Rumoured & Confirmed Signings - Part 5

[Luke Bowden]

It's not an opinion. It's a statistical fact

Can you show me the “Laziness” statistic. That’s a new one.

It’s your opinion based on your observations without any facts or idea of what’s going on behind the scenes.

It’s fine to have your opinion, but you need to know that’s all it is.

 

[AlbertRoss]

Rumoured & Confirmed Signings - Not for several pages​

 

[martielang]

Can someone smarter than me put up the stats of Garner v Martin. Avg. runs, run metres, errors etc?

The fact Garner has had injury troubles all year, which apparently proves Martin has played well, yet has performed the way he has is all credit to him.

 

[WestyLife]

Can you show me the “Laziness” statistic. That’s a new one.

It’s your opinion based on your observations without any facts or idea of what’s going on behind the scenes.

It’s fine to have your opinion, but you need to know that’s all it is.

You tally up how many times Ivan makes the same face as the misses when you don't do a job around the house and you have your laziness stat.

 

[Fangs]

Can someone smarter than me put up the stats of Garner v Martin. Avg. runs, run metres, errors etc?

The fact Garner has had injury troubles all year, which apparently proves Martin has played well, yet has performed the way he has is all credit to him.

I don't think I have the time.

But I will say that Garner has better Supercoach points. An all important statistic.

 

[snickers007]

Can someone smarter than me put up the stats of Garner v Martin. Avg. runs, run metres, errors etc?

Here's a real quick overview:

Martin
Games 20
Tries / Assists 2 / 0
Line Breaks / Assists: 4 / 3
Offloads 9
Tackles / Pct 539 / 91.2%
Avg Run Mtrs 70.6
Errors 13
Penalties / Sin Bin 8 / 1

Garner
Games 15
Tries / Assists 7/ 2
Line Breaks / Assists 6 / 0
Offloads 13
Tackles / Pct 349 / 91.6%
Avg Run Mtrs 77.6
Errors 3
Penalties / Sin Bin 6 / 0

All stats from https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/stats/players

 

[kinghippo]

Here's a real quick overview:

Martin
Games 20
Tries / Assists 2 / 0
Line Breaks / Assists: 4 / 3
Offloads 9
Tackles / Pct 539 / 91.2%
Avg Run Mtrs 81
Errors 13
Penalties / Sin Bin 8 / 1

Garner
Games 15
Tries / Assists 7/ 2
Line Breaks / Assists 6 / 0
Offloads 13
Tackles / Pct 349 / 91.6%
Avg Run Mtrs 84
Errors 3
Penalties / Sin Bin 6

All stats from https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/stats/players

Martin avg 70 minutes per game
Garner 56

 

[West Nowra Panther]

All I've been reading for 2 days is nothing about how shit Tago is, because he found form and had a great game on Friday night, so he must have been moved from death row.

But now poor old Liam Martin has been moved from general population and is awaiting the guillotine because Luke Garner scored 2 tries.

The guy gets pummelled and bashes blokes every week, obviously plays hurt with niggling injuries, has had a different half near him every other week, but NO, crucifixion is the only way for him, for the good of the fans, not the team.

Ease up you so called Panthers fans, players are like beer, there's no real bad ones, but some are better than others.

 

[WestyLife]

All I've been reading for 2 days is nothing about how shit Tago is, because he found form and had a great game on Friday night, so he must have been moved from death row.

But now poor old Liam Martin has been moved from general population and is awaiting the guillotine because Luke Garner scored 2 tries.

The guy gets pummelled and bashes blokes every week, obviously plays hurt with niggling injuries, has had a different half near him every other week, but NO, crucifixion is the only way for him, for the good of the fans, not the team.

Ease up you so called Panthers fans, players are like beer, there's no real bad ones, but some are better than others.

Tago was good. That's the standard we knew he had in him and wish he was achieving. It's not that he's bad quite the contrary it's a good player not playing to their own standard. Martin is the same story this season. Likely playing injured and not playing to his own high standards except for when with NSW. We finally saw beast Martin Vs Roosters but that shouldn't take away from another Panther who's been consistent in Luke Garner.

The garner one is especially note worthy since no one rated him while at the tigers.

 

[age.s]

Wtf there's plenty of bad beers.

 

[Panther Pete]

If we are talking garbage about who has been in form this year, to’o is similar to Martin.
He hasn’t had his best year.

I thought Too had been quiet since origin but he has definitely stepped it back up the last couple of games.

 

[West Nowra Panther]

Tago was good. That's the standard we knew he had in him and wish he was achieving. It's not that he's bad quite the contrary it's a good player not playing to their own standard. Martin is the same story this season. Likely playing injured and not playing to his own high standards except for when with NSW. We finally saw beast Martin Vs Roosters but that shouldn't take away from another Panther who's been consistent in Luke Garner.

The garner one is especially note worthy since no one rated him while at the tigers.

Look, I get it. For the 4th year straight we've had a slightly different side and this year it just wasn't as superior as the past.

But, the other sides out there are different too, and maybe, just maybe, they have improved some.

Any side is only as good as their opposition let's them be.

Factor in all the variables, injury, suspension, form and then do the same for the opposition and bingo, different results from the same players.

Crucifying individual players because the perceived standards are not met is plain and simple, nasty.

 

[Fangs]

Wtf there's plenty of bad beers.

Great Northern heads my list.

Others:

- Better Beer
- Iron Jack
- Emu Export
- Anything made by Grifter (Beware especially of Serpents Kiss)
- Pure Blonde no carb

 

[Iamback]

Look, I get it. For the 4th year straight we've had a slightly different side and this year it just wasn't as superior as the past.

But, the other sides out there are different too, and maybe, just maybe, they have improved some.

Any side is only as good as their opposition let's them be.

Factor in all the variables, injury, suspension, form and then do the same for the opposition and bingo, different results from the same players.

Crucifying individual players because the perceived standards are not met is plain and simple, nasty.

Other teams being better effects tries etc. not sure a team being good forces a good player to start dropping the ball and so on

 

[WestyLife]

Other teams being better effects tries etc. not sure a team being good forces a good player to start dropping the ball and so on

Or giving away penalties. Someone mentioned tago is one of the worst for penalties.

 

[Iamback]

Or giving away penalties. Someone mentioned tago is one of the worst for penalties.

Yeah top 10 in the nrl for errors and penalties.

That stuff isn't subjective like defence is and certainly not what you expect from someone pushing Origin selection last year

 

[West Nowra Panther]

Other teams being better effects tries etc. not sure a team being good forces a good player to start dropping the ball and so on

Penalties aside, good tackle techniques do cause a lot of dropped ball.

Doesn't mean a social media crucifixion is called for after mistakes.

Sometimes we just get outplayed.

 

[West Nowra Panther]

Great Northern heads my list.

Others:

- Better Beer
- Iron Jack
- Emu Export
- Anything made by Grifter (Beware especially of Serpents Kiss)
- Pure Blonde no carb

You got some favourites by the looks, BUT, nothing tastes better than FREE beer...

 

[Luke Bowden]

Great Northern heads my list.

Others:

- Better Beer
- Iron Jack
- Emu Export
- Anything made by Grifter (Beware especially of Serpents Kiss)
- Pure Blonde no carb

How does VB, Melbourne and Tooheys extra dry not make the list??

 

[WestyLife]

Yeah top 10 in the nrl for errors and penalties.

That stuff isn't subjective like defence is and certainly not what you expect from someone pushing Origin selection last year

Yeah he was clearly down mentally with things.