What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Superthread LXXIII: Honouring He Who Shall Not Be Named

Status
Not open for further replies.

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,644
Mick lives in TWeed, I dont know him all that well but I knew his brother a lot better, both were in the same board riders club as me a while back, Kirra Board Riders.

He's a mad leagie and a Penrith fan, he was born and raised in Penrith and moved up to Tweed later on.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,644
10451058_10153464534009889_1344022046948924656_n.jpg
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
103,487
There is absolutely no way it was a fourteen foot shark IMO. Sub ten foot I would guess based on the size of the dorsal and the tail and the distance between. It was a juvenile or sub adult great white, certainly under the 3.5m mark for a mature shark. It came in, checked him out, and got caught in his tail rope. White sharks are ambush hunters, watch how it just lazily pops up and then thrashes when it gets caught. It's just cruising, wants to know wtf Mick is and gets startled when it feels the tail rope.

A white shark attacks with a powerful charge from below, takes a huge bite out of the prey, and then waits around while it bleeds to death. Even if this was a curiosity "attack" or test bite, he would have lost a limb and probably died. They like to chew on something they don't understand. Behaviour wise, this is just a "bump" where the shark got a but more than it bargained for. Bumps can be territorial, or they can be a precursor to an investigative bite, or just a tactile response to something that gives off an unfamiliar electronic impulse. It certainly doesn't circle back, it shakes it's head to get free and it's off. If anything, by hitting it he probably made it seem like it was going to come again, because it would have thought it was still caught up and shaken again.

It would have been a reasonably pants shitting moment and any encounter with any kind of predator is potentially dangerous, but calling it an attack is why people develop the wrong idea about sharks and it really, really shits the marine biologist side of me
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
103,487
He doesn't need to teeth to attack some one, what did you think it was, maybe he was just trying to shake hands

Why did he bite through the leg rope if it wasn't an attack ?

Yes because sharks are mindless killing machines and never display any other behaviours whatsoever :roll:
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,644
Surfer Fantasy forums going into meltdown, some people have a funny take on what actually happened and why it happened. There are some images of the shark being there 4 hours earlier.

Meanwhile I had both Mick and Julian in my team and they split the points so needless to say I did pretty well out of the JBay result.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,644
Yes because sharks are mindless killing machines and never display any other behaviours whatsoever :roll:

Of course they dont but what has that to do with JBay.

I spent years surfing in white pointer breeding grounds in South Australia and in my experience they only attack when they need a feed. We used to see heaps of them but they were pretty well fed there and never really bothered us.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,235
There is absolutely no way it was a fourteen foot shark IMO. Sub ten foot I would guess based on the size of the dorsal and the tail and the distance between. It was a juvenile or sub adult great white, certainly under the 3.5m mark for a mature shark. It came in, checked him out, and got caught in his tail rope. White sharks are ambush hunters, watch how it just lazily pops up and then thrashes when it gets caught. It's just cruising, wants to know wtf Mick is and gets startled when it feels the tail rope.

A white shark attacks with a powerful charge from below, takes a huge bite out of the prey, and then waits around while it bleeds to death. Even if this was a curiosity "attack" or test bite, he would have lost a limb and probably died. They like to chew on something they don't understand. Behaviour wise, this is just a "bump" where the shark got a but more than it bargained for. Bumps can be territorial, or they can be a precursor to an investigative bite, or just a tactile response to something that gives off an unfamiliar electronic impulse. It certainly doesn't circle back, it shakes it's head to get free and it's off. If anything, by hitting it he probably made it seem like it was going to come again, because it would have thought it was still caught up and shaken again.

It would have been a reasonably pants shitting moment and any encounter with any kind of predator is potentially dangerous, but calling it an attack is why people develop the wrong idea about sharks and it really, really shits the marine biologist side of me


I love you.
 

Misanthrope

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
47,627
There is absolutely no way it was a fourteen foot shark IMO. Sub ten foot I would guess based on the size of the dorsal and the tail and the distance between. It was a juvenile or sub adult great white, certainly under the 3.5m mark for a mature shark. It came in, checked him out, and got caught in his tail rope. White sharks are ambush hunters, watch how it just lazily pops up and then thrashes when it gets caught. It's just cruising, wants to know wtf Mick is and gets startled when it feels the tail rope.

A white shark attacks with a powerful charge from below, takes a huge bite out of the prey, and then waits around while it bleeds to death. Even if this was a curiosity "attack" or test bite, he would have lost a limb and probably died. They like to chew on something they don't understand. Behaviour wise, this is just a "bump" where the shark got a but more than it bargained for. Bumps can be territorial, or they can be a precursor to an investigative bite, or just a tactile response to something that gives off an unfamiliar electronic impulse. It certainly doesn't circle back, it shakes it's head to get free and it's off. If anything, by hitting it he probably made it seem like it was going to come again, because it would have thought it was still caught up and shaken again.

It would have been a reasonably pants shitting moment and any encounter with any kind of predator is potentially dangerous, but calling it an attack is why people develop the wrong idea about sharks and it really, really shits the marine biologist side of me

Agree 100%. Sensationalised bullshit backed by general ignorance as to sharks and shark behaviour.

Scary? f**k yeah.

An attack? Nope.
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,971
Leaving Baltimore. Actually kind of sad.

i understand your unhappiness..

had you chosen to move to melbourne instead of sydney, the feeling you would have right now is one of elation..

so.. in effect you have brought this melancholism upon yourself...


shame on you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top