What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

You know you just have to admit it.

Quigs

Immortal
Messages
34,774
If you follow rugby league then in my opinion you have just got to admit that the Pennies are one of the greatest sides ever. I know I am and I have followed league closely for well over 56 years.

To win four in a row is just amazing in this era of the Salary Cap.

Every year after winning the Panthers have lost players because of the cap yet they just bounce back producing another local to fill the spots. How many St Mary's juniors were in the side yesterday. Five wasn't it.

And this win and the previous three victories were in 16 / 17 team competitions.

When you look back and consider the great Souths side and their run of five GFs in a row (winning four lost in 69) back in the late 60s early 70s it was in a twelve team competition.

Look even further back to St George's run of 11 straight in the 50's and 60's it was a 10 side competition with unlimited tackle rule. (No 4 or 6 tackles)

Yep the Panthers are incomparable rugby league champions and most of us will not see a run like this again. You have just got to admit how brilliant they are and have been.

Pssst and I was going for the Storm.
 
Messages
15,064
Agree.
The greatest team I've seen in my lifetime. Good on them, the way their systems are makes it look like they'll be up the top for a very long time.
They have changed how clubs should be organised to get continued success.
Massive congrats to them!
 

Craigshark

First Grade
Messages
6,860
Penrith and Melbourne are so far in front of every other team at just the basics. I mean just the basics, holding the ball, catch and pass, kicking.. all the very minor things you get taught in under 7’s. Even captains challenge, they get it right almost every time, it’s not a toss of the coin. Then they throw it away at the end when it suits them to have a rest. It all comes down to discipline. I’ve never really thought Penrith's attack is actually that great. They just continually break down teams and then know they’ll score from tiring the other team out.
 
Messages
15,444
One of the biggest things that killed us this year was errors and discipline.

In the main you won’t see the Champion sides commit these sins.

We have a lot of recidivists in this team that need to sort their shyte out on those game killers or get the f**k out of the team. (One of them left this season. Good riddance.)

The problem is a few of them are our better players.

The other major issue with our team is that we have quite a few “confidence” players. FMD you have to play the game like a James Maloney and have a memory of a gold fish.

Do you see any “confidence” players in the Panthers side?

They stick to the plan and believe the plan will work if “everyone” is on board. It’s hard enough winning against the better teams when you have these “confidence” players being an anchor when they’re down on confidence.

Look at the players in our GF winning side and the majority of them were so damn mentally tough. If you don’t have that level of mental toughness you won’t win shyte ever.

Congrats to the Panthers they do everything I want with my footy team to do. Their fans are so f**king lucky.
 

2012....Sharks Year

First Grade
Messages
5,723
Yep freakish that they can lose players every year and still be pretty much unbeatable. And to think we all used to take the piss out of Gus's 5 year plan out there. Sure it may have taken 7 or 8 years but it's a f**ken dynasty.
 

DJDL

First Grade
Messages
5,368
There's no way around it, they're just too good.
As Quigs said, it's a massive achievement in this day and age.
As much as I don't want them to win, you can't help but sit back and marvel at how well-drilled they are.

Getting to that level is an almighty challenge.
 
Messages
15,444
Penrith and Melbourne are so far in front of every other team at just the basics. I mean just the basics, holding the ball, catch and pass, kicking.. all the very minor things you get taught in under 7’s. Even captains challenge, they get it right almost every time, it’s not a toss of the coin. Then they throw it away at the end when it suits them to have a rest. It all comes down to discipline. I’ve never really thought Penrith's attack is actually that great. They just continually break down teams and then know they’ll score from tiring the other team out.
The tactics were really obvious but the Storm had no answer to stopping them. They really worked Melbourne in the middle and gassed them.

Luai constantly tried to get quality offloads away to make them do extra tackling. 9/10 times he was successful because his aim was to engage the middle of the defence enough to commit to him but he had the ball in a good position to get it away and his teammates knew what was going on so they were ready for the offloads. He’d also crab along the line a bit to get players out of their normal positions and then get straight runners at pace to exploit spaces.

Cleary ran with the ball more than usual also exploiting space and he got the defence back paddling. The Penrith defence got a lot of negative metres with their tackling when the Storm was coming off their own line and they dominated the field position.

Just like how our 2016 team made Cam Smith tackle to death with over 50 tackles giving him less energy in attack they did the same to Harry Grant.

Plan executed.

Result achieved.
 

Frenzy.

Post Whore
Messages
51,177
The tactics were really obvious but the Storm had no answer to stopping them. They really worked Melbourne in the middle and gassed them.

Luai constantly tried to get quality offloads away to make them do extra tackling. 9/10 times he was successful because his aim was to engage the middle of the defence enough to commit to him but he had the ball in a good position to get it away and his teammates knew what was going on so they were ready for the offloads. He’d also crab along the line a bit to get players out of their normal positions and then get straight runners at pace to exploit spaces.

Cleary ran with the ball more than usual also exploiting space and he got the defence back paddling. The Penrith defence got a lot of negative metres with their tackling when the Storm was coming off their own line and they dominated the field position.

Just like how our 2016 team made Cam Smith tackle to death with over 50 tackles giving him less energy in attack they did the same to Harry Grant.

Plan executed.

Result achieved.
There's a lot more subtlety to what they do than just the obvious. If there wasn't they'd be a 50/50. 40/60 chance to be beaten every week because every team and every coach would have was to beat them

I hope Ivan Cleary writes a book one day and tells all. He's a flippin' genius.
 
Top