2012 NSW soo side..

[RABK]

Hutty - Hayne and Uate should be our wingers.

Make up the centres from J Morris, Jennings and Lawrence.

I'd take Ferguson over B Morris. All i hear against fergo is that he's prone to errors, well what the f**k is Morris at rep level? With Fergo's brain explosions you at least know he has the talent and heart to try and make ammends with a brilliant individual play. With Morris he goes back to his wing and watches his team mate winger get belted bringing it out from their own end.

 

[Hutty1986]

Hutty - Hayne and Uate should be our wingers.

Make up the centres from J Morris, Jennings and Lawrence.

I'd take Ferguson over B Morris. All i hear against fergo is that he's prone to errors, well what the f**k is Morris at rep level? With Fergo's brain explosions you at least know he has the talent and heart to try and make ammends with a brilliant individual play. With Morris he goes back to his wing and watches his team mate winger get belted bringing it out from their own end.

Hayne should be like Gal-first bloke picked. Whether or not Sticky will include him, who knows! And Morris has a lot less errors in his game than Turd Ferguson btw

 

[Vic Mackey]

Lol buhuer

Please die Fulton

 

[Tigger Madness]

Could someone with an unbiased view please tell me why Tamou is so far ahead of Woods in the pecking order?

 

[gronkathon]

He is a better option at this stage.

 

[The Gambler]

Could someone with an unbiased view please tell me why Tamou is so far ahead of Woods in the pecking order?

I wouldn't say he is 'far ahead in the pecking order'. Fact of the matter is, they are both great props in great form. However there are a limited amount of spots. Tamou has been around a little longer, has a bit more experience and recently played a test match.

It is just the little things giving Tamou an edge. Woods will get his chance - and he will keep a few other 'young props' out of the NSW team himself over the years.

 

[Patorick]

Buhrer is the fastest and arguably the most skillful forward in the Manly team. Manly's backrow are very capable of dominating their QLD counterparts.

Glenn Stewart on Line 1 for you...

;-)

 

[firechild]

Well it wouldnt be a NSW team if Bozo didnt didnt sneak a Manly player in from left field.

He's better than Gidley but Id rather Hinchcliffe. Probably on par with Wade Graham.

Of course Manly being premiers and the most dominant team of the last 5 years would have nothing to do with Manly players getting picked would it? :crazy:

 

[Ladmate]

Of course Manly being premiers and the most dominant team of the last 5 years would have nothing to do with Manly players getting picked would it? :crazy:

Lets be real though, Manly players that have no business being there still get picked even when Manly don't win the premiership. Some Manly players like Watmough, Stewart, T Williams deserve it and others don't.

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Lets be real though, Manly players that have no business being there still get picked even when Manly don't win the premiership. Some Manly players like Watmough, Stewart, T Williams deserve it and others don't.

And Wade Graham for example deserves the bench spot? The the only Manly name thrown into contention from left field is Buhrer.

If Ricky Stuart desperately needs someone that can fill in at hooker, plug the back-line if need be and make a few hit-ups it's really only out of Hinchcliffe, Buhrer and Wade Graham.

You can argue that none of them are are "SOO quality", but maybe all of them are good enough for a NSW bench position in 2012.

 

[Tigger Madness]

I wouldn't say he is 'far ahead in the pecking order'. Fact of the matter is, they are both great props in great form. However there are a limited amount of spots. Tamou has been around a little longer, has a bit more experience and recently played a test match.

It is just the little things giving Tamou an edge. Woods will get his chance - and he will keep a few other 'young props' out of the NSW team himself over the years.

Fair enough.

I honesty hadnt heard much at all about Tamou before the eligibility kerfuffle earlier this year. Looking at their stats they are pretty similar with Tamou being more consistent with run metres while Woods has better tackle counts.

How long has Tamou been playing for?

 

[Tigger Madness]

Of course Manly being premiers and the most dominant team of the last 5 years would have nothing to do with Manly players getting picked would it? :crazy:

Manly will be HEAVILY represented in the NSW side, most of them deservedly so.

Putting a player in Origin just because his team has been going well has led to disaster in the past, ala Steve Turner.

Also lets not forget the Jason King and Dean Young debacle of last year :?

 

[Patorick]

Why do we have to pick a bench utility if Luke Lewis is already in the squad?

 

[Tigger Madness]

Between Lewis and Hayne you would think most positions could be covered.

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Why do we have to pick a bench utility if Luke Lewis is already in the squad?

I guess Ricky wants someone that can play a bit of hooker?

My concern is the potential Lewis/Glenn Stewart and Bird in the same team. All to similar and would much rather have a few "running backrowers" than all three of those.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Of course Manly being premiers and the most dominant team of the last 5 years would have nothing to do with Manly players getting picked would it? :crazy:

Pretty much everyone on here wants both stewarts, watmough and williams picked.

If Lyon was available he would be picked.

If balin, foran and dce could play for nsw they would All get picked.

Hell if matai was from nsw he'd go close too

However if Jamie buhrer gets picked it a joke.

 

[MSIH]

I've watched Stewart plenty of times, he is a good player.
In my opinion he's not the best for the job.
How dare I have an opinion different to such an obvious authority on the game.

You can have an opinion, but if you're going to post that Brett Stewart can't create anything himself and needs people to set up tries for him then I'm going to call you on how shithouse your opinion is.

 

[Jason Maher]

Mozza don't deserve nothing. Anyone who even has him in their B side have NFI and should have their post moved to a troll dump thread.

And this is no way a troll... :roll:

 

[betcats]

Not keen on Buhrer at all, he played poorly in CvC and i just cant see what utility value he adds that isnt already in the team.

 

[Jason Maher]

It wouldn't have anything to do with Manly being premiers would it?

He did it last year when Saints were Premiers...