The Ricky Stuart myth

[Miller was a legend]

Some people troll and some just have NFI.

No disrespect Parra fans, but its a shit squad developed by a shit coach who has been punted. It's going to take time to restructure.

 

[Someone]

Some people troll and some just have NFI.

No disrespect Parra fans, but its a shit squad developed by a shit coach who has been punted. It's going to take time to restructure.

most of us level headed fans know that.

whether or not ricky is the right man wont be seen until the end of 2014, start of 2015. No point bitching now.

 

[Aragorn]

Bluey had a GF squad. Kearney had a poor squad, which through recruitment and replacement decisions, he made worse. Its that simple.

Here's a comparison. Players in each position for Kearney's first game, Sticky's first game, and last weekend.

1. Jarryd Hayne..........Jarryd Hayne..........Jake Mullaney
2. Luke Burt...............Ken Sio..................Ken Sio..................
3. Chris Walker...........Ryan Morgan...........Ryan Morgan...........
4. Ryan Morgan..........Jakob Loko..............Wilie Tonga
5. Etuate Uaisale.........Cheyse Blair............Semi Radrada
6. Daniel Mortimer.......Luke Kelly...............Ben Roberts
7. Jeff Robson.............Chris Sandow..........Luke Kelly
8. Tim Mannah............Mitch Allgood..........Tim Mannah
9. Casey Maguire.........Matthew Keating.....Matthew Keating
10. Mitch Allgood.........Tim Mannah............Fui Fui Moi Moi
11. Nathan Hindmarsh..Reni Maitua............Darcy Lussick
12. Taniela Lasalo.........Ben Smith..............Daniel Harrison
13. Justin Horo.............Matt Ryan..............Joseph Paulo

14. Matthew Keating......Darcy Lussick.........Reni maitua
15. Shane Shackleton....Joseph Paulo..........Mitchell Allgood
16. Ben Smith...............Ben Roberts...........Peni Terepo
17. Fui Fui Moi Moi.........Fui Fui Moi Moi.......Junior Paulo

Only the front row and Morgan are common in all three. The first side is not great, but it's a damn site better than the last.

Sticky has bought Peats, Norman, Mossop and Hock. Kearney bought Whatuira, Chris Walker and Carl Webb

didnt kearney recruit the kid whose father liked to stick his finger up peoples A-hole? the name eludes me.

 

[Lambretta]

didnt kearney recruit the kid whose father liked to stick his finger up peoples A-hole? the name eludes me.

Will Hopoate? Yes he did - but you didn't need to be Einstein to work out he is a good player and Luke Burt was retiring.

 

[Aragorn]

Will Hopoate? Yes he did - but you didn't need to be Einstein to work out he is a good player and Luke Burt was retiring.

you're missing the point.

think harder. :roll:

 

[Loudstrat]

Some people troll and some just have NFI.

No disrespect Parra fans, but its a shit squad developed by a shit coach who has been punted. It's going to take time to restructure.

Certainly no disrespect in what you posted. Its the truth.

Us having a crap squad because of Sticky is like saying Manly have a gun squad because of Toovey.

Yet the same twats remember the affect of previous coaches when accounting for the 2002 premiership winners.

you're missing the point.

think harder. :roll:

Think harder? You mean "Its hard to think"?

 

[betcats]

Very good point, you only need to see what Elliott has done at the Warriors with the same cattle that McLennon had in 2012

Comparing a talent filled warriors team to the shit Parra has is a bigger fail then anything Ricky has ever done, and I don't even like Ricky or Parra lol.

 

[Lambretta]

you're missing the point.

think harder. :roll:

All I can think about is the whooshing sound made by the noise of your point going over my head.

 

[Utey]

Besides Bellamy...

LOL! :lol::lol:

 

[POPEYE]

You really are a dumb sh*t. Do you really think they physically hand out a spoon????? :lol::lol::lol:

That was Kearney. Sticky's got the results of his recruitment.

Of course, Kearneys abysmal seasons were also Stickey's fault, right?

Crikey mate, your problem is you're seriously trying to defend the indefensible, I'm just taking the piss because I can. You can't be awarded something that's not tangible, but you can claim Stuart is a shit coach exactly the same as you can claim Melbourne cheated the system, and only the system.

You do realise that if you didn't persevere with your protests most of us would go away

 

[Newcastlerabbit]

It will end in tears with Stuart,it always does.

 

[millersnose]

Sorry parra fans

We had to endur this divisive one trick pony for years and it tore the place apart

Ricky will never acknowledge Ricky can make mistakes

He is always the victim

He is the Julia gillard of nrl coaching

 

[Brutus]

Ricky is doing a great job at the Eels.

The players really want to play for him...

 

[whall15]

I'm so f**king sick of it.

 

[the_flight_of_the_magpie]

if Ricky Stuart was a ships capt he'd be this guy

 

[Parramatta1947]

Put Bennett or Bellamy in charge of this rabble and even they wouldn't improve it

 

[Delboy]

Unfortunately the biggest myth is the roster he inherited, friggin pathetic, perhaps 4/5 NRL standard players.

 

[hineyrulz]

Honestly tonight how many of these players would any of you blokes want in your own team???

Mannah would be about the only one, i'll give him at least next season with an improved roster before i put him in the fail pile.

 

[Michael Bishop]

Honestly tonight how many of these players would any of you blokes want in your own team???

Mannah would be about the only one, i'll give him at least next season with an improved roster before i put him in the fail pile.

I'd take Lussick back at the Eagles. None of the others though.

 

[Marshall_magic]

Unfortunately the biggest myth is the roster he inherited, friggin pathetic, perhaps 4/5 NRL standard players.

Agreed, he has told a dozen to look elsewhere and how many have been signed by another NRL club? None of the 15 other coaches in the NRL see anything in his players either. Without a doubt the worst squad since the turn of the century.