What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Swiftstylez

Bench
Messages
2,858
I will say it again. With Hayne a possibility of not even coming with no Norman or Foran, Cooper Cronk is now a MUST not just a little fantasy football wish. He allegedly will play until 2020 and at one point wanted to come to Sydney. He has to be sounded out before he puts pen to paper at the Storm. What is happening to this club? Wake up.
 

Swiftstylez

Bench
Messages
2,858
Some merkins on there just make shit up tho.

I find it hard to believe unless BA made the call.

I trust BA. Who knows, he might have Hayne and Jackson Hastings lined up.

Maybe Hayne & Foz.


Do you live in an alternate reality? We can't afford both and Hayne won't come here when Union can throw the dollars at him. So much for the NRL war chest, politics at their finest. We are f**ked unless we target someone right now and the only one that is going to make a difference with the absence of Hayne and Foran, someone that you can invest a reasonable amount of money into is Cronk. There is no other quality halfback on the market.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
Do you live in an alternate reality? We can't afford both and Hayne won't come here when Union can throw the dollars at him. So much for the NRL war chest, politics at their finest. We are f**ked unless we target someone right now and the only one that is going to make a difference with the absence of Hayne and Foran, someone that you can invest a reasonable amount of money into is Cronk. There is no other quality halfback on the market.

The reality is that you have as much idea as anyone here - zip.

Cronk is the Oz & QLD halfback. Why do you think he is worth less than Foran or Hayne ?
 

Swiftstylez

Bench
Messages
2,858
The reality is that you have as much idea as anyone here - zip.

Cronk is the Oz & QLD halfback. Why do you think he is worth less than Foran or Hayne ?

Hayne is worth a lot more than Cronk now that he is pushing up his asking price, third parties aside Cronk is on just over 600k and is apparently having problems with his deal at the Storm (probably third parties?) which are obviously still yet to be ironed out. If both Foran and Norman go I don't see why we can't afford both Hayne and Cronk, but if we only have one to pick Cronk is going to be cheaper and at least you have money left over to bring in or retain a halves partner.

If we don't have Foran, Norman or Hayne next year this is the only competitive option.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,546
The reality is that you have as much idea as anyone here - zip.

Cronk is the Oz & QLD halfback. Why do you think he is worth less than Foran or Hayne ?
It's not what he's worth now, it's what he is likely to be worth over the duration of the next contract.

Given Cronk's age, he is likely to come a fair bit cheaper than a player still in his prime. Especially on a multi-year deal.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,546
Hayne is worth a lot more than Cronk now that he is pushing up his asking price, third parties aside Cronk is on just over 600k and is apparently having problems with his deal at the Storm (probably third parties?) which are obviously still yet to be ironed out. If both Foran and Norman go I don't see why we can't afford both Hayne and Cronk, but if we only have one to pick Cronk is going to be cheaper and at least you have money left over to bring in or retain a halves partner.

If we don't have Foran, Norman or Hayne next year this is the only competitive option.
Cronk's kicking game is so good you could partner him with Gutherson as well. There wouldn't be a need to bring another half into the top 17.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,233
I agree he's over-rated but he's still the incumbent nsw hooker so not a complete nuffie. He also has a kicking game which would take pressure off our halves.

I'll also concede he's old but we are also considering offering De Gois a 2 year contract so I'm not sure age is that much of a concern for BA.

As for being a cancer, I think that's largely due to his significant influence at the Tigers. He has played all his footy there and they have a very young side that lacks leadership. If he were to join the eels I can't see him being able to exert as much influence, coming to a new club with experienced leaders such as Scott, Wicks, Gower, Mannah. I also can't see players like Mau and Edwards taking his crap.

With the Tigers forking out plenty of his salary for 2017, I'd offer a two year deal, with the 2nd year amount considerably less commensurate with his likely drop in performance due to age.

At one point, Brett Finch was NSW's incumbent 5/8, so...

He's a good player, but old, injury-prone, over-rated, selfish a dick.
 
Last edited:

phantom eel

First Grade
Messages
6,327
Some merkins on there just make shit up tho.

I find it hard to believe unless BA made the call.

I trust BA. Who knows, he might have Hayne and Jackson Hastings lined up.

Maybe Hayne & Foz.
Or maybe Foz and Hastings... and Robson?
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,786
There's a real possibility that we could have one of the most inexperienced spines in the comp next year...

Haynes leaning towards rugby
Normie is every chance of signing with saints if he hasn't already done so
Foz is gone
Flash is gone and
IDG may struggle to past Kaysa at full strength

I hope you merkins aren't expecting to make the 8 next year if that happens?
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,101
There's a real possibility that we could have one of the most inexperienced spines in the comp next year...

Haynes leaning towards rugby
Normie is every chance of signing with saints if he hasn't already done so
Foz is gone
Flash is gone and
IDG may struggle to past Kaysa at full strength

I hope you merkins aren't expecting to make the 8 next year if that happens?
If this happens next season the f**king board merkins should be f**king sacked!!!
 

Swiftstylez

Bench
Messages
2,858
Hey Cooper, It's Brad. You know the guy that used to be at the Storm? I've got a proposition for you. Whatever the Storm are giving you, we will add another 200k. What's that Cronk? It's only half of Hayne's asking price and you aren't even getting more than what you did in your last contracts? I'll give you a clause: if I leave, you can. Either way the season would be f**ked so you have my guarantee. That's cool? Ok mate, see you in 2017. We now have a hope of making the eight and hopefully the four. You would be revered as the halfback that finally had the class to step up to the plate for Parramatta for centuries to come. The younger generation today will be telling their children of the halfback that finally had the whole package both on and off the field. For proven class is what this team needs.




(Not a real conversation)
 

Latest posts

Top