planes, getting pissed in Origin camp and along with his mate Fergo, is basically a douchebag all round.

Time to get off the meds.
Sinking to low blows? Wow, I respected you until you referred to him as a douchebag. He did plenty of good for our team and yet you refer to usual male regressions. Good one. Plenty of other young blokes have survived worse than that. I'll take that panadol and go to bed.
 

Belta

Juniors
Messages
1,131
Dufty continues to impress me. IMO he was more dangerous and effective then Boyd in R1, and more dangerous and effective than Dugan in R 2. His confidence is growing and consider many world class players who've played for years add extras to their games ie bay playing improves....he's got some way to go but he looks the goods to me


It's just my opinion
 

Drag Queen

Bench
Messages
2,981
Dufty continues to impress me. IMO he was more dangerous and effective then Boyd in R1, and more dangerous and effective than Dugan in R 2. His confidence is growing and consider many world class players who've played for years add extras to their games ie bay playing improves....he's got some way to go but he looks the goods to me


It's just my opinion
LOL thank God it's just your opinion. How many relatives does this kid have on this post? The thing that impressed me the most about Dufty was his ability to lay down before the opposition dived on him and dragged him sideways and backwards. Didn't see that happen to Duges. Did you?
 

Latest posts

Top