Round 7 vs Souths

[franklin2323]

Where did i say that? I just said we gave him an extension which is hardly a punishment from us unless he really hates it here.

But why wouldhe? He gets suspended on his suspension and then gets rewarded with an extension.

Any other club sacks him the moment he pleads guilty.

Garbage. Players rarely get sacked on 1st offence tbh I can’t think of any that have been

 

[Tronald Crump]

You can bet if May was a bum reserve grader with no talent he would have been shown the door last year, like Liam Coleman.
The fact that he is Nathan's mate and has a bit of skills he has been given another chance.

 

[WestyLife]

He played more recently then a few other guys. He played trials and round 1.. he is in the same boat as everyone else not in the 17

He's played what 3 games in a year and a half? He will need some consistent game time but yes a lot of guys will be suffering with no reserve grade.

 

[murraymob]

As I have said before, and I will say it again. I know people who are victims of this crime. Your view point would be different if you know someone who this has happened to. Do not bother responding.

Also, I am tough enough.

We could always line him up against a wall and fire
At what point is a sentence imposed by the courts and nrl enough .He served that
We have a justice system and courts to deal with things.They don’t always get it right

 

[murraymob]

You can bet if May was a bum reserve grader with no talent he would have been shown the door last year, like Liam Coleman.
The fact that he is Nathan's mate and has a bit of skills he has been given another chance.

Coleman was a repeat offender.And had been issued several warnings

 

[Tronald Crump]

Garbage. Players rarely get sacked on 1st offence tbh I can’t think of any that have been

Wrong
Steve Irwin did.
Todd Carney was disqualified from driving and drove Irwin's ute.
During a police chase Carney parked the ute down a dead end and fled on foot. Irwin who was a passenger remained in the ute.
Irwin was never charged with any offences yet the Raiders sacked him and kept Carney at the time.

I don't recall of any other problems Irwin ever had before the incident.
There is an old saying the better the player the better the treatment. Even better if you have friends in high places.

 

[Tronald Crump]

Coleman was a repeat offender.And had been issued several warnings

My point is if May was a reserve grade bum with no talent he would have been booted out last year. Repeat offender or not.

 

[Tronald Crump]

A little part of me thinks that he was living with Nathan at the time and there was someone else in those videos and Tyrone kept his mouth shut about who that was....maybe the Clearys feel a little indebted toward Tyrone,

I have those suspicious too.

 

[franklin2323]

He's played what 3 games in a year and a half? He will need some consistent game time but yes a lot of guys will be suffering with no reserve grade.

There were rumours of Shawn Blore playing this week for Tigers. He hasn’t played for 14 months... it isn’t ideal but with no 2nd tier footy then it will happen more.

Not that I see May playing this week unless the Cleary injury rumours are true. There is nothing those type of guys can do to get match fitness

 

[franklin2323]

Wrong
Steve Irwin did.
Todd Carney was disqualified from driving and drove Irwin's ute.
During a police chase Carney parked the ute down a dead end and fled on foot. Irwin who was a passenger remained in the ute.
Irwin was never charged with any offences yet the Raiders sacked him and kept Carney at the time.

I don't recall of any other problems Irwin ever had before the incident.
There is an old saying the better the player the better the treatment. Even better if you have friends in high places.

Yep all true so no club will sack May in the circumstances as they were

 

[mxlegend99]

Garbage. Players rarely get sacked on 1st offence tbh I can’t think of any that have been

Bulldogs sacked 2 players who didnt even break any laws just this year. Because what they did while not illegal was not morally right.

Is it really hard to think someone breaking the law with crimes related to woman would be sacked at most clubs? How often do you see them not only keep their job but get an extension despite getting in trouble again while still being punished for their first offence?

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Oh Alice reading things in my comments which are not there. Have a gre

I'm responding to actual posts you have made. Posts like on page 9 where you said '

'By the sheer fact you are challenging my viewpoint'.


Sounds like your demanding that I agree with you.

Guess what that isn't happening.

 

[CCJohnC]

MAY I say this has been one of the most boring and repetitive posts I have ever read.

 

[martielang]

Anywayyyy this will be a very tough game for us. I think we probably edge them in the middle but they still have quality across the park & when they get a roll on, very hard to stop Walker, Mitchell etc.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

The game will be a close one.

Souths are no easybeats.

If the riff sit back and rest we will be caught out.

Should be a good game.

 

[Black Diamond]

There were rumours of Shawn Blore playing this week for Tigers. He hasn’t played for 14 months... it isn’t ideal but with no 2nd tier footy then it will happen more.

Not that I see May playing this week unless the Cleary injury rumours are true. There is nothing those type of guys can do to get match fitness

What Cleary injury rumours?

 

[Jane Murray]

I'm responding to actual posts you have made. Posts like on page 9 where you said '

'By the sheer fact you are challenging my viewpoint'.


Sounds like your demanding that I agree with you.

Guess what that isn't happening.

WRONG. I couldn't care less about that.

 

[Jane Murray]

MAY I say this has been one of the most boring and repetitive posts I have ever read.

Yet here you are, reading this boring post?

 

[kinghippo]

Anywayyyy this will be a very tough game for us. I think we probably edge them in the middle but they still have quality across the park & when they get a roll on, very hard to stop Walker, Mitchell etc.

I think we have a clear advantage in the forwards and if we can put players on their backs it will hamper cook.
Souths probably have close to the best backline in the game when firing, but they have plenty of players that can go missing at times.

Roberts, Walker,Gagai, Roberts and lattrell can be world beaters but sometimes don’t turn up.

Hopefully we can bully them into some mistakes, but if we rush to hard in defence out wide they could hurt us.

 

[The_Frog]

Any other club sacks him the moment he pleads guilty.

Which is three layers of penalty.