What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The 2009 AGM Review thread.

eels81236

Bench
Messages
3,643
LC money might not be forthcoming in the future with its current financial situation. (as per Paul Osborne)

To my knowledge, none of them have ever said they couldn't guarantee the future of the Eels beyond 5 years.

Suity

Now It may be petty and immature to bring it up again....Even though you did raise it :sarcasm:....

PO can't guarantee The LC money will be continually forthcoming. We all acknowledge that without LC money the Eels cannot survive. So how can they guarantee survival beyond 5 years without guaranteeing LC money?
Sounds to me to be the exact sentiments of DF pre election 2009. He couldnt guarantee the LC money therefore guarantee survival. Me no comprende......:crazy:
 

Jodeci

Bench
Messages
3,513
Perhaps the agenda was sent out before the meeting and none of the topics were relevant for us hence why we didn't have a representative perhaps?
 

fish eel

Immortal
Messages
42,876
Now It may be petty and immature to bring it up again....Even though you did raise it :sarcasm:....

PO can't guarantee The LC money will be continually forthcoming. We all acknowledge that without LC money the Eels cannot survive. So how can they guarantee survival beyond 5 years without guaranteeing LC money?
Sounds to me to be the exact sentiments of DF pre election 2009. He couldnt guarantee the LC money therefore guarantee survival. Me no comprende......:crazy:

Given the AGM was for the football club, which do not run the NRL side, suggesting turning off the tap for the FC would not necessarily mean not funding the Eels in the NRL, would it?
 

eels81236

Bench
Messages
3,643
Given the AGM was for the football club, which do not run the NRL side, suggesting turning off the tap for the FC would not necessarily mean not funding the Eels in the NRL, would it?

I guess that is open to interpretation.
 

Haynzy

First Grade
Messages
8,613
I would also imagine that the money garnered from the memberships generated by the massive membership drive would seek to replace some of the LC grant.
 

parra pete

Referee
Messages
20,683
Perhaps the agenda was sent out before the meeting and none of the topics were relevant for us hence why we didn't have a representative perhaps?

As part of the NSWRL all topics SHOULD be relevant to the PDRLFC. It was the AGM after all.
 

JessEel

Accredited Media Releases
Messages
28,677
Not we, Jess, YOU would look after them..I have worked out that you are the 'go to gal' at CRL...:clap:
I am one person in an extremely hardworking office... even if you are not a fan of the people i work for....
 

eels81236

Bench
Messages
3,643
I wasn't there, so I dont know the context, where you?

I couldn't. I had a golf tourney on. I should have bloody went considering the way I "kicked" the golf ball around.
My brother in law went.... all he said was that nobody was "bi partisan" (correct usage of the word or not I'm not sure - his words) enough to take too seriously.
 

parra pete

Referee
Messages
20,683
I am one person in an extremely hardworking office... even if you are not a fan of the people i work for....

Oh, you get me wrong. I am a fan .One in particular, Dave Skinner does a great job. He has a real feel for bush football..and is what I call, a 'progressive'.
 

Sangreal 86

Juniors
Messages
689
I think Strider has already covered that, but I can remember that there was a great deal of press before the QRL and NSWRL board meetings that the issue of an independent commission was to be raised.



As above.



I will take you back to the first part of our Meeting today, the apologies, from Luke Burt and Nathan Hindmarsh for their non attendance. The NSWRL and or its CEO would make a representation to any Persons receiving awards, if Denis was to be made a life member then they would have been in contact to ensure his attendance to receive the Honor.

Now if in the normal course of that notification of the AGM, a member club has not RSVP'd to the AGM, and you are speaking to that Member Club's former representative about his attendance I would think it would be as simple as asking the question to someone who may well still have his ear to the ground at Parramatta.

I am quite sure the NSWRL informed Osborne and Hilditch (the clubs nominated representatives) first and did not receive a reply before trying to get a confirmation from a Non-Direct source.

But what is of interest to me is not just that Ossie and Ron could not attend but that task was not given to the Vice Chair, or any other member of the Board. Or could all 8 of them not attend this meeting about the games future?




I am reading with great interest Marks notes on the AGM. Unfortunately I had committed to a charity day for the Research Institute for Schizophrenia , and the Black Dog Institute with the Gibson Family.

A few points I would like to stress: Point 1.. I think you should all have a good look at yourself and pull your heads in, and put yourself in the position of your Mother with cancer. There are some things that take precedent over position or occasion, and for Ron not to be able to organise anyone, it had to be a very late call for Paul to pull out. The other thing that struck me reading Marks notes, is it sounds as though Ron had no idea of the Life Membership that Denis was to receive that night, and Ron has been a close friend of Denis for years. This is a situation of circumstances and I believe everyone is reading way to much into this matter.

Point 2... Andrew Hill fell on his own sword, he resigned....

Point 3...Denis running in the next election? I hope he seriously shuns the idea. Denis is etched in the history of this club as a player and administrator, and should be remembered with dignity and respect he deserves for the many years service he put into this club,rugby league and the community. Misguided agendas can ruin such respect, and I believe not in the best interests of this club, as Denis can offer an enormous amount to our community, and that is where he should channel his abilities. This club is starting a new chapter in its history, and does not need to go back to the future, and I say that with all the due respect it deserves, and although you may not agree with everything being done, explore these new concepts objectively, as this is an exciting new beginning.

Point 4...Congratulations to Denis on his Life Membership with the NSWRL. Well deserved
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,830
yep,

I don't want to sound like I'm nitpicking but I found it interesting that John Fenwick who was sitting at the same table and right opposite to Dennis made the point about Fitzy's life membership not being aknowledged because of someone not attending the board meeting and yet a few years back Fitzy failed to attend a funeral of a club legend and former director because he apparently had work committements.

some peoples priorities differ from others...

i thought ron was extremely sincere in his response...
 
Last edited:

fish eel

Immortal
Messages
42,876
Sevens, I think if Fitzy wants to be remembered with dignity and respect he could do well not to rant and scream into a microphone at AGM's as has been reported....
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,830
Sevens, I think if Fitzy wants to be remembered with dignity and respect he could do well not to rant and scream into a microphone at AGM's as has been reported....


unlike his former colleague who covered himself in glory...

in saying that, as a member he had every right to get up there and express himself how ever way he sees fit, if he did that infront of the former CEO he would of copped a gobful from him. :lol:

and that was the point that Mario Lbertini made when he asked members to embrace the membership change.
 

fish eel

Immortal
Messages
42,876
unlike his former colleague who covered himself in glory...

in saying that, as a member he had every right to get up there and express himself how ever way he sees fit, if he did that infront of the former CEO he would of copped a gobful from him. :lol:

and that was the point that Mario Lbertini made when he asked members to embrace the membership change.

absolutely, and if wants to carry like the reports suggest he did, thats how people will see him.

If he wants to at with dignity and respect, then likewise, people will acknowledge that.
 

Hellsy

Immortal
Messages
30,754
I also like Paul's praise for the state of the club he walked into, and his personal thanks to Denis. Now I know some may take it as slight sarcasm, but there was alot of sincerity in Paul's thanks and I think Denis acknowledged it regardless of the gripes he has with the board PO now works for.
 
Top