09 :: R19 Sat :: Panthers 27 Raiders 14 @ CUA

[shear_joy9]

Josh Dugan - 5 errors
Daniel Vidot - 3 errors
Terry Campese - 2 errors
Josh Miller - 2 errors
Marc Herbert - 2 errors

very misleading stats though.
Failure to get the out of the in-goal is classified as an error when it's most often due to a good kick and chase.
Dugan and Vidot were caught in-goal a number of times.

 

[skeepe]

Yep, Penrith led 18-0 and weren't the better side :lol:

You've lost it bud.

Now, try a response without calling me an avalanche of naughty words

If the video ref's decisions were correct, Canberra would have been leading 12-6 going into half time. FACT.

 

[mxlegend99]

very misleading stats though.
Failure to get the out of the in-goal is classified as an error when it's most often due to a good kick and chase.
Dugan and Vidot were caught in-goal a number of times.

Are you serious? Being tackled in goal counts as an error? That's definitely a little harsh. Although the Raiders sure as f*ck were making a lot of errors, but that definitely explains why Dugan was so high up. I didn't remember him dropping the ball that often.

If the video ref's decisions were correct, Canberra would have been leading 12-6 going into half time. FACT.

That's not a fact, it's a biased opinion. The second one decision changes the entire game after that decision would be different. FACT.

ie. if Frank Puletua was ruled held up, we would have just played the ball and could have scored of the next tackle, or gained a repeat set like we did every other time we were on the line.... it's just absolutely impossible to say what would have happened.

The fact is the Panthers were the dominant side and while we had a few decisions go our way, most of them are nowhere near as bad as you would like to believe.

 

[VictorTheViking]

The better side did win mx, that doesn't change the fact that it should have been a lot closer than it was.