Timana or Inu

[2150_souLJA]

This seems obvious doesnt it. Timana has achieved everything in rugby league, while Inu has done nothing but score a few tries and kick some goals. In a perfect world you would want to keep both but in this world with the salary cap and Gallop the wanker then we can only keep one since Joel Reddy has the other position on lockdown..

For me, I would resign Inu to a decent contract and let Timana go at end of season. Because Timana is not the player he once was, what told me this was when he kicked through near the end of the game today and was one on one with wesser. The old Tahu would have picked it up and scored, but this one now looked like he had nothing left.

 

[Hutchy86]

he's still getting his match fitness up and adjusting to the pace of the game...
I don't think he's running around too badly on his old legs.
Inu needs to tighten up his D cos he's becoming a bit of a turnstile...

 

[bartman]

Wow... Tahu has his best game for ages (including Union) today, in attack and defence.

Inu... was found out in defence in the first half.

It's a no brainer at the end of the season... as long as Krisnan's passport is valid.

 

[hineyrulz]

Wow... Tahu has his best game for ages (including Union) today, in attack and defence.

Inu... was found out in defence in the first half.

It's a no brainer at the end of the season... as long as Krisnan's passport is valid.

Agreed, Tahu lifted the team big time with his defence, he looked dangerous when he had some ball in space as well.

 

[PB]

I like Inu, but if it was a choice between two it is Tahu and it isn't even close at the moment...

I think given the contract staus it is more likely Inu or Grothe.

 

[woddy]

Tahu for sure......but how many more seasons can he play

 

[fish eel]

IMO, it's more Inu or Reddy.

 

[akers]

IMO, it's more Inu or Reddy.

i agree,i would keep inu he suits our style of play IMO

 

[Djay]

Neither, I would rather we lose Reddy not that it will happen though.

 

[Joely01]

Inu or reddy..... INU

 

[2150_souLJA]

good to see Timana fire up today.

 

[2150_souLJA]

reddy stays.

 

[codger]

i thought Tahu was the difference today. he showed much aggression and will to win which is where we lacked the last 5 weeks.
Me thinks no Tahu no win

 

[PB]

Reddy is gold. If he had a winger who could defend and a half who could put him in a hole, he would be knocking down the door of Country Origin honours.

 

[Eels Dude]

I wasn't that impressed at all with Inu today. He makes good dummy half runs but that's about it. I get worried everytime cause he seems to want to offload in nothing situations. Tahu wins this battle easily.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Tahu will take some time, but he had a great game today. If we continue to play the off-loading game, he is going to put the fear into the oposition.

 

[Avenger]

Best thing for Inu to do is find another club. He was the worst on the field today.

 

[Brenno75]

How could you not pick Tahu, especially after today's performance. He certainly did a good job of shutting down champion.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

I don't was to bad, yes he let in two tries which should not happen. But he made some good metres ( 105 metres overall) but yes I would have Tahu over Inu

 

[jeff27]

no doubt tahu shut down the whole right side attack of the rabbits. if he continues this form, i reckon they should throw him in an origin jumper. the last time he played origin, nsw won their last series. :crazy: