What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

#Sterling slams Parramatta halfback Chris Sandow as being overweight

Captain Rabbit

Juniors
Messages
15
I have seen every game that Chris has played throughout his career and I have got to say his performance against Newcastle was easily his worst ever. His defence is no better or worse than it has ever been, but why isn't he running the ball at ALL this season? He doesn't look completely fit to me. I think Sterlo has done the right thing...because that along with Kearney's comments after six games should definately shake him up. He will either step up to the challenge or turn up in Cherbourg - I reckon he will step up to the challenge. As is always the case, if you can string a couple of wins together, everyone looks and feels better.
 

Eels Dude

Coach
Messages
19,065
So Mannah says "It's upsetting" hearing someone in the media make a comment like that. No wonder we're labelled mentally weak.
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
http://www.foxsports.com.au/league/nrl-premiership/fox-sports-stats-investigates-chris-sandows-start-at-parramatta-in-2012-compared-to-his-2011-figures/story-fn2mcuj6-1226324959219

Stephen Kearney didn't want to answer questions about Chris Sandow's form last week, so Fox Sports Stats have come to the party. And they reveal that despite the hysteria at Parramatta, the much-maligned No.7's start bears a heavy resemblance to his first six rounds at South Sydney in 2011.

The Eels forked out a reported $550,000 for their marquee recruit based on his 2011 performances, but fans have been left pulling their hair out watching a disorganised and insipid side over the first six rounds.

Most fans assume that Sandow lies at the heart of the problem, resembling a shadow of the player who almost single-handedly carried the Rabbitohs into the finals in the latter half of 2011.

But despite the appearance of a player low on confidence and devoid of ideas, Fox Sports Stats reveal that Sandow endured a similar start last year.

The charismatic playmaker’s key downfall this year has been his defence – he’s averaging 6.2 misses per game, one up on his 2011 average and two up on his first six rounds last campaign.

Eels legend Peter Sterling, who rarely criticises players at his former club, vented on Monday by commenting that he thought Sandow was struggling because he is overweight.

Former teammate Michael Crocker, who came to Sandow’s defence this week, thinks that is a perception.

"He's a little nugget so it's hard to tell if he's carrying any, but it's probably more so that he's not taking the line on than anything," Crocker said.

"That's probably why (Sterling is) probably saying he's unfit. Chrissy is at his best when he's taking on the line and I don't think he's been doing that."

However, Sandow is taking the line on. He’s just not making as many inroads as he did last year.

Although he has taken the line on more over the first six rounds this year than at the start of 2011, his 30 metres per game is 17 metres less per match than at the same stage in 2011. And compare that to his 2011 yardstick: 50 metres per 80 minutes.

But for Eels fans wanting more from their halfback, here’s some stats to bring things into perspective.

Sandow has touched the ball more, run more, forced more dropouts, assisted more line breaks, busted more tackles and made more tackles this year than at the same moment in 2011.

And his line breaks (one), line breaks assist (three) and try assists (two) stats are no worse than his 2011 benchmarks.


We all know what he produced once he got into his groove last term, so perhaps Eels fans might need to be more patient as he adjusts to a team already low in confidence and needing to iron out their combinations.

“He's obviously under a lot of pressure being one of their major signings and one of their major playmakers," Crocker said.

"I think it's just a matter of them working on their combinations and getting comfortable with each other.

"They just need to communicate and I'm sure once they gel it's going to be pretty exciting.

"I think it's a high pressure situation, It's a lot harder for a half to go into a team and take over then it is for any other player.

"I'm sure the more he works with Ben Roberts and Jarryd Hayne and they get their combination right, I think the better they will be."

Yes, but Sterlo says he's fat :roll:
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,509
So Mannah says "It's upsetting" hearing someone in the media make a comment like that. No wonder we're labelled mentally weak.
I would suggest it was a PG13+ version of what he wanted to say. If he wants to be the next captain and all, having a bagging battle with a legend and TV commentator wouldn't be the best thing to do
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,290
Apparently Sandow is struggling with a knew injury for this weeks game. It would surprise me if he didnt play, but it does bring to a head the issue that we have put all our eggs in one basket as far as the 6/7/9 is concerned.

I ask the question, if he is ruled out injured who do we play in the 7?? McGuire? Burt??
 

natheel

Coach
Messages
12,137
Apparently Sandow is struggling with a knew injury for this weeks game. It would surprise me if he didnt play, but it does bring to a head the issue that we have put all our eggs in one basket as far as the 6/7/9 is concerned.

I ask the question, if he is ruled out injured who do we play in the 7?? McGuire? Burt??

he will play
 

cv8z

Juniors
Messages
1,712
Apparently Sandow is struggling with a knew injury for this weeks game. It would surprise me if he didnt play, but it does bring to a head the issue that we have put all our eggs in one basket as far as the 6/7/9 is concerned.

I ask the question, if he is ruled out injured who do we play in the 7?? McGuire? Burt??

McGuire is the backup 7
The coach said it at the fan forum
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
SK is being innovative for Rugby League and trying to create a new position.

sk is trying to evolve the halves play. 2 edge halves, a central half in mcguire and a roaming fullback.

btw hindy says its the forwards fault but sk sticks in casey to replace a forward.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,058
Parramatta coach Stephen Kearney has expressed disappointment at club legend Peter Sterling's attack on halfback Chris Sandow, declaring he is comfortable with the out-of form halfback's fitness.
A candid Kearney also blasted reports long-serving utility back Luke Burt wants out of the club and revealed he has the backing of the Eels board to continue as New Zealand's Test coach despite Parramatta's poor start to 2012.
On another difficult day for the besieged Parramatta boss, Kearney addressed a raft of issues headed by Sterling's claim Sandow is playing 'four or five kilos' above his ideal weight.
Asked if Sandow was overweight, Kearney replied: "We don't have an issue with that."
"It's easy to pick on someone when the team's not going so good.
"We need to perform better as a team - that's everyone not just Chris.
"In terms of (poor) form, he's not there by himself."
Kearney also denied veteran Burt, controversially dropped to the NSW Cup, was seeking a release to join Cronulla.
"Not that I've heard of," he said.
"He wouldn't want to go."
But Kearney hinted the 200-game veteran Burt was upset about being banished to feeder club Wentworthville.
He continued: "I'd be disappointed if Luke was happy playing reserve grade."
Despite the drama on and off the field at Parramatta, Kearney has given no further thought to quitting the Kiwi coaching job to concentrate on matters closer to home.
He said he will have the full blessing of the Eels hierarchy when he enters camp with the New Zealand team ahead of next week's ANZAC Test.
"It (quitting New Zealand) hasn't crossed my mind," he said.
"I don't have to do a great deal in the preparation and the lead-up to the Test.
"It's a pretty well-oiled machine.
"I am comfortable and the people that support me are comfortable."
Kearney's more immediate concern is a buoyant Cronulla at Toyota Stadium on Sunday.
The form of both clubs could not be more of a contrast but the Eels coach is refusing to give up on his side after five losses in six starts.
"There is life every day you wake up. That's how you approach it and deal with it," Kearney said.
"We find ourselves in a situation we're not all happy with and we've got to fight our way out of it.
"I'm trying to find ways to make our side perform better and for this group to perform to their abilities.
"We all need to lift our efforts."
Prop Tim Mannah added: "We are very embarrassed with the performance (last weekend against Newcastle). It showed we have a lot to work on."
"We've got to stick together tight and get through this."
http://www.sportal.co.nz/league-news-display/kearney-backs-sandow,-denies-burt-rift-171106
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,058
Sterling's Sandow call on the money

12/4/2012 7:32 PM
Adam Lucius

Sportal

There are plenty of people in rugby league who make a living as dial-a-quote go-to men, willing to hock their integrity for some air time.
Peter Sterling is not one of them.
Rightly regarded as one of the best players of any era, Sterlo made a seamless transition from the paddock to the small screen thanks to his ability to read a game, break it down and expertly translate it for his audience.
Outlandish comments or shooting from the lip is not his go.
He rarely criticises players and has regularly resisted the opportunity to sink the boot into the Eels, no matter how much ammunition they have provided him over the years.
So when Sterling, unprompted, launched into new Parramatta halfback Chris Sandow this week, it made for fascinating listening.
Not only for what was said but for who was saying it.
For those who missed it, here it is again:
"I think Chris Sandow is overweight," Sterling said.
"I think he's playing four or five kilos above what he should be paying. And it affects your sharpness."
"There's no way you can carry weight in this game ... or very few players can."
"Looking at him, I don't think he's fit. If he did (lose four or five kilograms), he'd be sharper than he is."
As soon as the words left his mouth you knew it was going to create a storm.
Here was Parramatta's greatest player bagging the player brought to the club as the next Sterling (yes, that tag has been used before) at a cost of $550,000 a year.
No one has forced Sandow onto the scales but you can rest assured Sterling's assessment is close to the mark.
Coach Stephen Kearney conceded as much in the way he avoided giving direct answers to direct questions on the subject.
Asked if Sandow was overweight, Kearney replied: "We don't have an issue with that."
Neither denial nor confirmation.
So is Sandow overweight?
This writer's experience in assessing matters of flab is confined to half an episode of Excessive Baggage.
But I checked Sandow's weight as listed in the official NRL media guide (80kg) and then ran the eye over him at training on Thursday.
Sandow is short and stocky so won't easily hide any extra pud.
He looks heavier than 80kgs but I'd be more worried about what is going on between his ears.
At South Sydney, Sandow was hard to handle at times.
Late last year he went missing for a few days before a game, lost in a world of his own.
A confidence player, the Rabbitohs were constantly pumping Sandow's tyres up to ensure his mind stayed positive and on the job.
Thanks to Sterling, Kearney might need to start pumping furiously.
http://www.sportal.com.au/league-opinion-display/sterlings-sandow-call-on-the-money-171137
 

Latest posts

Top