What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

SWANS v St Kilda

Morenito

Juniors
Messages
1,700
The match is finally here, well in 16 hours anyways.

Cant wait for it to start and hopefully the swannies can finally get back into that grand final and have another crack.
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
Hoping for a saints win and certainly believe (despite missing personnel) that they still have the game and the cattle to coffee scroll the gallant Swans.
 

lockyno1

Post Whore
Messages
53,348
Does anyone know the news on Hamil? Footy Show said he trained well! If you read between the lines, I expect him to play!
 

meltiger

First Grade
Messages
6,268
I'm switching to thinking South Melbourne will win.


If St Kilda's injuries are that bad that they have resorted to running Fiona out there tonight, they must be in a bad way.
 

raider_ktj

Juniors
Messages
604
GO THE SWANNIES!!! I'l be at work, so i cant watch the game :cry: hopefully theres a repeat on about 11pm ish.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Could be close but Saints to win with a slight chance of an upset, if Hamil plays, Saints by about 5 goals
too strong across the half forward line, and the swans defence will struggle to contain Gerig and Harvey
 

choc_soldier

Coach
Messages
10,387
This last quarter is F***ING FANTASTIC! Absolutely blowing the Saints away... where did this come from?!

We are into the grand final!

SYDNEY!!! SYDNEY!!! SYDNEY!!!
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
Fabulous win to Sydney who came home brilliantly in the last term to win comfortably in the end.

Disappointing for the Saints, who were luckless with injuries during the latter part of the season, and were found out with players clearly suspect fitness wise.

They're a brave side the Swans and there is no better side at riding its luck. Alas, I feel that's as far as it goes for the side, particularly as they will be without Hall for the big game next week.

I was really taken by O'Keefe, as I have been on numerous occasions this season, and felt he was easily best afield. Hall has played better games, and was a throwback to his old daft self with his needless punch on Maguire, but he did create a target for the Swans and will be sorely missed. Buchanan did a super job, as did Schneider in the last term. More than anything though, the Swans held the big trump card with their dominant ruck hand, which proved decisive on the night.

For the losers, I though Dal Santo was great in giving Luke Ablett a football lesson. Harvey also played well, and Gehrig never stopped trying. Goddard & Hudghton both gave what they could and Fiora did some nice things, but in the end they just missed key players and collapsed badly under the weight of suspect players being unable to run the game out. Ball was disappointing, and Hayes clearly not himself, but Guerra was easily the worst player on the field with his 1 possession shocker.

There'll be much to think about for the Saints over a long summer.

For Sydney, the immediate challenge will be preparing their case to save Hall. It would be inexcusable for the AFL to let Hall off given the line they've taken this season and the precedents that have been set. That being said, there's no way the AFL would want Sydney to take the field in a GF without Hall, so they may yet pull a patented AFL swifty.
 

choc_soldier

Coach
Messages
10,387
I dunno about Hall... I think it looked worse because the Saints player went to the ground. Not that I am making any excuses... but Hall may very well just get off. Let's just see.

History repeats itself though... Andrew Dunkley was in the same position in '96.
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
parra_panther said:
I dunno about Hall... I think it looked worse because the Saints player went to the ground. Not that I am making any excuses... but Hall may very well just get off. Let's just see.

History repeats itself though... Andrew Dunkley was in the same position in '96.

I don't think it was particularly severe, but it happened 40m off the ball, was clearly premeditated by Barry, and was a deliberate punch to the stomach.

It was the deliberate nature of the action and the accompanying fact that it happened so far off the ball that will have more weight than the actual impact of the punch itself.
 

Morenito

Juniors
Messages
1,700
If Hall gets a week for that thats rubbish. That old guy commentating doesnt like sydney much, you could just tell he has something against them.

As for the last quarter demolishion job, wasnt it fitting considering in the 2003 premil final against brisbane theye were down by the almost exact margin at 3/4 time and ended up losing by 40 but this time is was sydneys to win in convincing style!

Good work boys. One more win!
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Raider_69 said:
Could be close but Saints to win with a slight chance of an upset, if Hamil plays, Saints by about 5 goals
too strong across the half forward line, and the swans defence will struggle to contain Gerig and Harvey

boyo, could not have got it any more wrong :?
 

Morenito

Juniors
Messages
1,700
Quote:
Originally Posted by Raider_69
Could be close but Saints to win with a slight chance of an upset, if Hamil plays, Saints by about 5 goals
too strong across the half forward line, and the swans defence will struggle to contain Gerig and Harvey




boyo, could not have got it any more wrong :?

:lol: ..
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
Morenito said:
If Hall gets a week for that thats rubbish.

They've outed other players for less this season, so he has to go. It was old time stupid from Hall and I don't know what the flock he was thinking??!!

Morenito said:
That old guy commentating doesnt like sydney much, you could just tell he has something against them.

Walls always sounds like he has a beef with any and every side when commentating. I actually thought he was harder on the Saints last night though.

Morenito said:
As for the last quarter demolishion job, wasnt it fitting considering in the 2003 premil final against brisbane theye were down by the almost exact margin at 3/4 time and ended up losing by 40 but this time is was sydneys to win in convincing style!

A big difference between a full strength Brisbane in its prime, and an injury hit Saints outfit.

Morenito said:
Good work boys. One more win!

Don't think they'll do it, but I'd like to see it, more for the old faithful ex-South Swans fan base than for the new vogue Sydney one though.
 

Latest posts

Top