Who Would Win?

[Bumble]

Team A:

Inglis

Merritt
Walker
Champion
Goodwin

Sutton
Reynolds

Asotasi
Luke
Lima
McQueen
Te'o
S.Burgess

G.Burgess
Tyrrell
Clark
Peats

---

Team 2

Hayne

B.Morris
J.Morris
Jennings
Ferguson

Maloney
Pearce

Tamou
Farah
Gallen
Lewis
Hoffman
Bird

Fifita
Gidley
Watmough
Merrin


---

I think Team 1 has a far stronger spine and a better forward pack. Team 2 has better centres and interchange. Wingers are all decent, Merritt the best of the four though.

Would be a close one but I reckon Team 1 would take it by 6-8 points.

Discuss.

 

[StormHi]

To many wabbitwoes in the 1st side they are bound to choke so 2nd team wins

 

[Tom Shines]

Need more Souffs players.

 

[the dude]

Solid analysis.

We've got it over them in the halves and Inglis will be good for 2 tries.

 

[ek999]

Seeing as though Inglis and S Burgess are the only two players in Team A that would be good enough to make Team B I'm going to say Team B by about 40

 

[Son of Minto]

Team 2's tries would all be conceded through Meritt

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

Team 2 has better halves, better forwards, better backs and Kurt Gidley. They win by 27

 

[cleary89]

haha almost as bad as the would the 2010 dragons beat qld thread. But at least that one had one or two decent points. Like having 7 players playing origin and the best coach of all time.

Souths have 1 and haven't even made a GF let alone won 1.

 

[BranVan3000]

Team 1 has better spine

Team 2 has better props and a better bench and better outside backs. You know you have a pretty good forqward pack if you have Watmong coming off the bench

Gotta go with Team 2, but it would be a good game. Team 2 would dominate the ruck, but Team 1 would still cause plenty of damage. In a legitimate contest, team one would be a lot better coached so that would be a factor to

P.S. stupid thread.

 

[BranVan3000]

A better question would be, would Melbourne Storm beat NSW? I think they would

 

[firechild]

A better question would be, would Melbourne Storm beat NSW? I think they would

Which team does Hoffman play for? Or do they have to clone him?

 

[ek999]

I don't the quality of their spine over NSW isn't enough to counter the fact that NSW would completely dominate in all other areas. NSW would win by at least 20

 

[BranVan3000]

I don't the quality of their spine over NSW isn't enough to counter the fact that NSW would completely dominate in all other areas. NSW would win by at least 20

Who knows. The football might not even get to other players with Gallen taking every hit up :lol:

 

[the dude]

Fullback
Advantage Team A

Wingers
Equal

Centres
Advantage Team B

Halves
Advantage Team A

Hooker
Advantage Team A

Props
Advantage Team B

Second Row
Equal

Bench
Advantage Team B


In summary, very even.

Inglis, the Burgess boys and our superior Halves would prove the difference.

 

[Allstar Knights]

Any wonder people lol@50uffs and their fans ffs.

Team 2 by the length of the straight.

 

[Timmah]

Bumble... this is Bunniesman level butthurt you're exhibiting...

 

[simmo1]

Apart from Inglis and S.Burgess, NSW wins every match-up and pretty comfortably too.

 

[Different kind of Rabbit]

Bumble... this is Bunniesman level butthurt you're exhibiting...

Agree

Apart from Inglis and S.Burgess, NSW wins every match-up and pretty comfortably too.

Correction - Reynolds > Pearce

Apart from that, I think you are correct.

 

[Bumble]

Team 2's tries would all be conceded through Meritt

I agree, team 2 would concede a lot of tries due to Merritt.

 

[Bumble]

Bumble... this is Bunniesman level butthurt you're exhibiting...

I wouldn't know Tim Tam, he's been on my ignore list for months