Mixmasterreece for the mighty Warriors.
******************************************
Shattered Glass
Sit back, relax and allow your mind conjure up a typical Newcastle Knights home game. Perhaps a Bluetongue stadium landscape, an emerald patchwork beneath a canopy of blue and red jerseys, a din of anticipation, air thats so frought with excitement that it almost hurts to breathe. Truly beautiful, isn't it? One might even say that this pristine vision of rugby league's splendour defines the identity of Newcastle supporters in some unique way.
But look a little closer. Are those empty seats scattered like salt and pepper across the landscape? Instead of the cheers of ecstasy, those rolling pastures are bathing in hot tempers and hurt. And zoom in on those dandruff-like flecks - seemingly caught in the fences that divide our vast spaces from the outside world - and they turn out to be fans leaving in droves before the full time siren.
Despite the image of perfection that's peddled by the marketing brains involved with the Newcastle Knights, 20 years of “Courage, pride and unity” * has turned into confusion, embarrassment and divisive splits. And it can't all be blamed on the departure of the messiah that was Andrew Johns. The club aren't big consumers on the player market, and theres screeds of evidence that they've played fast and loose with their recruitment methods – and with the club's future – when you look at both the the club's 13 year reliance on one man and their inability to develop a strong playing roster across the field.
The amount of information we're receiving about the club's failings - both on and off the field - is absolutely overwhelming, a seemingly stultifying combination of the grindingly boring and the absolutely terrifying. It's all player discontent this, Michael Hagan that, with liberal dustings of over-paying Kirk Reynoldson, the hunt for Andrew John's successor and the flavourless back line... not to mention warnings of biblical proportions, such as the lackluster look to the makeup of the 2008 squad.
A substantial report of NRL supporters from December 2001 to March 2007 was recently conducted by Roy Morgan International **, and the news was bad for the Newcastle Knights management. At best, the inability of the club to increase it's support base shows the club has been very slow to take definitive leadership in making the the team more attractive to support (a political minefield), failing to provide adequate carrots and sticks for supporters to get behind the blue and reds on a regular basis.
At worst, the clubs lack of growth has been paralleled by it's poor showings on the NRL competition ladder. The clubs supporter base has seen a downturn of 4.0% since 2001** – almost matched by the growing discontent within the ranks of the fans - and more worryingly - the players.
Especially bad news for the club's hopes of improving in 2008 is that, while the club has started to offload a lot of 'deadwood' on the playing roster, it seems to have angered senior players. Captain Danny Buderus has described the release of Adam Woolnough, Clint Newton, Josh Perry and a host of others as “"two much, too soon"***. If his comments are read into further, it would seem apparent that Buderus wouldn't lose any sleep if Brian Smith was given the 'axe' tomorrow.
While this might just seem like a problem for Knights supporters, it should actually be a worry to all supporters of the game. With the Knights short term future looking shaky, one could be forgiven for wondering if we might have another South Sydney Rabbitohs on our hands, and without another Russel Crowe to pull the club out of the cellar, the Knights might be struggling to stay out of the grasp of the wooden spoon for many years to come.
The Knights have been a fragile club since 2004, the amazing ability of Andrew Johns to turn the result of a game had momentarily brushed the club's deficiencies under the carpet. It was inevitable that once Johns retired there was going to be big problems. And it's not like Michael Hagan and Ken Conway didn't have time - it had be apparent for years that John's reign at the club was going to come to a close and the club would need to make some savvy recruitment decisions.
With an alleged rift between senior players and coach Brian Smith - not to mention a club rolling into 2008 with what seems on paper to be an appalling squad - the glories of 2001 will soon be a distant memory.
******************************************
References :
*
http://www.newcastleknights.com.au/
**
http://www.roymorgan.com/news/press-releases/2007/664/
***
http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,...-23214,00.html
750 words between the stars.