Who was better ?

[Loudstrat]

Randall. He was sane.

Cheif or Spud?

 

[Loudstrat]

I never saw Simms but his legacy is legend. Best field goal exponent ever - and a toe poker (no Antitwat, Benji's fg was not the only one ever!)

Speaking of field goals, Shaun Timmins or Nathan Cayless?

 

[typicalfan]

I never saw Simms but his legacy is legend. Best field goal exponent ever - and a toe poker (no Antitwat, Benji's fg was not the only one ever!)

Speaking of field goals, Shaun Timmins or Nathan Cayless?

Timmins for sure but Cayless had the i didn't know you could kick factor.



Robbie Kearns or Michael Vella

 

[ANTiLAG]

Villa Vella didn't produce that many good vintages. And the real kick...

How many props are brilliant when they start and then get steadily worse?

Robbie Kearns greatest highlight was reducing GB down to 12 - but still - he was a solid consistent player over a decent period. I gotta go with him well clear of Vella.

 

[anjado]

better forward pack

Balmain 89

Roach
Elias
Edmed
McGuire
Sironen
Pearce

Penrith 89

Gerrard
Simmons
Kelly
Geyer
Cartwright
Chris Mortimer

 

[anjado]

double post

 

[Moffo]

Tigers by the length of the flemington track

Hoppa vs faafili

 

[Noa]

faafili if only for less headaches

ellery hanley or laurie daley

 

[Moffo]

hanley had more pure brilliance but you'd have to say daley overall

justin hodges or dale shearer

 

[Tommy Smith]

Hodges. When he's not being a dickhead (and injured) he's been arguably the best 3/4 in the game over the last 8 years collectively.

For those that saw them:

Steve Rogers vs Mick Cronin

 

[snoozer]

sludge for sure.

dallas donnelly v geoff robinson

 

[Loudstrat]

Crow was better kicking and setting up his wingers.

Dallas - test prop vs dogs benchie/

Now - pay attention.

CHIEF OR SPUD????

 

[anjado]

Harragon i think he was slightly better, and more intimidating.

It's a shame we don't see clashes like this anymore they were awesome. smashing each other proving who was the better man on the day.

Slightly morbid question

who would of had a better career if they had lived .

Ben Alexander or James Matthews.

 

[Loudstrat]

Probbly Ben, because he was with a very strong club getting set for a long run as a powerhouse.

MG or SBW?

 

[anjado]

SBW is one of the most talented footballers i have ever seen, but didn't play enough. Geyer was great from 88-92 especially 1991 when he was an awesome enforcer in club and rep level.

i will take MG just SBW easily if he played for longer.

Alan Mcindoe or Brett Dallas

 

[Brutus]

SBW is one of the most talented footballers i have ever seen, but didn't play enough. Geyer was great from 88-92 especially 1991 when he was an awesome enforcer in club and rep level.

i will take MG just SBW easily if he played for longer.

Alan Mcindoe or Brett Dallas

Dallas - better at busting tackles

Terry Butler or Steve Stacey

 

[webbland]

terry stacey

terry randall v ray higgs v fred pagano

 

[Brutus]

terry stacey

terry randall v ray higgs v fred pagano

Adrian Higgs

Shaun Edwards v Andy Gregory

 

[Moffo]

tough one

andy gregory

cliff lyons or steve menzies

 

[dontmakemeangry]

better forward pack

Balmain 89

Roach
Elias
Edmed
McGuire
Sironen
Pearce

Penrith 89

Gerrard
Simmons
Kelly
Geyer
Cartwright
Chris Mortimer

Close call....Penrith just.