The question not Marshal/Reynolds? it’s Marshal/Brooks?

[Tiger05]

You only look at what we have in the bubble. Need to expand your thinking. And to be honest, are other teams really shaking in their boots about Lawrence, Garner and Chee-Kam? I don’t think so

I definitely think they are worried about all 3 of them. Did you see Chee-Kams run last night. How many players do that ?

Our edge backrow stocks are really good at the moment. We lack a Kikau but there is one of him in the comp.

 

[Tiger05]

Re making semis/winning comp our primary probs lie in no.s 1-5

Our edge backrowers are awesome. Our middle forwards are really good but I'm worried over the next couple of seasons. You need a lot of middle forwards and Packer and Matulino look to be at the back end of their careers.

I think our weakness is our 1-5 as well.

 

[WA Tiger]

Ok I didn’t see the page 2 and 3 ...I’m new at this ..problem is coach loves Marshall almost as much as I do..I think he will find a spot for him however he can ...but yip nothing more predictable than injuries

 

[WA Tiger]

I’m more a backs guy but ...re our forwards...I think we’ve seen that coming from Chee - Kam for a while. Your right I hardly notice or remember Matalino after each game...maybe one more kick A prop but everyone says that .. I thought the way our tempo was high until the end from everyone is what’s going to win us games. And the fact Brisbane couldn’t get through was no accident

 

[WA Tiger]

Who was man of the match....I’d say Chee-kam but could have easily been Brooks ...Brooks outplayed Farah ..well well ....the confidence he got from his running transferred to his kicking high kicks grubbed kicks u name it ...We needed that !!

 

[WA Tiger]

I can’t find it...must have been Chee-kam no brainer

 

[benched tiger]

MCK,Brooks,JR,Twal take your pick for MOM,they were all good in a great team effort.

 

[trevcogger]

Wonder where Lawrence fits in now? Maybe lock?

Lawrence might be a benchie , at best
Cant drop Chee Kam after his performance.

 

[trevcogger]

For mine it's Reynolds or Benji. We need 4 forwards on the bench.

Well its Reynolds for mine......Give Benji another week off.
Not sure if Chee Kam is a centre though,but hes in the 17 somewhere for mine.

 

[trevcogger]

MCK,Brooks,JR,Twal take your pick for MOM,they were all good in a great team effort.

3. Twall Doll
2. Chee Kam
1. Brooks/Reynolds
Not easy to pick..all played well.

 

[trevcogger]

Re making semis/winning comp our primary probs lie in no.s 1-5

Spot on Tiger Ted.
Need an injection of pace.......Might have to wait till 2020 for that though.

 

[trevcogger]

Garner has been great but he did miss the tackle on Nikorima to let the Broncos back in the game. I think Lawrence will start with Garner coming off the bench.

No utility on the bench. Needs to be 4 forwards.

Lawrence should play ISP Cup for a few games.
Hes coming back from badly broken jaw so he will be gun shy...
Needs to build confidence in getting whacked in the head again...Garner will make way when Crystal is ready....Chee Kam has the 17 jersey welded on for now.

 

[gordsy]

Not saying that Brooks played horrible but all this talk that Brooks played awesome last night for mind is crazy. I still say he still lacks energy and puts up for too many nothing bombs that put no pressure on the other team. Let's face it we were extremely lucky with that try to Cheekam. Not many other teams stuff up that bad that he scores. I still say that if Bird catches the ball we lose the game.

 

[trevcogger]

I think benji will be a better option at 1 than mbye, mbye the worst player on the field tonight, the 4 forwards on the bench are gold.

Mbye is going nowhere....Hes been earmarked as captain,so wont be dropped...
Your right though,he was our worst......took a few good bombs,but dropped one trying to do his superman impression.

 

[trevcogger]

Not saying that Brooks played horrible but all this talk that Brooks played awesome last night for mind is crazy. I still say he still lacks energy and puts up for too many nothing bombs that put no pressure on the other team. Let's face it we were extremely lucky with that try to Cheekam. Not many other teams stuff up that bad that he scores. I still say that if Bird catches the ball we lose the game.

we bombed a few tries too though Gordsy.
Brooks went ok,nothing special last night.
Up to his bad habits of hail mary bombs again.
Reynolds has a great kick on him,he keeps it low and into space....
He's showing his worth $$$$$$...2 games back and 2 excellent performances.Just what we need to motivate others.

 

[Tiger Ted]

Not saying that Brooks played horrible but all this talk that Brooks played awesome last night for mind is crazy. I still say he still lacks energy and puts up for too many nothing bombs that put no pressure on the other team. Let's face it we were extremely lucky with that try to Cheekam. Not many other teams stuff up that bad that he scores. I still say that if Bird catches the ball we lose the game.

Both our centres bombed tries.

We did deserve some luck for a change.We didn’t deserve to lose to pissant clearys team & we were robbed against the arrogant broncos @ Campbelltown last yr.f**k the broncos !!

Just hope Madge gets to display elation in the box on GF day one day over next few yrs while he’s coaching WT.

 

[gordsy]

we bombed a few tries too though Gordsy.
Brooks went ok,nothing special last night.
Up to his bad habits of hail mary bombs again.
Reynolds has a great kick on him,he keeps it low and into space....
He's showing his worth $$$$$$...2 games back and 2 excellent performances.Just what we need to motivate others.

That we did Trev. I think for a bloke who gets paid huge money and has played over 100 first grade games Brooks doesn't do enough to spark the side. His running game is great but we don't see it enough. The frustrating part is Reynolds has half the talent of Brooks but seems to squeeze out more performance that Brooks, which is concerning. You want the paycheck , you;d be better pony up with the results.

 

[The Charlatan]

Lawrence should play ISP Cup for a few games.
Hes coming back from badly broken jaw so he will be gun shy...
Needs to build confidence in getting whacked in the head again...Garner will make way when Crystal is ready....Chee Kam has the 17 jersey welded on for now.

I love Rowdy but his injury has unfortunately put him at the back of the queue. ISP until someone gets injured or stops performing.

 

[trevcogger]

I love Rowdy but his injury has unfortunately put him at the back of the queue. ISP until someone gets injured or stops performing.

Yes its uncommon ground now being able to replace like with like.

 

[WA Tiger]

Each of the 1-5 have had their good days ...I don’t know what happened to Mbye that’s the second time he’s tried to catch a ball like that just asking for a knock on..could have left it....main problem I think is Jennings...I watched his so-called great year last year on his video for Souths and every try was catching and placing ball over tryline ...big but so what...havnt seen him beat a tackle yet ...