Team vs Manly

[hineyrulz]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake the snake
Funny how many people want Finch to be dropped...... What a waste of money!!

Come back Tim.

Ask him Hiney....

Ask him what, Tim Smith is gone and he's not coming back. The only reason i can see you are bring him up is to cover for the fact the you're Golden child is playing so poorly.

 

[Stagger eel]

Good one :lol:.......Who isn't?

but it's all about llleeeeeegggg driiiiiiive!!!!!!!:lol:

 

[woddy]

not a big fan of Reddy but didn't he play 5/8 in last yrs premier league GF for awhile? surely we have someone better FFS than Lowrie or Wagon

 

[Mateo Moi Moi]

1. Hayne
2. Williams
3. Inu
4. Ben Smith
5. Grothe
6. Kris Keating
7. Finch
8. Cayless
9. Matt Keating
10. Fui Fui Moi Moi
11. Hindmarsh
12. Wagon
13. Robinson

14. Luke Burt
15. Mark Riddell
16. Weller Hauraki
17. Josh Cordoba

Riddell to play prop/backrow & hooker.
Burt to come on, push Williams to the back row.

 

[sharks8601]

not a big fan of Reddy but didn't he play 5/8 in last yrs premier league GF for awhile? surely we have someone better FFS than Lowrie or Wagon

reddy has been one of your best backs all year. i wouldnt mind the sharks getting him for 2010

 

[parra pete]

Ask him what, Tim Smith is gone and he's not coming back. The only reason i can see you are bring him up is to cover for the fact the you're Golden child is playing so poorly.

The only reason I can see you are bringing him up is to cover for the fact, IN MY OPINION, your Golden child is playing so poorly.[/quote]

Have made a couple of changes to your post so I can understand what you are trying to say...

No, that is not the reason I brought it up..it was in reply to criticism of Brett Finch by JTS who is of the opinion Tim Smith would be a better option, despite the fact that he proved he couldn't hack the toughness of the NRL by chucking his arse in the corner and slipping over to the ESL (also known as "doing a Jamie Lyon")..

 

[Jake the snake]

but it's all about llleeeeeegggg driiiiiiive!!!!!!!:lol:

Ben Smith:lol: That's right.

 

[Jake the snake]

1. Hayne
2. Williams
3. Inu
4. Ben Smith
5. Grothe
6. Kris Keating
7. Finch
8. Cayless
9. Matt Keating
10. Fui Fui Moi Moi
11. Hindmarsh
12. Wagon
13. Robinson

14. Luke Burt
15. Mark Riddell
16. Weller Hauraki
17. Josh Cordoba

Riddell to play prop/backrow & hooker.
Burt to come on, push Williams to the back row.

Hayne
Grothe
Tautai
INU
Reddy
Keating
FOFF - Because their is simply nobody else
Cayless
M Keating
Cordoba
Huaraki
Hindmarsh
Robinson

Riddell
FUI
Oake
Williams

 

[TheParraboy]

BTW its pretty sad that you need to put the boot in still to a player that hasnt got a chance to redeem himself.. But its not ok to bag the New PP golden child!!!

Tim smith hasnt had a chance to redeem himself? :lol: ohh please....

I would have thought the club was very patient and persistant in giving him everything he needed to redeem himself. He couldnt cut it, was all too hard and left.

Im glad he left, moping around like a sad sack is not ideally redeeming yourself ;-)

 

[parra.letic]

Im glad he left, moping around like a sad sack is not ideally redeeming yourself ;-)

his bipolar may have had something to do with that though..

 

[BRAD BELLICK]

Hayne
Reddy
Inu
Tautai
Grothe
K Keating
Finch
Cayless
Riddell
Corboda
Hindmarsh
Huraki
Robinson

M Keating
Williams
Moi Moi
Manah

 

[parra pete]

his bipolar may have had something to do with that though..

And it has magically disappeared since he quit the Eels and moved to ESL..He actually intended stopping off at Lourdes on the way over..Did he?

 

[hineyrulz]

The only reason I can see you are bringing him up is to cover for the fact, IN MY OPINION, your Golden child is playing so poorly.[/quote]

Have made a couple of changes to your post so I can understand what you are trying to say...

No, that is not the reason I brought it up..it was in reply to criticism of Brett Finch by JTS who is of the opinion Tim Smith would be a better option, despite the fact that he proved he couldn't hack the toughness of the NRL by chucking his arse in the corner and slipping over to the ESL (also known as "doing a Jamie Lyon")..

It was past my bed time when i posted that ;-)

But my question still remains, why do you constantly bring up Smith in realtion to anything. Either as i posted it is to hide the fact that the great B Finch is going poorly or to rub into the noses of the Tim Smith fan club. But we can't comment on Finch even though he is still here FFS :roll:

 

[parra pete]

You say Finch is doing poorly..I don't think he is. It is a matter of opinion. You have yours , I have mine. Pretty weak old world if we can't have difference of opinion without be subject to a flaying. Freedom of speech is a trait of a democratic society.
If you are prepared to slam my views, be consistent and explain why you not take Jake T S to task for digging up the former golden child in his post with a 'come back timmy' plea - when he knows that T Smith has 'done a Jamie Lyon' and run out on his mates to the comfort of the cushy ESL, where mental toughness and defensive ability is obviously not a requirement.
It was in response to Jake's post that I dared to be critical of one of the greatest imposters and biggest show pony (i.e in my opinion) to wear the blue and gold in the past decade.
Mea Culpa, Mea Culpa, Mea Maxima Culpa..

 

[The Engineers Room]

If I had to pick a side of the players available for this weekend I would pick

1. Burt
2. Iwi Hauraki
3. Ben Smith/Talima Tautai
4. Joel Reddy
5. Krisnan Inu
6. Kris Keating
7. James Maloney
8. Brendan Oake/Junior Paulo/Jeremy Latimore
9. Matt Keating
10. Josh Cordoba/Brendan Oake
11. Nathan Hindmarsh
12. Wellar Hauraki
13. Chad Robinson/Daniel Wagon

14. Mark Riddell
15. Brendan Oake/Josh Cordoba
16. Fui Fui Moi Moi
17. Brett Blaker/Broderick Wright

These are dependent on injury, I don't think some are available.

But I would also have a more positive gameplan and look to have the outside backs running some inside lines.

 

[forward pass]

You say Finch is doing poorly..I don't think he is. It is a matter of opinion. You have yours , I have mine. Pretty weak old world if we can't have difference of opinion without be subject to a flaying. Freedom of speech is a trait of a democratic society.
If you are prepared to slam my views, be consistent and explain why you not take Jake T S to task for digging up the former golden child in his post with a 'come back timmy' plea - when he knows that T Smith has 'done a Jamie Lyon' and run out on his mates to the comfort of the cushy ESL, where mental toughness and defensive ability is obviously not a requirement.
It was in response to Jake's post that I dared to be critical of one of the greatest imposters and biggest show pony (i.e in my opinion) to wear the blue and gold in the past decade.
Mea Culpa, Mea Culpa, Mea Maxima Culpa..

Totally with you there PP. You are absolutely entitled to whatever opinion you want. No argument from me.

My only comment is why you have to shove it down everyones throat EVERY f**ken thread you can find. It is getting tedious mate and if you were a smart guy you would realise that and give it a rest.

Apart from that - I actually enjoy what you have to say most of the time!!

 

[Raudonikis]

If parras forwards were performing as they can and should be Finchy would be exelling behind that pack..no half can do his job when the pigs arent doing their job.. He is putting his heart into it every game but fighting a losing battle

 

[hineyrulz]

Totally with you there PP. You are absolutely entitled to whatever opinion you want. No argument from me.

My only comment is why you have to shove it down everyones throat EVERY f**ken thread you can find. It is getting tedious mate and if you were a smart guy you would realise that and give it a rest.

Apart from that - I actually enjoy what you have to say most of the time!!

Well said, that was my problem with PP. I'm sick of hearing about Smith, he is gone and he's not coming back.