Who are the biggest underachieving and overrated players in the NRL?

[toomuchsoup]

Tom Turdbo - he's fast but... nothing else
Jack Bird - love ya work brother!
Boyd Cordner - boring vanilla piece of plod
Josh Jackson - see above
Sharon Woods - just an absolute skirt
Anthony Milfdud - fast but just garbage
James Roberts - see above
Andrew Fatfita - fat, lazy, grubby, slow PTB's
Jarrod Choker - just a dud
Thurston - getting shown up now...

Or it could just be that Kayln Ponga makes everyone else look sh*t

Have you watched Fifita play? He’s one of the best props in the game

 

[OzDragon]

Have you watched Fifita play? He’s one of the best props in the game

....when he decides to put in the effort.

 

[mongoose]

Matt "next darren lockyer" moylan

 

[The_Shield]

Turned on him faster than the WCW crowd on Hogan being the 3rd man

Turned on who? I’ve turned on anyone

 

[phatnonphatness]

Brad Fittler.

1. L.p. ķ

 

[Barkley]

1. L.p. ķ

 

[JJ]

Cordner, Cronk, Friend and the headless chickens must be under consideration at the moment

 

[Penrose Warrior]

Holy shit, 'that player from my team' doesn't apply here. That hasn't happened in a while

 

[Sydney Knight]

England? He suffered severe home sickness after moving from Campsie to Breakfast Point

Robbie Farah maybe a lot of things but a underachiever and overrated is not one of them. Farah is at the backend of his career and can't get a run because the starting hooker Damien Cook is having a superb year. Cook has also attributed Farah mentoring for the season he is having.

I think Farah made a mistake going to Souths. I think he should of gone to England and get some decent coin and experience some new surroundings before calling it quits.

 

[Maroon4life]

After tonight points for overrated need to go to Thurston/Morgan.

 

[Griffoshark66]

Napa, Bird, JWH, Cordner, Moyza, Milford, Lodge, Junior Paulo.

 

[Rhino_NQ]

Holmes doesn’t look like a national rep try scoring record holder this year

 

[Travitoh]

After tonight points for overrated need to go to Thurston/Morgan.

Only Thurston. Morgan took them to a grand final less than 12 months ago.

 

[JJ]

1. Tom T
2. Hayne
3. Bird
4. Croker
5. Roberts
6. Moses
7. Thurston
8. Woods
9. Friend
10 Napa
11. Cordner
12. Jackson
13. Cartwright

14. Wairea-Hargreaves
15. Tamou
16. Cherry-Evans
17. Gladsby

 

[mozza91]

2 absolute myths right there. What do they even do?

Very little this year that’s for sure. I rate Cordner as a player but he’s gone downhill a great deal over the last 18 months.

Jackson is an honest club player who shouldn’t be anywhere near a Rep Jersey. Plus he makes way too many errors for a player that offers so little in attack. Kind of like Simon Mannering.

 

[Lambretta]

He can't be Matt Cooper levels of hog

Oh come on, the backwards running, tutu wearing, fairy back rower who played in the same Dragons team and then amazingly for NSW never offloaded or passed once in his entire career. What was his name again? Ben Creagh, that's him. Hoggy Hogface of Hogsville County, Hogsland.

 

[veggiepatch1959]

Oh come on, the backwards running, tutu wearing, fairy back rower who played in the same Dragons team and then amazingly for NSW never offloaded or passed once in his entire career. What was his name again? Ben Creagh, that's him. Hoggy Hogface of Hogsville County, Hogsland.

You forgot to mention Dallas Johnson. CEO of Hog's Breathe and ambassador for Harley Davidson.

Even some Cowboys supporters called him Captain Araldite when he played for them.

 

[Cherry_poppins]

Quality work

I'm in tears

 

[Sphagnum]

You forgot to mention Dallas Johnson. CEO of Hog's Breathe and ambassador for Harley Davidson.

Even some Cowboys supporters called him Captain Araldite when he played for them.

I remember him going hard in a game and sterlo talking him up like he was the best ever. Next minute he went into a tackle the wrong way and was knocked senseless.

Happened about 4 games in a row. Sterlo talking him up, knocked out in the next tackle.

That merkin is a mock. No wonder parra hasn't won anything for decades. He is cursed.

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Oh come on, the backwards running, tutu wearing, fairy back rower who played in the same Dragons team and then amazingly for NSW never offloaded or passed once in his entire career. What was his name again? Ben Creagh, that's him. Hoggy Hogface of Hogsville County, Hogsland.

Probably why he finished up at prop.