Coach of the Year: Bennett or Moore ?

[God-King Dean]

I'll go with Moore as well, just for the sheer fact of going from spooners to possibly MPs.

 

[nathanbrown'sghost]

Sticky.

 

[hellteam]

Nah it's all Hayne. Take Hayne away, you guys would struggle to beat the Sharks/Roosters

 

[nomarg]

daniel anderson LOL!!!!!!!!

Parra haven't even made the top 8 yet.

It should easliy be Moore-

Wooden spooners-to minor prems if they were not robbed of 4 points- v dragons (soward interference) and v panthers (14 men).

A rookie coach taking a bunch of misfits to the top of the table, with a new CEO.....

What Moore could he do!

Saints were in the finals last year so this is a no brainer to me.....

 

[caylo]

Nah it's all Hayne. Take Hayne away, you guys would struggle to beat the Sharks/Roosters

take Hayne away and we would have another 400K to spend on a halfback or 5-8. Essentially this year we have played without our #1 halfback (on 350K) and have had key players like Mateo and KK out for 13 weeks.

With what Anderson has done (esp in the last 2-3 months) has been very good but you cant go past Moore IMO. His team is not full of superstars but good honest players and made them perform to their best. Someone like Armitt has struggled to play consistant footy in the past but this year looks the good... started to stand up and I'm sure that has alot to do with how he club is now being run.

 

[Evenflow]

Daniel Anderson for mine. He's turned a very average Parramatta side into top 8 contenders.

Parra won a total of 13 games last year while this year they've won 11 with 2 to go, you do the maths. Yep, the bloke is a genius :lol:

Its called coach of the year for a reason, not coach of the month and a bit.

 

[little_aza]

craig bellamy..... :sarcasm:

 

[Sir Biffo]

Moore - spooners to possible MP's.

Bennett a very close second.

Then Cartwright, then maybe Anderson. Calling Anderson coach of the year is like shooting your load off over Jarryd Hayne saying he's the greatest player ever to lace on a boot ...

 

[Liam]

Moore - spooners to possible MP's.

Bennett a very close second.

Then Cartwright, then maybe Anderson. Calling Anderson coach of the year is like shooting your load off over Jarryd Hayne saying he's the greatest player ever to lace on a boot ...

http://www.nospam09.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/phil-gould.jpg

 

[nomarg]

Moore - spooners to possible MP's.

Bennett a very close second.

Then Cartwright, then maybe Anderson. Calling Anderson coach of the year is like shooting your load off over Jarryd Hayne saying he's the greatest player ever to lace on a boot ...

sorry- he is the greatest player of any footballing code to lace up a boot acc. to Phil.....

 

[userlogin]

I'd have to say Moore, i'm sure there were many people doubting him when he took over!

 

[Red Bear]

Bennett easily.

Moores done well but f**k he bought in how many players? Kimmorley Ennis Stagg Hannant Eastwood Morris Goodwin and i may have forgotten a few. These were big buys and expected to be good players.

Bennett has changed the culture of the Dragons completely and turned a talented side with a sh*t attitude that just lost two of its best players into a formidible outfit. Look at the improvement in the players at the dragons, the likes of Soward, Hornby, Scott, Creagh, Weyman etc. He's suprised me big time cos i had big doubts over how he would go outside of Brisbane, but he has been very good.

 

[Broncodr01d]

Moore, easy.

From wooden spooners to league leaders and a premiership favourite. Bennett has been good, Moore has been better when you look at last season compared to today.

 

[nomarg]

Bennett easily.

Moores done well but f**k he bought in how many players? Kimmorley Ennis Stagg Hannant Eastwood Morris Goodwin and i may have forgotten a few. .

Even more of a well done to Moore- Half the team hasn't played together....

Bennet is a much better coach- but as far as this year goes no one can touch moore-

7th spot to poss minor prems is good

Last to first is f**king great!

 

[bulldog]

Why do people keep perpetuating this myth....after getting rid of these 2, they came last.

And after signing them you might just win a spoon too.

 

[Hanscholo]

Hypothetically, if Dogs & Saints finish on equal points this season, who do you think should get Coach of the Year ?

The one who wins the comp. I dont believe in handing out regular season titles.

 

[Fein]

sorry- he is the greatest player of any footballing code to lace up a boot acc. to Phil.....

Gasnier will be shattered!!

Moore by one length to Bennett.

 

[nomarg]

The one who wins the comp. I dont believe in handing out regular season titles.

Agreed-

Can anyone find a list of coaches of the year- be good to compare how many won it and won the GF

 

[Anon]

This myth that Moore has taken a wooden spoon team to be a chance at minor premiers/premiers really sh*ts me. If he had the same team that won the spoon last year I would agree he would be coach of the year but the fact is most of the team played elsewhere. It's a completely new look team.

 

[African Monkey]

Parra won a total of 13 games last year while this year they've won 11 with 2 to go, you do the maths. Yep, the bloke is a genius :lol:

Its called coach of the year for a reason, not coach of the month and a bit.

Hey it's just my opinion. I just think that he's done a great job considering the fact that he didn't really have a choice as to what players he wanted as well as having to work with one of the weaker forward packs in the comp as a result. They also won 11 games last year, not 13.