- Messages
- 100,985
I don't think they've offsetted the path with round corners, I think they've literally applied the stroke blending option and slid the number up to 100It would probably fix the problem in every single case, but it wouldn't necessarily look good.
Enclosing shapes, keylines, simplified elements, different colours, ... they're all different tools a designer can use to better adapt a logo to its application. I'm guessing the roundels/shields/ovals became popular at the time because of manufacturing limitations. We don't really have these limitations anymore and the design styles have evolved as a result.
That doesn't excuse poor design though, which is the case with the Broncos and Panthers. And in my opinion, chucking them in a roundel as a patch-up job is just bad design stacked on top of bad design as they stylistically don't match. The logos would need to be done from scratch to fix the problems.
The keyline on the Panthers logo is a bad example - someone has just offsetted the path with round corners, other versions have used mitre corners with the mitre limit jacked up which is why there were sharp jags on the keyline around the claws. Its just lazy design and the keyline should have been drawn by hand. I just hate the whole logo to be honest, not saying I can do any better but the Panthers have enough resources to have ended up with a better product.