Who was better ?

[anjado]

Royce Simmons he got chosen over Mario for rep sides, Both pretty similair Mario was a great player it's a shame he is more remembered for being the but of all jokes on the footy show.

Luke Patten or Michael Potter

 

[saint_marto88]

Michael Potter. Luke Patten is hopeless.

Nathan Blacklock or Manu Vatuvei

 

[_Johnsy]

Blacklock

he used his natural skill & speed to beat a defender. manu uses & relies on his size.

mannah or douglas

 

[Allstar Knights]

Blacklock

he used his natural skill & speed to beat a defender. manu uses & relies on his size.

mannah or douglas

Both completely different players, ones more of a workhorse and the other is more of an impact player. But I'd go Mannah

Uate or Vatuvei?

 

[ANTiLAG]

Vatuvei - speed, skill in the air and size.

Okay

Tuiaki or Uate?

 

[anjado]

I'm going for Uate on the back of Tuiaki being out for so long, next 2 years will go a long way to determining who is better.

David Gillespie or Les Davidson

 

[Loudstrat]

lol Offiah was a pathetic winger....overrated he was simply on the end of a super Wigan backline. In the NRL it isnt even close.

Dead Heat. Both played zero NRL games.

Cement. Better choice of clubs to win a premiership at with Canterbury an Manly. Davidson, never had a hope.

Again - Mick Liubinskas or Geoff Foster?

 

[ANTiLAG]

Geoff Foster. Longer career and less interchange stuff ups.

St George or St George-Illawarra?

 

[Brutus]

Gavin Robertson vs Michael Slater

pass..

John Plath v Phillip Lee

 

[Big Pete]

John Plath, actually starred in a few games where as Lee always showed potential, just never realised it.

Robbie Farah vs. Michael Ennis

 

[anjado]

Robbie Farah pretty easily in my opinion.

Gary Freeman or Greg Alexander

 

[Brutus]

Robbie Farah pretty easily in my opinion.

Gary Freeman or Greg Alexander

Brandy was a gifted footballer while Freeman was an ultra competitive niggly thug. Brandy easy.

Greg Dowling v Peter Tunks

 

[Loudstrat]

Tunks. Nicer hair

Reg Gasnier or Ben Kusto?

 

[anjado]

I would go with Greg Dowling i think he achieved more in Origin and Test level.

Danny Buderus or Benny Elias

 

[anjado]

Reg Gasnier just

Ben Csizlowski or Don Tweddle

 

[Loudstrat]

Tweddle.Easier to spell.

Justin Hodges at Brisbane or Justin Hodges at Easts?

 

[Big Pete]

Hodges at Brisbane easily. Comparing 2002-03 would be interesting but I'd say his form for the Broncos from 2005-07 would have that covered.

Brent Tate vs. Matt Cooper

 

[Brutus]

Hodges at Brisbane easily. Comparing 2002-03 would be interesting but I'd say his form for the Broncos from 2005-07 would have that covered.

Brent Tate vs. Matt Cooper

Tate by a chin.

Bruce "Bruiser" Clark v Bruce "The Sloth" Gibbs

 

[Loudstrat]

Tate - has done some real special stuff over the years.

Arko or Bullfrog?

 

[Stagger eel]

Tate - has done some real special stuff over the years.

Arko or Bullfrog?

both scheming manipulators but I would have to lean towards Bullfrog, only just..

by the way, both never completely got their own way as Arko missed out on Lewis when he was pratically signed sealed and delivered while Bullfrog allowed Fearnely to steal Cronin when he agreed to come to the dogs.