Who was better ?

[Von]

Kennedy for his longevity (Raiders, Knights, Manly) but both at their absolute prime, I would say Mason.

(sorry for sitting on the fence)


Bill Harrigan or Greg Hartley?

 

[Loudstrat]

Kennedy - he reached his potential and stayed there.

Spud or Chief?

 

[typicalfan]

Kennedy for his longevity (Raiders, Knights, Manly) but both at their absolute prime, I would say Mason.

(sorry for sitting on the fence)


Bill Harrigan or Greg Hartley?

Harrigan. Far more annoying.

I thought Chief was better than Spud as well Loudy.

Ken Nagas or John Hopoate.

 

[Von]

Nagas; had the ability to pull up his pants and score a try.
Hopoate was only worried about pulling others pants down!


North Sydney Oval or Henson Park?

 

[Desert Qlder]

Haven't been to either but NSO looks the most appealling.

Steve Jackson or Mark Hohn?

 

[typicalfan]

Nagas; had the ability to pull up his pants and score a try.
Hopoate was only worried about pulling others pants down!


North Sydney Oval or Henson Park?

North Sydney is one of my fav grounds, still love watching the occasional limited overs cricket match there

Andrew Gee or John Lomax

 

[typicalfan]

Haven't been to either but NSO looks the most appealling.

Steve Jackson or Mark Hohn?

Mark Hohn except for that moment in 1989.

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

North Sydney Oval has the bonus of cricket. That's the edge.

Mark Geyer vs Ian Roberts

 

[Von]

Steve Jackson...for THAT try in the 89 Grand Final.

and Ian Roberts

Warriors wing battle:
Francis Meli or Manu Vatuvei

 

[Desert Qlder]

Roberts for not being a knob, Gee for being a knob and vatuvei cause he's just a beast.

Jonathon Docking or Paul Hauff?

 

[Desert Qlder]

Double

 

[typicalfan]

Roberts for not being a knob, Gee for being a knob and vatuvei cause he's just a beast.

Jonathon Docking or Paul Hauff?

To be honest I felt Hauff was underrated but still Docking slightly

Wiki or Thorn

 

[Desert Qlder]

Wiki was a leader and this counts for a lot, Thorn seems more the follower but achieved much more. Tough one but I'll tak take Wiki by a whisker.

Phil Blake or Jason Taylor?

 

[typicalfan]

Wiki was a leader and this counts for a lot, Thorn seems more the follower but achieved much more. Tough one but I'll tak take Wiki by a whisker.

Phil Blake or Jason Taylor?

Blake would have played for Australia if he played today. He would have made the 14 jersey his own. Taylor a good club halfback but that is it, although he was a better organiser Blake was the better player.


Michael Witt or Grant Rovelli

 

[Moffo]

Well one was a 2nd rower and the other a front rower.

David Furner was a fanastic player (not so much a coach). Played a lot of footy for NSW and Australia.

Brett Mullins or Anthony Minichiello?

um, no. both played the majority of their career in the second row

 

[gUt]

Blake would have played for Australia if he played today. He would have made the 14 jersey his own. Taylor a good club halfback but that is it, although he was a better organiser Blake was the better player.


Michael Witt or Grant Rovelli

hah. I think Witt was underrated and he did some good things. Rovelli is pure knob cheese and shouldn't be allowed to hang around with footballers.

Nathan Fien or Michael Ennis.

 

[mozza91]

hah. I think Witt was underrated and he did some good things. Rovelli is pure knob cheese and shouldn't be allowed to hang around with footballers.

Nathan Fien or Michael Ennis.

Ennis is more of an attacking threat, Fien is solid but not as dangerous as Ennis.

Mitchell Pearce or Peter Wallace?

 

[gypsy]

Ennis is more of an attacking threat, Fien is solid but not as dangerous as Ennis.

Mitchell Pearce or Peter Wallace?

Pearce. He adds a bit more spark, Wallace is very reliable but I think Pearce brings more to a team. Plus he's not a ranga.

Noel Goldthorpe or Paul Green?

 

[attamarrap]

Pearce. He adds a bit more spark, Wallace is very reliable but I think Pearce brings more to a team. Plus he's not a ranga.

Noel Goldthorpe or Paul Green?

I'd have to say paul green


marty bella or mark tookey

 

[typicalfan]

I'd have to say paul green


marty bella or mark tookey

Marty Bella with ease. Tookey was a gimmick nothing more.

Nathan Hindmarsh or Craig Fitzgibbon