What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Confirmed Signings - 2012/13

Status
Not open for further replies.

DoggiesBro

Juniors
Messages
2,341
The only way I can judge him is how he plays against Australians and from what I've seen he is ordinary


So its safe to assume you don't watch much footy at all, he's been good at worst against australia and nz and hes been pretty unreal in some too.
 

Phantomlock

Juniors
Messages
23
It's not opinion, it was the inside word. Still, either as prop or second-rower, a lot have been surprised he has gone to the Dogs with the amount of guys supposedly ahead of him in both positions. Both the Eels and Panthers were also interested (the Eels having signed his younger brother, too) -- clubs he would arguably be closer to top grade in. That would suggest his decision to go the Dogs was based on money. If your club offered more money, then perhaps they hold him higher that you assume they do -- time will tell.

Well fancy 'seeing you on here' DV - how's things mate!

He's REALLY rated by Dimmock AND Hasler. Des wanted him signed up in June but Cleary, at that time, had him pushing hard for a topside spot and even with the current Warriors line up he would've been the next cab off the rank after such a strong NSWC showing. No less than 6 clubs wanted him signed at that stage.

Bluey wasn't confident he could work with him so a mutual agreement meant he could/would look for other opportunities - that's some oil I didn't share on the other forum. In November, Manley, Wests, Canterbury and Parra, who were interested initally withdrawing due to Mannah's arrival and other internal promotions (Juniors).

The Dogs got the nod due to Dimmock/Hasler (2013) being here and the 'club culture' and not so much on current prop/secondrow stocks. Dogs will see how good he is in the pre-season matchups. In some ways it's good he's a bit of an unknown - NSW Prop of Year aside; nothing wrong with slipping under the radar from the get-go.

PL
 

devoid

Juniors
Messages
1,401
Well fancy 'seeing you on here' DV - how's things mate!

He's REALLY rated by Dimmock AND Hasler. Des wanted him signed up in June but Cleary, at that time, had him pushing hard for a topside spot and even with the current Warriors line up he would've been the next cab off the rank after such a strong NSWC showing. No less than 6 clubs wanted him signed at that stage.

Bluey wasn't confident he could work with him so a mutual agreement meant he could/would look for other opportunities - that's some oil I didn't share on the other forum. In November, Manley, Wests, Canterbury and Parra, who were interested initally withdrawing due to Mannah's arrival and other internal promotions (Juniors).

The Dogs got the nod due to Dimmock/Hasler (2013) being here and the 'club culture' and not so much on current prop/secondrow stocks. Dogs will see how good he is in the pre-season matchups. In some ways it's good he's a bit of an unknown - NSW Prop of Year aside; nothing wrong with slipping under the radar from the get-go.

PL

Ha! Well look who it is... I'm very well, thanks mate -- hopefully you are too. That's some comprehensive oil there -- welcomed too, as always. Do you know much about the Leuluai stuff that's broken out in NZ's Saturday paper? The way one of the articles was written pretty much suggested Maloney to Souths/Leuluai to Warriors 2013 was a done deal, despite the Warriors trying to sign both... I found the certainty of the writing unsettling.

Anyway, you should stick around these parts -- for those that don't know Mr. Phantom Lock, he often has very reliable and always interesting information.
 

Evil Homer

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
7,178
Jack Spencer will be a reserve grade player, to be honest I think virtually nobody outside of Salford would have even heard of him. I'd be surprised if he's even in the first grade training squad, I didn't put him on here for that reason.

Shannon McDonnell also confirmed now at Hull KR.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top