What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,786
I would say to Benji..
This will be your last season at NRL level
Here's 250k..
Play 20+ games with us we'll throw an extra 50.
Take us to the playoffs there's an extra 50 there.
Win us a Comp - there's a extra 100 for the retirement fund.
Done.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,786
And by the way, I hear Bellamy is looking at Benji closely...
Who's brave enough to question the judgement of both BA and Bellamy??
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,403
I was about to ask how much demand there would be for Marshall. Remember, every player is a good signing at the right price.
 
Messages
13,876
Benji needs to improve his defence before i'd even consider him. Might be a bit late in his career to improve it.
But this young fella we signed from QLD cup could learn a few things off him.
 

The Colonel

Immortal
Messages
41,992
I would say to Benji..
This will be your last season at NRL level
Here's 250k..
Play 20+ games with us we'll throw an extra 50.
Take us to the playoffs there's an extra 50 there.
Win us a Comp - there's a extra 100 for the retirement fund.
Done.
And by the way, I hear Bellamy is looking at Benji closely...
Who's brave enough to question the judgement of both BA and Bellamy??

Build the incentives correctly and he could well turn into a bargain. He makes x if he performs. If he doesn't well he cost us the base and that's it.

Also allow Gutherson a further twelve months to work alongside Benji before a full time move in to the halves which I think he would do well at. Meanwhile he plays fullback and let's French mature further without added expectation.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,889
Will smith is equal to Moss.
We know how that turned out.Of we wanted penrith kids they have a gun under 20s centre and the jennings boys.I hear all signed for souths.
Wil Smith is to light and a huge liabliity in defense.He is not safe enough for fulback.
Id imagine his signing would be depth and back up from Wenty. He is quick on feet.And we do need a fullback for wenty. I guess he also can play halves.

Benji is almost had it but if he did come and was given a simple role he would perhaps be ok. His attacking skills are still a lot better then Robsons and so is his kicking game.So depends on cost.
$200-250k MAX. If he flops its not a huge hit.

I dont want will smith here.But if its for wenty not a bad player for them.
 

The Colonel

Immortal
Messages
41,992
Will smith is equal to Moss.
We know how that turned out.Of we wanted penrith kids they have a gun under 20s centre and the jennings boys.I hear all signed for souths.
Wil Smith is to light and a huge liabliity in defense.He is not safe enough for fulback.
Id imagine his signing would be depth and back up from Wenty. He is quick on feet.And we do need a fullback for wenty. I guess he also can play halves.

Benji is almost had it but if he did come and was given a simple role he would perhaps be ok. His attacking skills are still a lot better then Robsons and so is his kicking game.So depends on cost.
$200-250k MAX. If he flops its not a huge hit.

I dont want will smith here.But if its for wenty not a bad player for them.


What a load of horse shit. At the start of the year you were telling us how good Moss was and he should be playing first grade.

:joy:
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,403
Not if you don't need or want them.
Then the right price is zero. If you don't need or want them then you don't sign them. The point is that if you have a place for them in your squad then their value is determined by their price, not just by how good they are.
 
Last edited:

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
11,950
I would say to Benji..
This will be your last season at NRL level
Here's 250k..
Play 20+ games with us we'll throw an extra 50.
Take us to the playoffs there's an extra 50 there.
Win us a Comp - there's a extra 100 for the retirement fund.
Done.

You're crazy!!

You're putting the onus on him to deliver wins, which means he plays his hero-ball style, which is where he is at his worst.

It'd be more like
Here is a base salary ($300k)
For every pass that goes over the sideline without someone touching it -$5k
For every time you run it on the 5th tackle -$5k
For every time you kick it out on the full OR fail to find touch from a penalty -$5k

unofficially, NOT recorded in the board minute meetings, written down anywhere, emailed to the NRL HQ, or spoken of around Scott Seward: if we win the comp you get a part time coaching gig to work on Luke Burts staff. The 2 of you can put your heads together and come up with some new defensive techniques ($200k)
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,403
Wow. Edwards has over a year to run on his current contract. I guess we will soon be trying to re-sign the guys off contract next year.
 

amitropo

Juniors
Messages
585
I've been told Norman has re-signed. Along with Wicks and Edwards.
Edwards did say during his training eels video that when BA told him on game night prior to kick off while on massage table that the boys are stuck with him for next 3 years, he stated that he then replied to BA that he is stuck with him as he signed first for extension.

Edwards: We can’t drop our standards http://yi.nzc.am/QzVBI
 

Latest posts

Top