What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,123
And for the record I am only passing time waiting for my phone to ring. And if it does I am out of here for the day.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,960
Who says drugs are bad though?
The government? I just dont see a problem with people having a few lines or some hallucegenics on odd occassion. Most my friends dabbled in party drugs,weed,shrooms.
I just dont understand the drugs are bad thing. Everytime I had well I had a good time. Drugs are bad. Give me a break. Im fine.
Yet its ok to consume alchol,cigarettes and anti depressants on daily basis. Bit of a contradiction if ask me.
If they change the way you think they can change the way you behave, increasing the risk to others. The entire legal system is built on the idea of rational actors making decisions based on an understanding of the consequences. Illegal drugs completely subvert this. Obviously high alcohol levels do too, which is why there are heavy restrictions around which activities one can engage in while pissed, and why drunkenness is still frowned upon in respectable circles.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,831
How can we tire the opposition defense with pop gun props ? When was the last time Mannah or Evans dominated the defense. Unless we get a Tapau or Klemmer to compliment Jnr, it will be more of the same
No good trying to convert the converted Chiefy, I've been banging on about big skilful props for years and coping heaps of shit for it. But only this year has converted most of the people who've put shit on me previously and now they are saying the same.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,960
Actually the Panthers have to be very carefull.
4/5 years they been in same spot. Win a game in finals and blow the next game.
It seems a stagnation/pattern. Unless take next step they may implode.
Assuming a 50% chance of winning any given finals game it’s feasible to make the finals every year and never win the three or four in a row required to win the comp.

Obviously the secret is to increase your chances of winning a given game to well above 50%, but that takes structural advantages such as TPAs, facilities and being a one team town.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,831
I think Gennings is about as good as he will get. He's strong but otherwise fairly average for a winger. Probably lacks some athleticism and composure. Anyway he's good enough for first grade and I totally agree he would look significantly better in a winning side, like all wingers.
Hopefully Sivo? will be in similar mould as Semi. From his highlight reel he definitely runs similar to Semi so what has been holding him back, defence perhaps, catching the high ball? Hopefully he can sort the problems out in the off season, besides Semi wasn't a great defender either. With 2 big wingers we'll certainly be equipped to bring the ball out strongly.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,960
No good trying to convert the converted Chiefy, I've been banging on about big skilful props for years and coping heaps of shit for it. But only this year has converted most of the people who've put shit on me previously and now they are saying the same.
We all know who the best middle forwards are too, merkin. You’re not the only one who watches rep footy.

But our club is on a budget and clubs with deeper pockets tend to beat us to the best players. There’s no use whinging about it. We just need to do the best with what we have, which happened last year but most certainly did not happen this year.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,831
That's been our defensive structure for years. Often the centre jams as well.
Mennings was guilty of running out of the line and stopping nobody leaving the winger with a 2-3 overlap. Very poor form from a noted defensive centre, so did he have brain snaps or was our defensive structure shit? I expect the latter, and this needs fixing otherwise BA imo won't last the year.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,831
We all know who the best middle forwards are too, merkin. You’re not the only one who watches rep footy.

But our club is on a budget and clubs with deeper pockets tend to beat us to the best players. There’s no use whinging about it. We just need to do the best with what we have, which happened last year but most certainly did not happen this year.
There was a perception, rightly or wrongly, that BA didn't go after the big forwards, there was no good big forward purchased under BAs tenure. At the start of this year he was highly praising our forward pack. Just proves what poor judgement he has. Even with a shit year he has purchased Junior and Lane so why didn't he do it earlier in the better years?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,960
Mennings was guilty of running out of the line and stopping nobody leaving the winger with a 2-3 overlap. Very poor form from a noted defensive centre, so did he have brain snaps or was our defensive structure shit? I expect the latter, and this needs fixing otherwise BA imo won't last the year.
Every team uses outside backs this way in defence. The alternative is to slide on your tryline, which is a massive no-no.

So against numbers the defender needs to make a decision, and the playmaker needs to react to that. Often the defence is f**ked no matter what. In those cases the mistake was not getting the numbers right, which comes from being too slow or lazy in the middle.

But of course sometimes there is no need for a defender to come in, but usually when merkins go off about an outside back not staying on his man it seems to me that if he had stayed out the attack would have just crashed over closer infield anyway.
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,878
There was a perception, rightly or wrongly, that BA didn't go after the big forwards, there was no good big forward purchased under BAs tenure. At the start of this year he was highly praising our forward pack. Just proves what poor judgement he has. Even with a shit year he has purchased Junior and Lane so why didn't he do it earlier in the better years?
Whilst BA was publicly praising our forward pack, what were his options? To publicly state that "Our forwards are shit and not likely to get us anywhere but what the hell...".
Just because the public do not see or know who the club is targeting, talking to, or making unsuccessful offers to, doesn't mean we weren't out there doing it.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,960
There was a perception, rightly or wrongly, that BA didn't go after the big forwards, there was no good big forward purchased under BAs tenure. At the start of this year he was highly praising our forward pack. Just proves what poor judgement he has. Even with a shit year he has purchased Junior and Lane so why didn't he do it earlier in the better years?
He praised them because they did a good job the previous two years. How is that poor judgement? We used our mobility to beat bigger packs, but this requires the halves playing smartly and sending the ball where the defence is thin. This year that didn’t happen. Plus the edge forwards (and Brown) who were so good for us last year missed heaps of footy. Edwards was one of our key attacking players and he got arseholed from the club early on.

Buying Paulo, Evans and co is about changing the way we attack, so we don’t need to rely on edge players getting it right.
 

Obscene Assassin

First Grade
Messages
6,391
At the start of this year he was highly praising our forward pack. Just proves what poor judgement he has

"Yeah our forwards are shit, there's no point in us playing this season cause we're gonna get smashed". Strawman I know but if he had said this publicly what do our forwards then think?
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,831
He praised them because they did a good job the previous two years. How is that poor judgement? We used our mobility to beat bigger packs, but this requires the halves playing smartly and sending the ball where the defence is thin. This year that didn’t happen. Plus the edge forwards (and Brown) who were so good for us last year missed heaps of footy. Edwards was one of our key attacking players and he got arseholed from the club early on.

Buying Paulo, Evans and co is about changing the way we attack, so we don’t need to rely on edge players getting it right.
What a load of shit, our pack is no more mobile than any other club. In fact our pack looks about the slowest of all the clubs, and it showed this year. Our play the ball is so slow most opposing players are rolling their own waiting. And don't get me started about our lack of offloading and shit poor attack because of it.

End of rant, for now!
 

Latest posts

Top