TBH I hope he does decide to go to market at the end of the season. At this stage I'd hate to give him $5 mil over 5 years. It's a real double edged sword as if he does progress and becomes the player everyone thinks and hopes he'll be, it would be a bargain. However, based on the 4 games so far (and it is only 4 games, a long time to go in the season) he's regressed from what he was producing last year.
If he agreed to those terms now, and either plateaued, or continued to regress.........well it's Luke Brooks' all over again.
I'd be calling Moses bluff, and saying we respect Lachie's decision to go to market, and come November 1 we'll be first to contact you with an offer. This gives us the entire year to assess where he's at. This shows him the respect that all players crave and demand (whether they deserve it or not) and gives us time to determine his worth against our cap requirements. I'd check in with him periodically to make sure he's still happy to wait until November 1, which covers our arse should a DCE situation arise and it's all he said, she said.
Although it's illegal to negotiate prior to November 1, it's not illegal to express interest in other players we might want, if Galvin goes elsewhere, or doesn't improve as we want him to but still asks for a premium contract. We can contact them and let them know if they go to market also, we'd be interested. It gives us options.