Well when he was an eel, he played in a winning team. Now he is a seagle he plays in a losing one.
Clearly it is Manly's fault NSW lose. You give the NSW team so much. Wolfman, Stewarts, Buhrer, Lyon, King and Perry. Watmough may be an exception in 2005 - but now - NSW lost that game.
Kite when playing for ST George played like a champ in origin. Since moving to Manly he was limp.
You can go through history too, Krilich, Phil Daley, Hasler, Lyons, OConnor all Origin losers overall at Manly.
It is a relevant trend.
The only exceptions are probably Roberts, Toovey and maybe Terry Hill.
I hate Manly. Bring back the Bears.
Edit: Cleal was probably more a dead heat.