Rumours and Stuff

[I'm a loser baby...]

In terms of raw ability, Haynes was the best player Parramatta has ever produced, imo - kick, pass, run, tackle...he could do it all.

But in a professional league, with a salary cap, I would take Gutherson over him; I'm well aware that he is nowhere near as talented, but Gutherson provides in areas that Hayne struggled in (leadership, involvement), costs a lot less (allowing us to spend cap money in other areas), and (while not being in the same league as Hayne) Gutherson is still a very skilful fullback.

I know it's controversial, but there you go.

Probably true but that was an era when we weren't telling players to get f**ked.

 

[hindy111]

Hughes and Hollis have never played a Cantebury Cup game. Even last year they played SG Ball and at the conclusion of that played the remainder of the Jersey Flegg (7 or 8 games).

Hollis is playing for the Hills Bulls at the moment coming off the bench in the Presidents Cup.

Arent both boys 19 and turn 20 next year? I never said they'd play NRL but would perhaps take Stefano's spot who has had minimal minutes.

 

[hindy111]

They were starting front rowers in the reserve grade trial against West’s Tigers which was won 54-10 or close to. Both played well and would probably have played a number of games after starting in Presidents cup. Big enough and physical enough to handle it.

And 12mths at that age a kid will develop a lot. Another off-season will change things.

 

[Twizzle]

You're the one running around shrieking that's-your-opinion when you don't like what's said

thats the opposite of what I said, you want to argue so bad you've forgotten what you were arguing about

for the record, I said your opinion is not fact, you've lost the plot mate

anyway, thats all I have to say on the matter

knock yourself out

 

[T-Boon]

And as I said, involvement too low for a conventional fullback. It's a position that requires an endurance athlete to provide full service. Otherwise it's just a roaming winger.

True you did say that. But its wrong. Totally erroneous.

 

[T-Boon]

Hayne needed to play with a good forward pack. He would be epic behind this forward pack.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

f**king lol...………………..

Wooden spoons aren't funny and neither are accusations of sex crimes.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

thats the opposite of what I said, you want to argue so bad you've forgotten what you were arguing about

for the record, I said your opinion is not fact, you've lost the plot mate

anyway, thats all I have to say on the matter

knock yourself out

Your opinion isn't fact either. What's the point of stating the obvious here? You were just being a dick.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Hayne needed to play with a good forward pack. He would be epic behind this forward pack.

Yeah just coincidence he never played in a good team after moving to fullback and earning huge money. In 2018 he joined a team that had just finished in the top four and he won another spoon. Add soon as he left we were back in the finals.

 

[T-Boon]

Yeah just coincidence he never played in a good team after moving to fullback and earning huge money. In 2018 he joined a team that had just finished in the top four and he won another spoon. Add soon as he left we were back in the finals.

He was loyal to Parra through a terrible era and played against the best QLD team ever his whole origin career. Like are you saying its his fault NSW got hammered by that Qld team for 11 years in a row?

 

[hindy111]

Your opinion isn't fact either. What's the point of stating the obvious here? You were just being a dick.

Or a dickface

 

[hindy111]

He was loyal to Parra through a terrible era and played against the best QLD team ever his whole origin career. Like are you saying its his fault NSW got hammered by that Qld team for 11 years in a row?

I'd say Hayne was the mian reason NSW won that series when Reynolds was in halves.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

He was loyal to Parra through a terrible era and played against the best QLD team ever his whole origin career. Like are you saying its his fault NSW got hammered by that Qld team for 11 years in a row?

Loyal to Parra, the desperate club who was always highest bidder? How loyal was he when the Titans offered him more money?

 

[Poupou Escobar]

I'd say Hayne was the mian reason NSW won that series when Reynolds was in halves.

He was obviously an awesome player. He won Blues player of the series from the wing. Twice I think.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Loyal to Parra, the desperate club who was always highest bidder? How loyal was he when the Titans offered him more money?

or at the end off 2018 when the dragons were offering more..........

 

[T-Boon]

Loyal to Parra, the desperate club who was always highest bidder? How loyal was he when the Titans offered him more money?

That was Greenberg's doing.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

That was Greenberg's doing.

Don't make excuses for him. No player is forced to play for any club.

 

[Incorrect]

or at the end off 2018 when the dragons were offering more..........

Geez, Dragons dodged a bullet there... Instead they got Corey instead.... Wait....

 

[Chipmunk]

This has probably been mentioned somewhere on the forum, but does anyone know if Alvaro and Jennings will be able to play against us?

 

[Incorrect]

This has probably been mentioned somewhere on the forum, but does anyone know if Alvaro and Jennings will be able to play against us?

I believe they have returned to us from the Warriors and are no longer on loan. The Warriors game V the Dogs was the last for them.