What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,887
I’ll also throw into the debate the fact we were serious about bringing Burgess into the squad, which would have made Evans even less likely to be play first grade. Even at that conservative $250k mark, that’s far too much cap space tied up in your 8th middle. If not already, Kaufusi may take over him and Stefano could be anything by midway through the season. As it stands I reckon this is the likely pecking order:

Paulo
Alvaro
Brown
Mannah
Terepo
Tep/Mau/Lane’s minutes in the middle
Evans
Kaufusi
Stefano
Gower
Stone
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,733
I’ll also throw into the debate the fact we were serious about bringing Burgess into the squad, which would have made Evans even less likely to be play first grade. Even at that conservative $250k mark, that’s far too much cap space tied up in your 8th middle. If not already, Kaufusi may take over him and Stefano could be anything by midway through the season. As it stands I reckon this is the likely pecking order:

Paulo
Alvaro
Brown
Mannah
Terepo
Tep/Mau/Lane’s minutes in the middle
Evans
Kaufusi
Stefano
Gower
Stone
I think your depth chart is too rigid. There would not be the same number of levels as players. Instead there would be fewer levels with multiple players filling each level. The top level would just consist of the genuine top 17 players, including Paulo, Alvaro, Brown and Moeroa. Until he shows otherwise I consider Mannah to be part of this group as well. At the bottom are the genuine backups (only to be used in an injury crisis) like Stone. In the middle are players like Evans and Terepo. Who gets the nod out of these merkins depends on form and fitness, two things that fluctuate throughout the season.
 
Messages
42,876
If we needed his height that badly he wouldn’t have played reserve grade.
He had to play reserve grade to get fit. Anyway, this sounds like BA was thinking Evans was more than just depth.

https://www.theherald.com.au/story/5246434/settled-eels-primed-for-finals-pusharthur/
However Arthur rates Evans' addition as just as important as the code-hopper, arming the Eels with a weapon other teams will fear charging out of the middle of a smallish forward pack.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,733
Depth players all have something to offer. Otherwise they wouldn’t be able to compete for a spot in the 17.

It comes down to which one offers the most. He gets the nod that week.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,877

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,887
Did the cap only go up for us, and only at the last minute? Very lucky for the five players who got new contracts at that time.
No it didn’t. Which means plenty of other clubs would have had cash to push his price up.

Also, this article dated November 3rd 2017 reports on the salary cap increase finally getting approved for 2018. That’s about as last minute as you can get!!

https://www.google.com.au/amp/s/cou...s/news-story/8bf335bcb36781c772a1de7d6aa60967
 
Last edited:

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,887
I think your depth chart is too rigid. There would not be the same number of levels as players. Instead there would be fewer levels with multiple players filling each level. The top level would just consist of the genuine top 17 players, including Paulo, Alvaro, Brown and Moeroa. Until he shows otherwise I consider Mannah to be part of this group as well. At the bottom are the genuine backups (only to be used in an injury crisis) like Stone. In the middle are players like Evans and Terepo. Who gets the nod out of these merkins depends on form and fitness, two things that fluctuate throughout the season.
Terepo played 20 games last year, missing the first 3 games through suspension, whereas Evans played 8 games. In 2018 at least, I think Terepo has to be considered a genuine top 17 player. He would be worth around that $250-$300 figure IMO with the cap increase. K.evan not so much.
 

Latest posts

Top