Manly/Storm fight

[Frank_Grimes]

Mistyshit now trying to justify Lussick, Stewart and Watmough's actions with "but he said something nasty".

Such a tard.

 

[Engine]

Injuries...is it me or has there been more serious injuries than any year I can remember?

 

[HowHigh]

Credit to Slater too for the way he reacted and helped Williams after it.
I don't like Slater but it was nice to see..

 

[Liddell]

couldnt happen to a better person

Im sure he didn't know she was your missus

 

[BunniesMan]

http://www.nrl.com/nrl-to-investiga...-gallop/tabid/10874/newsid/64457/default.aspx

The National Rugby League will investigate three key aspects of last night’s Manly v Melbourne match.
The first is the on-field issues that the NRL Match Review Committee will examine as part of their weekly procedures starting Monday morning.
The second relates to the NRL’s Football Operations Guidelines in regards to the sideline benches and how players and officials must conduct themselves.
The third relates to the overall conduct of the clubs involved.

"The Match Review Committee will begin its deliberations on Monday morning and the NRL Football Department has already begun its own investigations into the other aspects of last night’s events.

Some who have suggested the worst culprits will only get a week and that'll be the end of that aren't even in the ball park.

Both clubs are going to get fined. Blair and G Stewart at the very least have played their last games of the season. The four Manly blokes who charged in into the 1 on 1 fight 30 seconds after everyone was lectured about 3rd man in are in strife. So is any bench player who came onto the field just to get in a brawl.

The NRL isn't going to just give people a slap on the wrist for this...

 

[Honkiest_Honky]

If G.Stewart and Blair are both suspended then any player who stars in a fight here on in deserves the same punishment.

If a player is so ill diciplined to get sinbined then shows another act off ill discipline in the motion of being disciplined what other action do the disciplinary panel have other than more discipline? Special hearing, big fines and a few suspensions.

 

[Beachy Eagle]

Actually.
Hes 100% wrong
Hinchy is the instigator the first time and Stewart is the instigator the second time.

Wrong again mate, have another look, in the second instance, blair runs to catch up to him, has something to say and then grabs him by the jersey around the throat area, after that Stewart takes a swing and the rest is history....

 

[oval]

couldnt happen to a better person

You are a total fvckwit.

Best wishes to David Williams.

 

[M2D2]

Wrong again mate, have another look, in the second instance, blair runs to catch up to him, has something to say and then grabs him by the jersey around the throat area, after that Stewart takes a swing and the rest is history....

:lol::lol::lol:
Stewart swung first, Instigator.
How hard is it for people to grasp this?

 

[ceagle]

:lol::lol::lol:
Stewart swung first, Instigator.
How hard is it for people to grasp this?

So it is ok to go upto people get in their face and push them, whilst not expecting any retaliation? Yep, strong logic there.

 

[sting]

If any players are suspended for the finals series it will rub a huge question mark on this years premiership.

Just when I was about to come in and say this was the dumbest post of the thread.....

David Williams - broken neck. Puts the BS in perspective.

couldnt happen to a better person

....This f**kwit comes along. You should be ashamed of yourself pirie.

As others have said, credit to Slater for reacting the way he did. He's one of my most hated players and I think he's a massive grub but he definitely did the honourable thing this time. Well done.

Hope the Wolfman can have a successful recovery

 

[siv]

At Orange wasn't a team kicked out of the comp for a similar fight

 

[HowHigh]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rk83bOsoLOc

heres a decent quality version if anyone missed it

 

[M2D2]

So it is ok to go upto people get in their face and push them, whilst not expecting any retaliation? Yep, strong logic there.

With how quick Stewart swung the moment Blair touched his Jersey. That wasnt retaliation, that was premeditated.
Stewart was the aggressor. No smokescreen manly fans/storm haters will put up will change that.
Just like Blair wasnt the aggressor the first time. Hinchy was.

 

[simostorm]

Its generating a fair bit of publicity down here..the attention its brought to the game, maybe the NRL should be paying Manly and Melbourne more money than what they are paying Bon Jovi to sing that rubbish song..

 

[HowHigh]

With how quick Stewart swung the moment Blair touched his Jersey. That wasnt retaliation, that was premeditated.
Stewart was the aggressor. No smokescreen manly fans/storm haters will put up will change that.
Just like Blair wasnt the aggressor the first time. Hinchy was.

He wouldn't have swung if Blair hadn't grabbed his jersey and got in his face
It was retaliation

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rk83bOsoLOc @ 3:25 onwards

 

[sting]

Does dessy get the cash?

''No one expected that, did they?'' Manly coach Des Hasler said. ''It was uncharacteristic for both players that were involved in the incident. We'll let the current processes take place now. I'm pretty sure they'll deal with it competently.''

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...tle-assault-20110826-1jeto.html#ixzz1WCMxKbHD



Sorry??????

 

[ceagle]

I think I might go down to the cross tonight and grab hold of a few people, surely nothing will happen :roll:

 

[M2D2]

He wouldn't have swung if Blair hadn't grabbed his jersey and got in his face
It was retaliation

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rk83bOsoLOc @ 3:25 onwards

Oh yeah?
Have a look at who grabs the jersey first at 4:47 on the replay?
Oh thats right, Its Stewart.

I think I might go down to the cross tonight and grab hold of a few people, surely nothing will happen

Sure, Off you go. The forum will be better for it.

 

[Eels Dude]

He wouldn't have swung if Blair hadn't grabbed his jersey and got in his face
It was retaliation

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rk83bOsoLOc @ 3:25 onwards

It doesn't matter if he grabs his jersey or not. The onus goes on the player that throws the first punch.