Rumoured and Confirmed signings - Part 4

[Jane Murray]

What?

2018 - 24 games
2019 - 18 games
2020 - 8 games (20 round comp, no reserve grade)

I’ll leave you to do the maths.

I think you need to except that Dean is definitely not eligible for a medical retirement and move on.

I think you need to accept that, firstly, I am entitled to my view. Secondly, I am entitled to air my view, and lastly, if you do not like it, just scroll on by. It is that simple.

 

[betcats]

I think you need to accept that, firstly, I am entitled to my view. Secondly, I am entitled to air my view, and lastly, if you do not like it, just scroll on by. It is that simple.

Whether or not he can medically has nothing to do with your views Jane, it’s decided by the nrl. Clubs and players can’t just decide medically retire someone(except souths).

 

[Jane Murray]

Whether or not he can medically has nothing to do with your views Jane, it’s decided by the nrl. Clubs and players can’t just decide medically retire someone(except souths).

I am fully aware of that. Has the club tried? Who knows.

 

[murraymob]

Logan is a personal trainer and runs a fitness gym with his dad in Penrith.

if you go to mark Geyer on Twitter you can see daily training sessions from the gym looks a great set up run well .MG.active

I am fully aware of that. Has the club tried? Who knows.

well if they tried it failed .He is still there.Again I have no problems with the man wanting to feed his family and. Honour his contract

 

[Luke Bowden]

I think you need to accept that, firstly, I am entitled to my view. Secondly, I am entitled to air my view, and lastly, if you do not like it, just scroll on by. It is that simple.

There are rules surrounding being medically retired, he can’t just decide to “medically retire”.

There is no way he meets the requirements, despite what your “View” is.

I realise that you rarely use facts, but it might pay to check them on this occasion, it will save you from sounding silly.

 

[Jane Murray]

There are rules surrounding being medically retired, he can’t just decide to “medically retire”.

There is no way he meets the requirements, despite what your “View” is.

I realise that you rarely use facts, but it might pay to check them on this occasion, it will save you from sounding silly.

OMG, give it up. Again I am aware of that FACT.

 

[BossleyPanther]

Hasn't Russell Packer signed with Catalan Dragons

 

[Luke Bowden]

OMG, give it up. Again I am aware of that FACT.

If you were aware of it, why did you maintain that he should medically retire? Why did you say it was what you would do?

Dumb, even by your standards. It’s ok to be wrong Jane, I was wrong about this same subject at the start of the year.

 

[Jane Murray]

If you were aware of it, why did you maintain that he should medically retire? Why did you say it was what you would do?

Dumb, even by your standards. It’s ok to be wrong Jane, I was wrong about this same subject at the start of the year.

Because it is my OPINION. Oh and how predictable, that you will respond, and with an attempted insult. Well done. You will respond again, which is your right, I will not respond. Enjoy your evening.

 

[BxTom]

Because it is my OPINION. Oh and how predictable, that you will respond, and with an attempted insult. Well done. You will respond again, which is your right, I will not respond. Enjoy your evening.

Have your opinion Jane, I for one will just ignore it.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Because it is my OPINION. Oh and how predictable, that you will respond, and with an attempted insult. Well done. You will do so again, which is your right, I will not respond. Enjoy your evening.

This post is a stupid as suggesting that a club should try and medically retire a player that is currently fit and available for selection.

You won’t respond because you are unable to and this is your way of avoiding it.

 

[Jane Murray]

This post is a stupid as suggesting that a club should try and medically retire a player that is currently fit and available for selection.

You won’t respond because you are unable to and this is your way of avoiding it.

I broke my word. Obviously, Luke you are in the mood for a debate, I am not. Clearly, you do not appreciate we all have differing opinions. I would love to see Dean Whare moved on. It is that simple.

 

[Jane Murray]

Have your opinion Jane, I for one will just ignore it.

Sweet.

 

[Exsilium]

Hire Shane Richardson, he knows how to medically retire fit players.

 

[murraymob]

Hire Shane Richardson, he knows how to medically retire fit players.

The local Doughnuts shop would love to have him back .

 

[herbert henry1908]

He has not signed.
The Tigers are trying to get Daine Laurie early and are throwing up a few options.
Packer is one of them.

Are they mad? Where’s the upside for us?

 

[Luke Bowden]

I broke my word. Obviously, Luke you are in the mood for a debate, I am not. Clearly, you do not appreciate we all have differing opinions. I would love to see Dean Whare moved on. It is that simple.

Rules are Rules Jane, there isn’t really any room for opinion.
It’s like saying, In my opinion Penrith tries should be worth 10 points and all other teams 4.

 

[Jane Murray]

Rules are Rules Jane, there isn’t really any room for opinion.
It’s like saying, In my opinion Penrith tries should be worth 10 points and all other teams 4.

I've broken my promise, again. This forum is for opinions? In here there is. Enjoy your evening.

 

[Luke Bowden]

I've broken my promise, again. This forum is for opinions? In here there is. Enjoy your evening.

Opinions where appropriate, in this case, it’s not. It’s a rule.
In my opinion, you are terrible at keeping promises.

 

[Blade23]

Are they mad? Where’s the upside for us?

It won't go anywhere. They know his knees are shot and they rejected him when the Tigers were trying to get DWZ last year.
The Tigers are quite keen for Laurie to come early and are hoping for a deal.