nothing personal phatman
Kearney played a lot more last year than this year millers.
i cant remember
how many games did he play?
Filiga, yea fair enough he never did anything but I was trying to fill my team.
Matua - May have been a known nutbag but people can change, he played for australia once and we could use him right now.
the fact is that he was a known nutbag and a huge risk
ricky rolled some dice and lost
Anderson - didnt set the world on fire but was a solid first grader IMO and again he is a lot better than some of the players in first grade atm.
the fire men are still safe back at the station
Wright - agreed.
Barrett - our win rate for the season is poor with or without baz, he has been one of our best all year in an injury depleted side.
yes
but the fact remains our win rate with him is poor and he has played the vast majority of games - we were gone before hius latest injury
Seymour - agreed but he was very good for us last year, this year a big dissapointment but I would have him playing ahead of Green this weekend.
again the club rolled the dice with a known nutbag and lost
what did he play? 4 games?
Caine - you know that bloke Steve Price ruined?
yes
but he aint exactly the top line talent is he
Selmes - Meh
Gallen - our best player
Toops - our second best player
Bird - One of x-factors along with kearney.
My point was that we are missing enough players to fill another team. No team in the NRL can win with their big names out. Look at the broncos the last few weeks.
Do you think if we had Bellamy or Bennett coaching us we would have made the 8 this year millers?
At least 8 of those guys would be playing for us this weekend if still with us or not injured.[/QUOTE]
and my point is that kearney and ross were missing the vast majority of the season last year as well
and that toops barret and gallen all suffered injury after the season had gone
bennet or bellamy coaching us - i think both would have picked the best sides available
i dont think ricky did
so if bellamy or bennet coaching i would say we would be contesting a low 8 spot rather than hoping the roosters loose the rest of their games so we can avoid the spoon