What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Sam Burgess returns to South Sydney

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,054
But old truth teller Rabbits20 assured us that souffs could easily fit Burgess in for next year.

Alien agreed with him as well.

Articles have said "reportedly" so we don't know if it's true yet.

Anyway if we lose McQueen and Grant as well to accomodate Sam I'm fine with that.

If you guys in the next 2yrs get both Hayne and SBW back then there most likely will be an uproar I reckon similar to the Sam situation.
 
Messages
4,604
Articles have said "reportedly" so we don't know if it's true yet.

Anyway if we lose McQueen and Grant as well to accomodate Sam I'm fine with that.

If you guys in the next 2yrs get both Hayne and SBW back then there most likely will be an uproar I reckon similar to the Sam situation.

You're a f**king idiot.
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
19,208
Articles have said "reportedly" so we don't know if it's true yet.

Anyway if we lose McQueen and Grant as well to accomodate Sam I'm fine with that.

If you guys in the next 2yrs get both Hayne and SBW back then there most likely will be an uproar I reckon similar to the Sam situation.

There is no uproar. Souffs would be over the cap if the NRL registered the contract for Burgess, it is as simple as that.

It's perplexing because it goes against everything truth tellers like you and alien told us. If the likes of you pair are wrong on a topic you know so intrinsically well then who can we trust?
 
Messages
15,545
Meh.

It's nowhere near as bad as you guys are making out.

If we have to shed a crab like Walker and a couple of plods like Tyrell and McQueen to get Sam back then so be it.

Cheap at half the price tbh.
 

The Pip

Juniors
Messages
299
Meh.

It's nowhere near as bad as you guys are making out.

If we have to shed a crab like Walker and a couple of plods like Tyrell and McQueen to get Sam back then so be it.

Cheap at half the price tbh.

Maybe that's true, but what happens if no club is interested in those plods like Tyrell and McQueen? Or if clubs wont pay for them in full - so I guess we have to subsidise parts of their contracts? So, how many do we release then - 4 or 5?, for big slammin Sam the rugby failure.
 
Messages
15,545
Maybe that's true, but what happens if no club is interested in those plods like Tyrell and McQueen? Or if clubs wont pay for them in full - so I guess we have to subsidise parts of their contracts? So, how many do we release then - 4 or 5?, for big slammin Sam the rugby failure.

Who are you calling "We"?

Are you a Souths fan now?
 

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,332
saying you've got a pretty big name signing heading your way next year, on decent $$ in the position that mcqueen would be playing in..

We signed Merrin long before we let Idris go and before looking in to McQueen. Merrin has nothing to do with it.
 

Pommy

Coach
Messages
14,657
I for one am more than happy to have a mediocre season in 2016 if it allows us to build a foundation for greatness in following seasons. Without Sam I wasn't expecting much for next season we weren't going to win the title with our squad but this gives us a much better chance in the following years. Of course this is just my opinion.
I fully expect GI to leave one way or another at the end of the season which will free up a lot of cap space.
People keep talking about the cost of Burgess being astronomical whilst Manly are paying DCE $1.2m a season after he did his U turn. Compared to that Sam seems like a Bargain.
Of course the usual wind up merchants and souths haters will say there won't be a future as Sam the Rugby failure is going to play netball in 2017, but we all know thats not true in reality and if there wasn't a cap everyone would want him in their team along with all the other greats of the NRL.
 

gallen23

Juniors
Messages
59
idiots complain about the salary cap then complain that some clubs have the best players. !!!

salary cap is meant to even the comp and move players around.
 

Parra

Referee
Messages
24,900
salary cap is meant to even the comp and move players around.

No it is not. A draft does that.

The salary cap was designed as a way to stop clubs from going broke. Sort of a big brother / communist type idea.

It was designed to work in conjunction with a draft. Not instead of one.

Only idiots suggest otherwise.
 

gallen23

Juniors
Messages
59
No it is not. A draft does that.

The salary cap was designed as a way to stop clubs from going broke. Sort of a big brother / communist type idea.

It was designed to work in conjunction with a draft. Not instead of one.

Only idiots suggest otherwise.

Wrong !

It still moves players around.... teams cant keep all the good players as there is a max they can pay....

dont you see all the players move around every year

how does cronulla get players if not for the salary cap.
 

natheel

Coach
Messages
12,137
Panthers have lost Idris without replacing him and McQueen is not in our budget now? We must have got Grevsmuhl for 2016 or someone else on decent money.

Thank god. I really didn't want McQueen.

The sudden pull out of negotiations from Gould with McQueen yesterday after Walker was released saying he's asking too much makes you think maybe they have got Grevsmuhl early. McQueen stays at Rabbitohs and maybe Grant will head to England?
 

Parra

Referee
Messages
24,900
Wrong !

It still moves players around.... teams cant keep all the good players as there is a max they can pay....

dont you see all the players move around every year

how does cronulla get players if not for the salary cap.

You are trying to make 1+1=3

Players move because the club they are at does not value them as much as the club they are going to.

The salary cap is about total spend on players in any given year. It has nothing at all to do with trying to encourage players to change clubs or to choose one club over another.
 

Latest posts

Top