What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2017 Draw

Raiderdave

First Grade
Messages
7,990
and seriously
how can every team play every other team twice anyway

we'd have a 30 week comp with no byes ... lol
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,990
Would make more sense to reduce the number of rounds and have everyone play once. Give Origin & rep football their own weekends to account for the lost rounds
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
and seriously
how can every team play every other team twice anyway

we'd have a 30 week comp with no byes ... lol
You'd have to start a week earlier, that's all.

The problem comes when the comp expands again, which might not be all that far off.
 

Raiderdave

First Grade
Messages
7,990
You'd have to start a week earlier, that's all.

The problem comes when the comp expands again, which might not be all that far off.

Wot
A week earlier ?
Hahaha

Try 4
And no byes , so players needing to back up after origin or miss their club games around origin.
With trials finals & rep games
We'd be asking some players to play nearly 40 games in a season

But no biggie eh lol
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,990
Yeah, Greenberg personally puts the draw together ...
 

Nice Beaver

First Grade
Messages
5,920
Yeah, Greenberg personally puts the draw together ...

Hahaha

Put it as simplistically as you like champ.

If you are naive enough to think directions are not given at higher level, then I am impressed you can work out how to use a computer
 

POPEYE

Coach
Messages
11,397
Would make more sense to reduce the number of rounds and have everyone play once. Give Origin & rep football their own weekends to account for the lost rounds
and each team could alternate away opponents on a 2 year cycle
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,990
Hahaha

Put it as simplistically as you like champ.

If you are naive enough to think directions are not given at higher level, then I am impressed you can work out how to use a computer
With that sort of tinfoil hat logic you sound like you'd be at home in the Youtube comments section of 9/11 videos...
 

NrlVader

Juniors
Messages
426
It's only half a dozen extra games for each team.

Over say 6 weeks where you play two games per week.

Quick backup never hurt anyone.
 

NK Arsenal

Juniors
Messages
1,861
Would make more sense to reduce the number of rounds and have everyone play once. Give Origin & rep football their own weekends to account for the lost rounds
I agree

I would love a 3 week window where the regular seasons stops, origin is played and Samoa, Fiji, PNG, NZ, Tonga and Cook Islands play some tests

Could also make it a transfer window for players coming off market to keep things interesting in club land during the mid season
 

BuderusIsaBeast

Juniors
Messages
554
Im of the opinion the NRL needed to present a Round 1 that will maximise crowds to set the tone, im not sure they have doen that. I would have had

Thursday 8pm - Sharks vs Panthers at Shark Park, Premier host first game against young exciting Panthers
Friday 6pm - Warriors vs Eels at Eden Park - Bold stadium choice and Foran rivalry, suits NZ time best
Friday 8pm - Bunnies vs Tigers at ANZ - Use the rivalry while its hot, big game for Sydney to open the season
Sat 4pm - Knights vs Dragons at Hunter - Guaranteed a good crowd
Sat 6pm - Storm vs Titans at AAMi - Bring Hayne to Melbourne to start the year
Sat 8pm - Cowboys vs Sea Eagles - Guaranteed a good crowd
Sun 2pm - Raiders vs Bulldogs - Raiders deserve a home game to start the year after a good season
Sun 4pm - Broncos vs Roosters at Suncorp - Bit of a novelty with Broncos on Sunday arvo, still 9 game vs NSW
 

Card Shark

Immortal
Messages
32,237
Would make more sense to reduce the number of rounds and have everyone play once. Give Origin & rep football their own weekends to account for the lost rounds

& take 30% revenue out of the game & have heaps more trialling for NFL!
 

NrlVader

Juniors
Messages
426
Below is from 1978. They had 12 teams but clubs also participated in a mid week cup comp.

All teams played each other twice. Nothing worse than having reduced club matches during Origin/Test.

Team
Pld W D L PF PA PD Pts

1 Western Suburbs 22 16 1 5 426 288 +138 33
2 Cronulla-Sutherland 22 15 0 7 418 261 +157 30
3 Manly-Warringah 22 15 0 7 427 287 +140 30
4 Parramatta 22 14 0 8 525 306 +219 28
5 Canterbury-Bankstown 22 13 2 7 307 273 +34 28
6 Eastern Suburbs 22 13 0 9 377 280 +57 26
7 South Sydney 22 12 1 9 298 300 -2 25
8 St. George 22 10 1 11 367 354 +13 21
9 Balmain 22 9 1 12 337 344 -7 19
10 Penrith 22 4 2 16 206 463 -257 10
11 North Sydney 22 4 1 17 325 439 -114 9
12 Newtown Jets 22 2 1 19 199 577 -378 5
 

Big Salad

Juniors
Messages
216
& take 30% revenue out of the game & have heaps more trialling for NFL!

It would be interesting to know how much money two extra teams - i.e. one extra game per round - would bring to the game through a TV deal, and whether or not it would make up for removing one or two full rounds of games (e.g. adding 22 extra games involving new teams, minus 16 games for two current rounds).
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,627
Below is from 1978. They had 12 teams but clubs also participated in a mid week cup comp.

All teams played each other twice. Nothing worse than having reduced club matches during Origin/Test.

Team
Pld W D L PF PA PD Pts

1 Western Suburbs 22 16 1 5 426 288 +138 33
2 Cronulla-Sutherland 22 15 0 7 418 261 +157 30
3 Manly-Warringah 22 15 0 7 427 287 +140 30
4 Parramatta 22 14 0 8 525 306 +219 28
5 Canterbury-Bankstown 22 13 2 7 307 273 +34 28
6 Eastern Suburbs 22 13 0 9 377 280 +57 26
7 South Sydney 22 12 1 9 298 300 -2 25
8 St. George 22 10 1 11 367 354 +13 21
9 Balmain 22 9 1 12 337 344 -7 19
10 Penrith 22 4 2 16 206 463 -257 10
11 North Sydney 22 4 1 17 325 439 -114 9
12 Newtown Jets 22 2 1 19 199 577 -378 5

Can you explain what this post is supposed to be demonstrating?
 
Top