2016 Match Review Committee / Judiciary

[SBD82]

Didn't see that one. Is there footage somewhere?

http://www.nospam47.com/league/news...news-video-broncos/1rpb5ws6ew5ox1vna8kl581hgs

I'm not sure if there's footage, but this link is to the story.

I personally don't think that glenn should be charged. I just don't think that frizzel should have been either.

 

[lockyno1]

Watch Graham NOT get charged....again.

Should get 2+ weeks for his mouthing off at the ref, and he has form in this regard.

 

[Sleep]

Bulldogs hooker could be in some strife after whacking the ref with his elbow as he walked past. Ref didn't move so he was aware of where he was and needed to leave the space.

 

[Timmah]

Watch Graham NOT get charged....again.

Should get 2+ weeks for his mouthing off at the ref, and he has form in this regard.

Errr, it was Reynolds and Graham pulled him away from it very quickly.

Idiot.

 

[lockyno1]

Errr, it was Reynolds and Graham pulled him away from it very quickly.

Idiot.

No it was Graham. The last penalty in regular time. Was Graham carrying on like a pork chop.

 

[Timmah]

"Carrying on like a pork chop"?

He was debating the validity of the penalty, he didn't break any rules. Get a clue.

 

[Card Shark]

He was quite sedate compared to some of his carry-ons over the years.

 

[Meth]

No it was Graham. The last penalty in regular time. Was Graham carrying on like a pork chop.

Yep

 

[Timmah]

No charges from Broncos v Eels.

 

[fulltime]

1 week for James. It pays to be part of the team with the Hayne hype in it.

 

[Clifferd]

The NRL Is a f**king joke. I'm fuming

Be a complete thug and break someone's jaw, get a week

Only in the NRL

He should've got season

 

[skeepe]

The NRL Is a f**king joke. I'm fuming

Be a complete thug and break someone's jaw, get a week

Only in the NRL

He should've got season

In all honesty there wasn't that much in it.

Tedesco was falling, it was just an unfortunate accident.

I think they got this one about right.

 

[Clifferd]

In all honesty there wasn't that much in it.

Tedesco was falling, it was just an unfortunate accident.

I think they got this one about right.

Not much in it? Did you see the blood gushing from his mouth? Jaw being broken in 2 places? I'm not a doctor, but you'd have to use quite a lot of force for that to happen

Freddy nailed it earlier saying James knew what was coming and had plenty of time to react, it can't be that hard to avoid the head area, falling or not that's a pathetic excuse

NRL is soft

 

[mave]

Kyle feldt....surely misses a week...touched the touchie..44th/45th minute.
If its good enough for Frizzel...

 

[Vic Mackey]

In all honesty there wasn't that much in it.

Tedesco was falling, it was just an unfortunate accident.

I think they got this one about right.

You said in the game thread it was a send off.

Simona got 3 fcking weeks for the most innocuous crusher tackle I've ever seen yet a swinging arm that hits a guy flush in the jaw and breaks it in 2 places gets 1 fcking week?!?

Hayne also touched the red AGAIN (there's photos on Twitter of it) and gets nothing

We know who the NRL want the Cinderella story from this year.

 

[skeepe]

You said in the game thread it was a send off.

Simona got 3 fcking weeks for the most innocuous crusher tackle I've ever seen yet a swinging arm that hits a guy flush in the jaw and breaks it in 2 places gets 1 fcking week?!?

Hayne also touched the red AGAIN (there's photos on Twitter of it) and gets nothing

We know who the NRL want the Cinderella story from this year.

I changed my mind. Tedesco had fallen a long way by the time contact was made. It sucks that he got injured, but a grade 2 careless charge sounds about right.

 

[Vic Mackey]

If it happened to jack wighton you'd want the guy in gaol

 

[TheFrog]

If breaking a player's jaw is Grade 2, I just wonder what you have to do to get a Grade 5, or a Reckless?

Perhaps the injured player's club should have the right to appeal, but then I suppose getting Ryan James suspended for a longer stretch only benefits their opponents, not them.

 

[Clifferd]

I changed my mind. Tedesco had fallen a long way by the time contact was made. It sucks that he got injured, but a grade 2 careless charge sounds about right.

Fallen a long way by the time contact was made meaning James had plenty of time to react

You just contradicted yourself

 

[Front-Rower]

Teddy was never falling, that is until he got smacked in the head then dropped in pain from having his jaw fractured in two places..

If you watch the video, you'll his knees are bent while catching the ball and is in the same position when he got hit.