Who was better ?

[anjado]

since big pete hasn't nominated anyone.

Dallas Johnson or Gary Larson

 

[Borat.]

Thuggdogg or Sando??

 

[Red&BlackBear]

since big pete hasn't nominated anyone.

Dallas Johnson or Gary Larson

Lars for sure. He was consistent and played longer therefore accomplishing more. DJ might yet surpass him but needs more time.

Darren Albert or Brett Dallas

 

[Big Pete]

That is a tough one! Dallas because of his 95 Origin series, that's the only thing that splits them for me.

Billy Slater or Anthony Minichiello.

 

[Borat.]

Slater > Mini... Slater at his peak for longer...

If Mini had an injury free career I'd have Slater just....best defensive fullback I've ever seen...probably close to the best in attack also..

 

[anjado]

Borat didn't add one

So battle of the unlucky not to play for NSW props

Luke Davico or John Skandalis

 

[axl rose]

Skandalis tough as nails. Davico injury prone.

Backdoor Benny vs Boxhead Walters

 

[Ram Man]

Benny just IMO, a little more creative, probably attribute Benny for the change in the way a hooker plays the game.

Paul Harrogan or Mark Carroll

 

[carcharias]

walters was better


Jared anderson - Luke Covel

 

[muzby]

luke covell, purely because of his kicking..

les kiss or craig makepeace?

 

[anjado]

Chief for earlier and Les Kiss since he played for Australia.

Cliff Lyons or Terry Lamb

 

[muzby]

lyons..


jody rudd or nigel roy?

 

[beave]

christ Muz, you are bringing up all the blue chip players there mate!!!

 

[Brutus]

deleteathon

 

[Brutus]

Nigel Roy was a ranga and had a man's name so he was better than Rudd.

Billy Noke or Steve Hardy

 

[muzby]

graving, purely because he started earlier...

matt seers or david riolo?

 

[to_ddeath]

Sorry was going to have a go at this. Muzbys upping the ante :lol: so I'm out............


T.

 

[Brutus]

graving, purely because he started earlier...

matt seers or david riolo?

Yes, Grant Graving v Shane Duffy was my original post which disappeared then came back then disappeared again.

Duffy actually started earlier (in 88), but Graving did score 2 tries on debut against Penrith in 89.

Matt Seers, purely for his pace, although he was chased down once or twice. Can't go for Riolo - he's now enticing people to play AFL.

Noel Cleal v Nathan Hindmarsh

 

[muzby]

hindmarsh, seems the more complete player...


michael weyman vs darren fritz

 

[Brutus]

hindmarsh, seems the more complete player...


michael weyman vs darren fritz

Fritz was good in short bursts and had a great mullet, but never reached the heights predicted.

Weyman.

Alan McIndoe v Ricky Walford.