What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rusty Let Us Bring Maitua Home

MattJ

Juniors
Messages
1,367
Im almost certain you guys are taking the piss, but it scares me a little that you may not be.
Even if hegarty does have a great season... how can you say a winger is the player that will lead the team to "the promised land?". A winger who has not shown any kind of form or consistency for years?
We have far better options for the backline now, he will only be used if there is no other alternative.
 

Paul Hewson

Juniors
Messages
746
I really believe that Hegs has been unfairly treated by Souths fans at times. Yes I do know that he has had plenty of shockers and done some crazy things.

I remember the game against Manly at Brookie this year. Hegs was by far our best player (I guess that shows how well we played). He recieved 16 out of the 17 player votes with only himself not selecting himself.

I couldn't believe that people still were critical of him. That just proved to me that no msatter what he does people will always pick him.
 

MattJ

Juniors
Messages
1,367
I really believe that Hegs has been unfairly treated by Souths fans at times. Yes I do know that he has had plenty of shockers and done some crazy things.

I remember the game against Manly at Brookie this year. Hegs was by far our best player (I guess that shows how well we played). He recieved 16 out of the 17 player votes with only himself not selecting himself.

I couldn't believe that people still were critical of him. That just proved to me that no msatter what he does people will always pick him.

Its nothing personal against the guy, but he is no longer one of the best options we have for the backline... some fans may take the blaming him for everything to the extreme, but can you honestly say he has been a strong player or even an above average player for any type of consistent time span?
People here are talking up as a leader and a game breaker etc... when he has one of his great games its because he has made metres out of dummy half, thats the only thing he is occasionaly capable of.
C'mon Paul, i've stood next to you at plenty of games in the last few years and heard you swearing and cursing about Hegs as much if not more than anyone else.
 

Ronnie Dobbs

Coach
Messages
17,344
This is not a popularity contest lads.

Hegs will play fg again because JT and the cadre understand that he has a lot to offer the team.

Heres a guy who made 200m+ against the eventual Grand Final winners who smahed the record books against the best team and coach in the last decade.

When his heads screwed on, he can match it with the best of them.

I make this solemn promise here and now.

Hegs will lead us to the promised land.

Years of confusion and darkness will be put right.

I believe in Shannon Heggarty and I always will.

What about the other 23 games Dave?
 
Messages
14,937
We all have differing opinions on Hegs,but one thing is crystal clear,is that JT is a massive fan of his,and was responsible for Hegs's last contract resigning.
 
Messages
654
You guys deserve the woman bashing bra boy thug

And the woman bashing bra boy thug deserves you

A match made in heaven id say.
 
Messages
654
On hegs, its not his fault, souths have sihned plenty of players in their prime and farked them up, if given a fair dinkum shot he would be very very handy at least.

I liked hegs at Easts, his loyalty can be questioned but his effort can not.
 

Paul Hewson

Juniors
Messages
746
Its nothing personal against the guy, but he is no longer one of the best options we have for the backline... some fans may take the blaming him for everything to the extreme, but can you honestly say he has been a strong player or even an above average player for any type of consistent time span?
People here are talking up as a leader and a game breaker etc... when he has one of his great games its because he has made metres out of dummy half, thats the only thing he is occasionaly capable of.
C'mon Paul, i've stood next to you at plenty of games in the last few years and heard you swearing and cursing about Hegs as much if not more than anyone else.

One thing I do is call it as I see it. When he has a shocker I will say so and when he plays well I will say so. To me it seems as though no matter what he does from here on in people have their minds made up.

I'm not saying that he will be in the starting line-up and he wouldn't make my strongest line-up. All I am saying is that the treatment of him has been very unfair.
 

Earl Hickey

Juniors
Messages
180
I really believe that Hegs has been unfairly treated by Souths fans at times.

Paul, I'll agree with you here that Hegs does get unfairly treated at times but so does Capewell and Simpson.My issue with Hegs is'nt with his game but the favourable treatment JT gives him.
 

Appin Rabbit

Juniors
Messages
1,038
:crazy:Maybe if JT keeps giving Hegs favourable treatment by the end of 2009 they will both be shown the door
Paul, I'll agree with you here that Hegs does get unfairly treated at times but so does Capewell and Simpson.My issue with Hegs is'nt with his game but the favourable treatment JT gives him.
 

Achillies

Juniors
Messages
401
Reni is asking for a 100 grand payout from the dogs,is this to top up a smaller offer from souths for 09?
 
Messages
15,545
I would imagine that no matter which team makes him an offer in the NRL, it will be far smaller than what he was on at the Dogs. The only team's which could possibly have the cap space to make Reni a decent offer would be the Dogs cos they just sacked him and the Sharks if they were to sack Bird. Considering that Reni's manager mentioned they would have him sorted out by Christmas, I'd say that this rules the Sharks out because they won't sort out the Bird situation before then.

This 100k payout would have nothin to do with us and more to do with the fact that Reni knows he will be on a far smaller contract this year no matter where he goes in the NRL. There is still the high possibility he will go to England as well. Reni is just after more money and has probably had legal advice to tell him that he is half a chance of making a succesful case against the Dogs. That would be all that this would be about.
 

Ronnie Dobbs

Coach
Messages
17,344
I don't want JT sacked, I just want him to be fair to all of our team.

The future is bright for Hegs. Even if he gets cut he is at short odds to get the part of Ming the Merciless if they ever remake Flash Gordon. I'm pretty sure he's Ming & Dale Ardens love child - the resmblance is striking.

Shaun McRae to play Flash, obviously.....
 

Dave Q

Coach
Messages
11,065
One thing I do is call it as I see it. When he has a shocker I will say so and when he plays well I will say so. To me it seems as though no matter what he does from here on in people have their minds made up.

I'm not saying that he will be in the starting line-up and he wouldn't make my strongest line-up. All I am saying is that the treatment of him has been very unfair.

Paul probably wont admit it here publically, but its well known amongst the Souths LU cadre here that he is a genuine shadowy insider.

If he has formed the view that Hegs has been underdone, I submit to the panel that this adds additional weight to the pro-Hegs cause.

Those who have joined the pro-Hegs campaign, welcome, have faith, we will be rewarded.

Lets get behind all of the boys, all the hard working staff from Richo to the NYC gear steward.

When Souths finally man up, I promise you lads, we will bring this wretched game to its knees.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top