What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

09 :: QF1 Fri :: Storm 40 Sea Eagles 12 @ Etihad

Qualifying Final 1 :: Storm v Sea Eagles


  • Total voters
    58
  • Poll closed .
Messages
220
Yep...will do. A tight game that Manly wins by 16...:roll:

You're speaking as if it couldn't happen. Manly are very good at scoring a flurry of late points after bashing their opposition for a large portion of the game. It happened in every finals game we played last season and you're team got the biggest dose.

I'll admit there was a time when Manly struggled to beat the Storm in recent seasons. You guys we're clinical and always put on a ton of pressure which we didn't quite cope with. Manly though have a ruthless quality that no team can match when they have their heads right. It's good that we get to face you guys in our first finals match as the boys will be well and truly pumped.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
The first of those scores was against a side without their hooker, captain and best 2nd rower.

The second was against a full strength side that got dominated and has no excuses.

Not true, in 07 we did not have the Wolfman.
 

eagles4eva

First Grade
Messages
9,965
From NRL.com

Storm (4) v Sea Eagles (5)
Etihad Stadium
Friday 7.45pm

Rugby league’s greatest modern-day rivalry resumes with a fierce encounter at Etihad Stadium that could have drastic repercussions for either side should they lose.

With the seventh-placed Knights given a fair chance of upsetting the Bulldogs in Brett Kimmorley’s absence, and the resurgent sixth-placed Broncos dominant favourites in betting markets to account for the Titans, a loss by the fifth-placed Sea Eagles or fourth-ranked Storm would see them out the back door in 2009.

Given that, there’s no doubt coach Des Hasler will have his charges primed and focused for this.

Likewise, Craig Bellamy.

The Storm enter this on the back of two wins, including a 30-nil shutout of the Warriors in New Zealand. Before that they thrashed the Roosters 38-4.

They’ll line up the same as last week, providing second-rower Adam Blair beats his contrary conduct charge at the judiciary.

Meanwhile the Sea Eagles may enter this battle without brilliant game-breaker Jamie Lyon, who remains troubled by a shoulder injury. Now, while we don’t doubt Lyon is injured, we also suspect Des Hasler could be playing a few mind games and, given the importance of the game, don’t be surprised to see Lyon on deck.

Watch out Storm: Anthony Watmough – Dally M Second-Rower of the Year and a strike weapon Craig Bellamy rated highly during Origin this year – is the danger man. The dynamic back-rower provides huge impact around the park – he’s averaging 16 hit-ups a game, makes 24 tackles and offloads almost 2.5 times a match. His 138 tackle breaks rank him the most damaging open-play runner in the NRL, while his 13 line breaks are the most by any Sea Eagle.

Watmough presents a huge try-scoring threat; he has tremendous vision and knows when to time his run through the ruck, picking up passes from ball-players like Matt Orford (22 try assists) or offloads from other forwards like Glenn Stewart (21), Chris Bailey (19) or Josh Perry (14). To counter that the Storm will need to ensure they wrap up the ball carrier in the centre of the park.

And Brett Stewart, just two games back from a long break, needs to be monitored closely. He has proven a real thorn in the Storm’s side in recent years and will be ‘up’ for a strong performance.

Watch out Sea Eagles: Billy Slater has had a quiet year by his great standards – which means he could be ready to explode.

Also Greg Inglis showed great form last week, scoring a wonderful 60-metre try from dummy-half. Right-side defending centre Ben Farrar will need to improve on his 80 per cent tackle effectiveness if he’s a chance of keeping the newly crowned Dally M International Player of the Year quiet.

On the other flank, expect Cooper Cronk, Will Chambers and Billy Slater to torment Manly’s left-side defending centre Steve Matai, who can be a liability with just a 68 per cent tackle effectiveness.

Where it will be won: In defence and forcing the opposition into repeated tackling effort.

Both sides have shown good mettle recently, with the Storm keeping the Warriors tryless last week, while the Sea Eagles surrendered just the one try against the Titans last week.

Also, both coaches will look to their forwards to lay a platform for their brilliant backs.

The Storm forwards were particularly impressive last week and coach Bellamy will be smiling at the way they are rolling up their sleeves.

Prop Aiden Tolman has really grasped his opportunities lately and his effort last week – 27 hit-ups for 233 metres and 27 tackles – represented the most metres by a Melbourne ‘bookend’ since Robbie Kearns’ 247 metres in 2001. But it didn’t end there – when added to Brett White’s 163 metres it represented a club record for the front row.

And for the Sea Eagles, Kite provided arguably his biggest impact all year with 127 metres in just 49 minutes.

Also, Cooper Cronk’s tactical kicking game to gain the Storm repeat sets will be crucial – the side was able to force the Warriors into six line dropouts last week and it’s that sort of sustained pressure that coaches love come finals time.

The history: Played 16; Storm 9, Sea Eagles 7. They are yet to meet at Etihad Stadium. The Storm have won four of the past six, although the Sea Eagles won 20-16 in Round 24 at Olympic Park when both sides were missing strike players Brett Stewart and Greg Inglis.

Conclusion: The Storm deserve to be narrow favourites in this one, although given the clash is at Etihad Stadium rather than their spiritual home and opposition ‘graveyard’ Olympic Park, it’s hard to read too much into the “home-ground” advantage.

This qualifying final will be played close to the chest – the Sea Eagles made just five offloads last week (average 10.8) and the Storm an extravagant (for them) 14 (average 9.9). It will all boil down to pressure and limiting mistakes. On that basis, we’ll pump for the Storm to frustrate Matt Orford into playing rushed footy. Melbourne to get the cash.

Match officials: Referees – Shayne Hayne & Gavin Badger; Sideline Officials – Steve Chiddy & Jeff Younis; Video Ref – Bill Harrigan.

Televised: Channel Nine – Live 7.30pm; Fox Sports – Delayed 10.30pm.

* Statistics: NRL Stats.

 

Lowdown

Juniors
Messages
1,062
Storm to win comfortably.

They took a lot of away from the upset loss to Manly and with GI back it will be the nail in the coffin for Manly.

The Storm are a 20-30% better team with the likes of Blair playing backrow, Ryan Tandy has been superb and Dane Neilsen is not the defensively liability that Joe Tomane was.

Storm have key players finding form at exactly the right time. Its almost like it was planned that way....
 

eaglerock

Juniors
Messages
159
Storm to win comfortably.

They took a lot of away from the upset loss to Manly and with GI back it will be the nail in the coffin for Manly.

The Storm are a 20-30% better team with the likes of Blair playing backrow, Ryan Tandy has been superb and Dane Neilsen is not the defensively liability that Joe Tomane was.

Storm have key players finding form at exactly the right time. Its almost like it was planned that way....

Forgive me for thinking that the Storm were playing the BYE, Manly as well as the Storm are 30% Better with Lyon and Stewart in form, and the find of the season, Foran who in my books will play SOO in the near future, the success for manly will come down to the ability to contain GI, which has been done before, although he was not in attendance last time i still see Manly being the dominant side, 40 Nil is a big mental scar and the Manly Crew will make sure melbourne remember that. Manly by 4,
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
Foran is a Kiwi.

I change my mind on who will win every 5 minutes. The reason I am leaning more towards Melbourne is Manly are so inconsistent. They can be brilliant one week and sh!thouse the next.
 

Whos Ya Daddy

First Grade
Messages
5,699
Storm are very lucky Blair got off. The bench looks disgraceful and they couldn't afford to lose another quality forward.
 

Lowdown

Juniors
Messages
1,062
Forgive me for thinking that the Storm were playing the BYE, Manly as well as the Storm are 30% Better with Lyon and Stewart in form, and the find of the season, Foran who in my books will play SOO in the near future, the success for manly will come down to the ability to contain GI, which has been done before, although he was not in attendance last time i still see Manly being the dominant side, 40 Nil is a big mental scar and the Manly Crew will make sure melbourne remember that. Manly by 4,

You'd be forgiven if you could find the fullstop key on your keybord. (Hint: It's the one next to the comma key)
 

cupid

Juniors
Messages
1,989
I think if Manly come with the same intensity, and the forwards are hitting hard like last week, Manly should pull of a win, with the Storm fairly depleted.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
No doubt we have the better pack on paper but it depends which pack turns up on the field. If they play like they did against the sharks we are screwed. If we can muscle up and dominate like we did against the Titans and have done against the Storm previously we should be ok.
 
Messages
17,822
Forgive me for thinking that the Storm were playing the BYE, Manly as well as the Storm are 30% Better with Lyon and Stewart in form, and the find of the season, Foran who in my books will play SOO in the near future, the success for manly will come down to the ability to contain GI, which has been done before, although he was not in attendance last time i still see Manly being the dominant side, 40 Nil is a big mental scar and the Manly Crew will make sure melbourne remember that. Manly by 4,

Yep...just contain GI and you will win...forget Slater, Cronk, Smith, Blair and co...they have no impact whatsoever.

This will be a stroll in the park for Manly...

Oh...and Foran is a kiwi...
 

Jason Maher

Immortal
Messages
35,981
I hope the refs basically put the whistle in the pocket and let the two teams bash the living snot out of each other. The more cheap shots, the better. :p
 
Top