2016 Match Review Committee / Judiciary

[skeepe]

Lol gonna grow a party when Wighton goes down with a season ending injury.

Lol. Go shove your head in a blender.

 

[Vic Mackey]

The media got this guy off this charge that is for sure

Absolutely.

FTR I thought he should have been charged, but I also thought Ennis should have.

In the end it's actually the farcical non charge of Ennis that got Wighton off, so raiders fans should be thanking the MRC

 

[Walt Flanigan]

I bet if i go over every shoulder charge this year a good chunk of them would not meet the nrls own criteria

Are referees supposed to go off that same criteria? It would be virtually impossible for them to tell if the arm was away from from the body in real time. The dipsh*t prosecutor couldn't even convince the judiciary with the 5 different angles he presented.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Shoulder got a week.

 

[THE CHAMP]

If they had any brain whatsoever they would have downgraded the charge or points to the point that he got a week.
At least then they save some face.
They both should have got a week but anyway it's probably better this way. We want the best available this weekend for all sides.

 

[Surely]

Just lead with a forearm problem solved

Dumb merkins and their dumb rules, shoulder charge shouldn't have been banned except for in the head or the back, attacking the head is already covered anyway.

 

[wittyfan]

#jackwillplay

 

[nick87]

If they had any brain whatsoever they would have downgraded the charge or points to the point that he got a week.
At least then they save some face.
They both should have got a week but anyway it's probably better this way. We want the best available this weekend for all sides.

Buettner's three point plan laid the platform for our defence
Dumb motherf**ker should have just shut his stupid mouth and maybe he would have gotten out of this with an ounce of respect

 

[Walt Flanigan]

If they had any brain whatsoever they would have downgraded the charge or points to the point that he got a week.

Because of the excessive amount of points a shoulder charge carries, it wasn't even possible to get less than 2 weeks for it.

 

[Generalzod]

Walt I told you he'll get off...

 

[Pete Cash]

You did

I didnt believe it tbh but im very happy

 

[The Undertaker]

Ennis effort = classic shoulder charge. drops shoulder as contact is made,both arms down
Wighton effort = hits more upright from side with chest, arms up at shoulder height
would of been a travesty if Wighton had been rubbed out, don't think his tackle was anything like Ennis'
Glad they're both playing though purely for the spectacle of the game.
will be a great tussle I'm sure and don't care who wins as long as the big dance is not won by the two heads or mexicans

 

[Generalzod]

You did

I didnt believe it tbh but im very happy

It was all about the drama.....

 

[Generalzod]

Its all Cronulla's fault

 

[Rabbits20]

Absolutely.

FTR I thought he should have been charged, but I also thought Ennis should have.

In the end it's actually the farcical non charge of Ennis that got Wighton off, so raiders fans should be thanking the MRC

Klemmer was lucky to not be charged also.

 

[wittyfan]

 

[Rabbits20]

Remember this weekend bottles can be thrown at other players.

They allow it now.

 

[JamesRustle]

This is a disappointing result. I was so looking forward to Fifita having FJW on his wrist strapping this Satday.

 

[Game_Breaker]

Remember this weekend bottles can be thrown at other players.

They allow it now.

Your team is not relevant this week

That's ok, we'll join you next week

 

[Rabbits20]

Your team is not relevant this week

That's ok, we'll join you next week

That wasn't my point was it.

My point is you are now allowed to throw bottles it seems.

Surely you've had a gutful of the MRC as well?