Australia v India 2nd (New Years) Test SCG

[mickdo]

Why are you rolling your eyes, that LBW was crap. In the match situation to give him out was just crap. Yesterday Hussey was plumb in front halfway up and not given. And BTW i'm a happy Aussies supporter. If anyone thinks hawkeye is gospel is kidding themselves.

Husseys should have been out, Tendulkars and VVS as well, and that last one was out in my book.

 

[Mr. Fahrenheit]

Mr F... who was your MOTM?

I'd pick from the following:

Symonds
Clarke
Hussey
Hayden

and for India the candidates would come from Tenders, Kumble and maybe Laxman.

I would have gone Lee or Kumble - bowlers undervalued IMO

 

[shiznit]

Hawkeye gave that LBW to clip the top of the stumps.... some people will say that vindicates it and some will say that means its dodgy...

the only one that matters is the umpire....

 

[mickdo]

Still 3 minutes???

So many rules change from year to year it's hard to keep up.

Yep, still 3

 

[Jeu_de_Treize]

The unfortunate thing here is that the test wont be remembered for the outstanding cricket provided by both teams but instead will be remembered for terrible umpirering.

 

[willvillain]

Gotta love Test cricket. Incredible stuff.

 

[Bay56]

Great game Symo .... irrespective of the fact he wasnt given out on 30 or so, he went on to score more than a ton after that .

great work son and the wickets jsut capped off a great all-rounders game

 

[Jobdog]

FFS. Pup's lbw was out. Look at the scoreboard.

 

[Mr Angry]

Kumble would have been my MOM.

Great win.

 

[Gene Krupa]

VVS = one chance

Symmo first Inns 4 OBVIOUS chances
2nd Inns One chance

Bowling - one wicket was a gift

Go cry a river, ffs!

 

[hineyrulz]

Husseys should have been out, Tendulkars and VVS as well, and that last one was out in my book.

His finger was out of the holster before it hit his pads, in the context of the game in was a harsh call IMO.

 

[innsaneink]

Amazing game....fkn brilliant and the fact so many were glued to it right at the end on day 5 says something

I wonder how much the bookies and b/a's picked up on the draw today ....a stack im sure.

 

[Gene Krupa]

His finger was out of the holster before it hit his pads, in the context of the game in was a harsh call IMO.

:lol:

You're a joke!

 

[Timmah]

The unfortunate thing here is that the test wont be remembered for the outstanding cricket provided by both teams but instead will be remembered for terrible umpirering.

Only if you continue to cast the negative light on it because you're a sore loser.

I think it's time people acknowledged umpires make mistakes. If they make too many then they should be reviewed and that's that. The game is over, it was exciting and a spectacle and that's what we wanted. We got it.

 

[Bay56]

The unfortunate thing here is that the test wont be remembered for the outstanding cricket provided by both teams but instead will be remembered for terrible umpirering.

everyone for his own dude .... I'll remember the great cricket thanks

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

I would have gone Lee

you are deadset on the level of lockyno1

 

[TITAN1]

The unfortunate thing here is that the test wont be remembered for the outstanding cricket provided by both teams but instead will be remembered for terrible umpirering.

..And for the monkey name calling. (Alledgedly :roll: )

 

[Mr. Fahrenheit]

Go cry a river, ffs!

If this wasn't the first test you've watched, that would have a lot more credibility.

 

[hineyrulz]

:lol:

You're a joke!

It's my opinion, some of the crap i have seen you post is beyond comprehesion.

 

[mickdo]

His finger was out of the holster before it hit his pads

whatever

in the context of the game in was a harsh call IMO.

The context of the game makes no difference to a decision