What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Segeyaro Gate

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,959
We're happy you are happy. We might be happy too when , 2 or 3 of your top flight players get season ending injuries, ruining yet another year for the Pennies. But , we won't. You see we have class. You would not catch us saying we are happy for that player to have a broken hip, because Pentrith refuse to enter the modern era when it comes to fitness, training & especially, conditioning.

Haha it's to easy to upset you
 

shaggs

Coach
Messages
11,168
The way I read the situation is this.

Cronulla want seg, however not for $400k dead money. $200k maybe.
The Reasons for this I believe is this.

I think the club can see brailey in NRL before the season is out. A 400k transfer fee on a loose cannon for 1 year is a waste when you have the current NYC player of the year.

Any longer than that and we hold him back too long.
Seggy is not a 5 more season player. Brailey is potentially 10 plus.

As the off season has progressed and from all reports of his trial form, perhaps brailey has put himself firmly in the drivers seat. If not then we have Nu.

As the days progress I reckon the club starts to focus on brailey and moves away quietly from seg. If they get him without a transfer fee then great if not. Be done with it.
Focus on what we have.
 

Chimp

Bench
Messages
2,902
Leeds are pissed at him for saying things about 'being bored every night, on his own looking at the same 4 walls etc' as part of his homesick story - they went out of their way to make sure that wasn't the case and had either players or welfare officers spending plenty of their free time with him to make sure he felt welcomed and part of the club. He also pushed Leeds for a place of his own (he was originally house sharing with Brett Delaney), and Leeds got him a place of his own about 3 weeks before he returned to Aus. So for him then to make out he was left to fend for himself has been a bit of a kick in the guts - hence the being so stubborn. Whoever decided that angle was the way to go on the homesick front is probably responsible for the approach Leeds are taking.
I still think it's BS though - regardless of what he's done, how can Leeds say 'we're not going to pay you, you're not welcome back here to start earning, but we're not going to let you earn anywhere else without a fee' - they're holding him to ransom and that doesn't seem right as he now as no options to earn a living from the game for 2 years, in what is already a short career.
Surely if they're unhappy with his behaviour (not turning up for pre-season), then they sack him and sue him, not just stop paying him but still hold him accountable to the contract duration.
 

Frenzy.

Post Whore
Messages
51,471
Leeds are pissed at him for saying things about 'being bored every night, on his own looking at the same 4 walls etc' as part of his homesick story - they went out of their way to make sure that wasn't the case and had either players or welfare officers spending plenty of their free time with him to make sure he felt welcomed and part of the club. He also pushed Leeds for a place of his own (he was originally house sharing with Brett Delaney), and Leeds got him a place of his own about 3 weeks before he returned to Aus. So for him then to make out he was left to fend for himself has been a bit of a kick in the guts - hence the being so stubborn. Whoever decided that angle was the way to go on the homesick front is probably responsible for the approach Leeds are taking.
I still think it's BS though - regardless of what he's done, how can Leeds say 'we're not going to pay you, you're not welcome back here to start earning, but we're not going to let you earn anywhere else without a fee' - they're holding him to ransom and that doesn't seem right as he now as no options to earn a living from the game for 2 years, in what is already a short career.
Surely if they're unhappy with his behaviour (not turning up for pre-season), then they sack him and sue him, not just stop paying him but still hold him accountable to the contract duration.

^ this

It's more infantile every day.

Segeyaro should counter sue for restraint of trade :)
 

Pommy

Coach
Messages
14,657
Leeds are pissed at him for saying things about 'being bored every night, on his own looking at the same 4 walls etc' as part of his homesick story - they went out of their way to make sure that wasn't the case and had either players or welfare officers spending plenty of their free time with him to make sure he felt welcomed and part of the club. He also pushed Leeds for a place of his own (he was originally house sharing with Brett Delaney), and Leeds got him a place of his own about 3 weeks before he returned to Aus. So for him then to make out he was left to fend for himself has been a bit of a kick in the guts - hence the being so stubborn. Whoever decided that angle was the way to go on the homesick front is probably responsible for the approach Leeds are taking.
I still think it's BS though - regardless of what he's done, how can Leeds say 'we're not going to pay you, you're not welcome back here to start earning, but we're not going to let you earn anywhere else without a fee' - they're holding him to ransom and that doesn't seem right as he now as no options to earn a living from the game for 2 years, in what is already a short career.
Surely if they're unhappy with his behaviour (not turning up for pre-season), then they sack him and sue him, not just stop paying him but still hold him accountable to the contract duration.

He has plenty of options to earn a living 2012.... Sharks year needs a new rent boy.
He only has himself to blame for his current situation and it might be shit that's he is getting the raw deal for plenty of players doing the same but a line needs to be drawn in the sand. There has to be consequences to walking out on a contract.
 
Messages
4,499
Haha it's to easy to upset you
Im not upset. You are the one that is upset. Your continual bagging of Seg, has revealed a deeped seated resentment.
So instead of keeping it to yourself, you feel the need to go anon in a forum & continually bag a guy that is jsut rying to earn a living & gave his all for your club , broke bones, sustained horrible injuries & was treated like shit.
Classy stuff.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,959
Im not upset. You are the one that is upset. Your continual bagging of Seg, has revealed a deeped seated resentment.
So instead of keeping it to yourself, you feel the need to go anon in a forum & continually bag a guy that is jsut rying to earn a living & gave his all for your club , broke bones, sustained horrible injuries & was treated like shit.
Classy stuff.

Seriously is this guy simple or something?
 

Inferno

Coach
Messages
18,336
I wonder if they're unsuccessful whether Segy can go after Leeds/NRL for restraint of trade.

What is the point of suing him for breach of contract, what is the end goal, money? Getting him to head back to the UK and lace the boots on?

Leeds are showing they're willing to play hardball, hopefully Segyaro has a decent lawyer.
 

Chimp

Bench
Messages
2,902
I think Lyall is playing this very well - no comment, we can take him or leave him, we certainly won't be getting into public negotiations on his asking price...
Segeyaro and his manager have gone very quiet and Hetherington is still banging his drum, which to me would suggest he's not making the progress he wants.... There's another side story with this that Hetherington needs to win some brownie points back with the Leeds fans (after a terrible 12 months on and off the field for the team and a number of other projects like ground re-development fallong over, despite lots of communications from Hetherington to the contrary and driving people to panic buy season tickets based on a false understanding ground capacity would be massively reduced due to the re-developments that are no longer happening), and I think this is the vehicle he's using to try achieve that. He needs to save face, hence his very public stance on the matter.
 

Madsharkie

First Grade
Messages
5,026
He has plenty of options to earn a living 2012.... Sharks year needs a new rent boy.
He only has himself to blame for his current situation and it might be shit that's he is getting the raw deal for plenty of players doing the same but a line needs to be drawn in the sand. There has to be consequences to walking out on a contract.
I'd love to see if you had the same level of righteousness if it was something to do with Souths...
 

southland

Juniors
Messages
2,016
"What is the point of suing him for breach of contract, what is the end goal, money? Getting him to head back to the UK and lace the boots on?"

Agree. The point has been made.

Current situation - no one wins. Leeds start to look less about principles and more stubborn and vengeful. Seggy loses - no income, no football. Sharks lose - miss out on a hooker. Fans (both here and OS ) lose - no one gets to see Segeyaro's brilliance on the field.

I agree that Segeyaro is in the wrong for walking out on a contract. There should be a consequence but the consequence needs to be balanced to suit the deed. He got homesick and bailed out. Not the first time its happened or the last. Hell the games he did play for them were huge. Leeds should celebrate that and accept it is now time to move on.

Heigtherington should be sprucing Parcell if he wants to win fans hearts not banging on about Segeyaro...
 

Pommy

Coach
Messages
14,657
I'd love to see if you had the same level of righteousness if it was something to do with Souths...

I would be exactly the same. Players shouldn't just be able to walk out on contracts.
I don't buy in to the whole home sick, his life is so hard angle either.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,959
Well for a person who doesn't care about sege you are doing a lot of caring about it betcats

I'm just posting here because i know it bothers you for some strange reason. Anyway dw bout Seggy, Morts will be a great full time hooker, he's been waiting years for this.
 

Latest posts

Top