What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 25 | Cowboys 22-14 Knights @ Dairy Farmers | Sat 7.30pm

Round 25 result :: Cowboys vs Knights


  • Total voters
    5
  • Poll closed .

Joker's Wild

Coach
Messages
17,894
I don't know what McManus offers that Kev doesn't but I was not once excited when McManus got the ball. Least when Kev gets the ball there is like a 1% chance of something exciting happening... With McManus, he might as well be the Joel Edwards of the backs... There I said it~!

Look harder Yosh

Jimmy has done so much clean up and dog work tonight we would have been down by 20 in the first half without him. 50% of footy is about defence remember mate, Kev has tonnes to learn about playing an all round game in first grade
 

Joker's Wild

Coach
Messages
17,894
So that's all that's required? Why hasn't Johnson been penalized 42 times tonight.

Mate I agree with that but there is no use whinging about the offside against Alex. It was blatant

We didnt deserve to win tonight. Its a tough reality to face but its the truth all the same
 

Nuffy

Bench
Messages
4,075
2012 has been a fail, next year doesnt look much better with little personnel changes.

Not enough quality, not enough competitors, not enough hunger.
 

Zoidberg

First Grade
Messages
6,522
Radio commentators are saying Roberts was one of our best.

lol my wife likes it when we win too Zoidy

Im a surly merkin when we lose

Same. Everyone knows to avoid me for a while if we lose. Just leave me be.
So us winning doesn't just make me happy, it makes my girlfriend, my mum, and my friends happy too. The world is a much happier place when the Newcastle Knights win....so stop f***ing losing you idiots!
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,317
While we are certainly not the first team it's happened to, I thought we were absolutely embarrassed by Thurston and Bowen tonight. It looked like we were deadset watching them stroll through us at some points. f**king frustrating, I don't know how we kept falling for it.

Oh also, McKinnon is an idiot and I hope Houston is okay.
 

Tom155

Coach
Messages
16,236
too many mistakes tonight, cowboys cant win the comp imo unless they rapidly improve their defence, the dogs or manly will carve them up
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,202
2012 has been a fail, next year doesnt look much better with little personnel changes.

Not enough quality, not enough competitors, not enough hunger.
Everything else you've said tonight, fair enough.

But this one, GTFO of here.
 

Nuffy

Bench
Messages
4,075
lol Ok mate

Go have a beer Nuffy. It'll all look better tomorrow mate

Already have, not helping.

We endured years of sh*t and I expected us to be better than last year, we aren't.

Teams are improving, young players are starring in the NRL and we are regressing.

When are we going to get our sh*t together as a club and become the force we are supposed to be?
 
Messages
3,740
Not enough spirit in that.
I'd be happier with the loss if they looked like they had some drive and were out there enjoying themselves.
Mullen didn;t seem to control the game as well as he can.
On the plus, they held the Cows out well.

How many of these guys can go back to NSW Cup? Rochow should. Replace Edwards with him.
 
Last edited:

Zoidberg

First Grade
Messages
6,522
2013

In response to Nuffy's "When are we going to get our sh*t together as a club and become the force we are supposed to be?"
 
Last edited:

perverse

Referee
Messages
26,753
lol, Nuffy has snapped.

disappointing effort tonight. we didn't look like a side still in with a chance of making the 8. quite pedestrian at times... and just sloppy execution. god it shows when Buderus is off the field, too. Nev isn't a hookers arsehole.

credit where it is due, though... the Cowboys made it really tough for us in the second half. they played a very clinical game, even if it wasn't their best football.
 

Whats Doing

Bench
Messages
2,899
Not enough spirit in that.
I'd be happier with the loss if they looked like they had some drive and were out there enjoying themselves.
Mullen didn;t seem to control the game as well as he can.
On the plus, they held the Cows out well.

How many of these guys can go back to NSW Cup? Rochow should. Replace Edwards with him.

Why would you drop Rochow when he made the most metres of all the knights forwards tonight and 25 tackles. Replace him with Edwards- you are kidding.:crazy:
 

Nuffy

Bench
Messages
4,075
Everything else you've said tonight, fair enough.

But this one, GTFO of here.

I didn't do a great job of explaining myself so I'll try again.

The difference between us and the better teams is those three things, we aren't strong enough in each of them. Forget tonight, that's irrelevant, losing mid season games to the raiders and titans when they were going like busteds sealed our fate.

We don't have the cattle, established and coming through, our junior nursery is barren if Roberts and tets are examples. Compare us to big guys and it's pathetic. We haven't exactly hit the market either, Scott is our only recruit for 2013.

We don't have fierce competitors in the team, blokes who just push through adversity through sheer willpower, we used too, not anymore.

Finally, the hunger isn't there like the top teams, we don't want it enough, dropping 5 straight mid season was proof of that. Look at the 1%'s, we just don't scrap and fight for every last possession and in every tackle, things runs against and we drop our bundle.

We used to be unbeatable at home, now we likely won more on the road than we did infront of the fans.

Bennett won't be happy with 2012 and neither should we, we have a better team that's performed worse than previous years.

Until we get the same mentality as the top teams, we arent in the race, ffs Manly are going to go close to winning the comp 3 times in about 5 years, with all their infighting and financial issues.

When are we going to be a challenger again?
 

IanG

Coach
Messages
17,807
Alex McKinnon should go buy himself a lottery ticket. Very very lucky not to get marched and the result would've been worse if if had to play with only 12 men.

Ball handling killed us tonight.

Anyway that's our season over. Now drowning the disappointment mingling with the locals at their leagues club.
 

chinorocks

Juniors
Messages
1,662
Radio commentators gave Roberts 1 point in the MOTM voting...

God we suck at wrapping up the ball. Particularly in the first half they were just standing in tackles and offloading at will. When random flick out the backs and dropped passes go to ground we just stand back and allow the opposition to retain possession.

Our middle defence was terrible. Thurston, Bowen and Paine killed us all night.

Tyrone Roberts is awful he should head to England right now and win a man of steel like Dureau, because he isn't an NRL player.

Bennett, hit the market man. I'm not a supercoach but you didn't win all those comps with this sort of cattle. 2 props and a halfback would suffice. If it takes 2 offseasons so be it.
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
12,001
I know Roberts didn't have the best of games tonight but I'm still willing to give him a go. I'm not saying he is gonna make it but something about him says he can really be a good player.

That said, he had a TERRIBLE game tonight... Some terrible reads in defense, the time he passed to no one on 5th tackle etc... His missed conversion attempts...

Still I'm willing to put a bit of faith in the kid.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
Didn't see the game, but was Roberts really that bad or is everyone here looking for someone to blame rather than just accepting we simply weren't good enough?
 
Top