Rumoured & Confirmed Signings - Part 5

[GowersDallyM]

The fact Taffe would be asking minimum to play in a good side? Luai walks who moves into 6 for us?

 

[Chins get the wins]

The fact Taffe would be asking minimum to play in a good side? Luai walks who moves into 6 for us?

Luai isn't going anywhere

 

[jane the pain]

Jane like most subjects you aren't very well educated on.

It seems like you must be such a expert in this topic. You must have some inside knowledge?

 

[jane the pain]

Gee that comment Chins is way harsh. I have an idea.......you can disagree with someone without making statements about a persons IQ, education or character.

I'm use to it Alice

 

[Luke Bowden]

Jane like most subjects you aren't very well educated on them

You make this statement, having just said that every club cheats the salary cap?? Really

 

[jane the pain]

You make this statement, having just said that every club cheats the salary cap?? Really

Thanks.

 

[Bred not Bought]

If all clubs are rorting the cap then the Dragons and Tigers are bloody incompetent.

 

[Bred not Bought]

The fact Taffe would be asking minimum to play in a good side? Luai walks who moves into 6 for us?

Luai. Stay off the tins.

 

[Chins get the wins]

You make this statement, having just said that every club cheats the salary cap?? Really

You think they don't? Haha

 

[jane the pain]

You think they don't? Haha

At least Luke doesn't stir things up. Your comment was inappropriate.

 

[19Panther90]

Doesn't Fuss me too much if Luai leaves the club, Last night showed once again how he chokes the attack and quite surprisingly Walker did a fantastic job.

The fact is simple Panthers and Luai 6 NSW take an age for points to be scored. Edwards is far more important to keep and Martin is our Terrier.

 

[Iamback]

Doesn't Fuss me too much if Luai leaves the club, Last night showed once again how he chokes the attack and quite surprisingly Walker did a fantastic job.

The fact is simple Panthers and Luai 6 NSW take an age for points to be scored. Edwards is far more important to keep and Martin is our Terrier.

Alot of it is how the side is coached. High completion rate is how we play

 

[Chins get the wins]

Luai is a good club half.

 

[chrisD]

Nothing of use could be determined from a dead rubber in which QLD made a classic token effort.

 

[age.s]

Nothing of use could be determined from a dead rubber in which QLD made a classic token effort.

Disagree. They picked fewer Panthers this time and got a better result. Clearly the answer for 2024 is fewer Panthers.

 

[Iamback]

Luai is a good club half.

He is high in most categories. I mean he had Cook at centre outside him in game 2.

Very rarely do we have a player dominate a club game, We normally share it all around.

For some reason atm people expect someone to dominate in rep games. Very rarely happens

 

[Iamback]

Disagree. They picked fewer Panthers this time and got a better result. Clearly the answer for 2024 is fewer Panthers.

There was atleast 1 try Brimson bombed. Walsh plays they look heaps better

 

[19Panther90]

Brimson was a far stretch from Walsh, I admit.

 

[Sime_11]

im more confident of retaining Luai then Edwards - Luai is from the area whereas Dyl came from Rural NSW.

Luai loves the West and has his family here - why would you leave a good thing?

Romey knows he can have his current attitude here at penrith - i doubt it gets tolerated at other clubs if things dont go to plan

 

[Pomoz]

Doesn't Fuss me too much if Luai leaves the club, Last night showed once again how he chokes the attack and quite surprisingly Walker did a fantastic job.

The fact is simple Panthers and Luai 6 NSW take an age for points to be scored. Edwards is far more important to keep and Martin is our Terrier.

Well, Walker had an actual centre playing outside him. Luai had Cook and Turbo in game 1, who doesn't play centre any more and was unfit and out of form. That said, I think Walker is a more creative player than Luai and the stats support that.

You can't build a team around the premise that there is a player better than the current Panther player so we should let our player walk. Walsh is better than Dylan, so out he goes.. Haas is better than JFH so out he goes.

Luai is still a world class player in his position irregardless of whether Walker is better and letting him walk would be a huge mistake.