Consistently worst current regular NRL top grade player

[user_nat]

Andrew Mccullough is def in the top 5 this year

Consistent is one thing he is not.

 

[The_Joey_Show]

Cameron Ciraldo and it's not even close.

Hard to disagree with this...

 

[mongoose]

Alan Tongue over the past few years.
Despite the fact that a bunch of downies from Canberra think he is a champ, he would not get a run at any other NRL club other than LOL@50uff$.
Special mention to Antonio "Pillow" Kaufusi, Anthony Quinn, David Simmons, Steve Michaels, Bryce Gibbs and Joel Reddy.

I feel bad for Tongue, there really isn't a place for him in the team at full strength. He's terrible at hooker and Fensom has left him for dead at lock. Even McCrone would make a much better utility. He's not going to make any impact off the bench as a second rower.

The Raiders are like NSW last year where the captain should not have even been in the side (Gidley).

 

[mjk_898]

On his 2011 form, Orford.

 

[azzah72]

Has to be kris keating

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

Now that Nick Kouparitsas has departed the NRL we have quite a few legitimate contenders for this award.

This just in from BesthalfwitPUS -
Anyone from the Dragons.
You heard it here first.

lmao

The troll that is BHP has Dragons fans shook. Second post and boom he gets a mention.

 

[besthalfbackPEARCE]

Funny thing is before I read the earlier pages I actually posted a non-Dragon player :lol:

 

[Cliffhanger]

Andrew Mccullough is def in the top 5 this year

Lol Nub, thread title says "consistently the worst" McCullough hardly fits that description, yes he's been pretty hot and cold this season but he has had his share of good performances in 2011. His kicking game from dummy half is fairly solid. For a young player to show that vision is impressive.

 

[Tommax25]

Forgot about big georgie rose
still he's on their bench every week, he's fair dinkum hopeless, surely they have another front rower better than him, surely?!

Than Vic? Hmm, maybe, but perhaps the fact that he's one of the few local juniors we have in the team keeps him in there when a more deserving youngster might be waiting in the wings.

 

[SingleSpeed73]

Lol Nub, thread title says "consistently the worst" McCullough hardly fits that description, yes he's been pretty hot and cold this season but he has had his share of good performances in 2011. His kicking game from dummy half is fairly solid. For a young player to show that vision is impressive.

Perhaps i'm being harsh on the kid, but watching the dummy half go from Baptiste who looks quick and lively between the ears to mccullough just seems to kill the broncos speed and momentum.
This is prob why he looks just plain awful for mine

 

[BranVan3000]

John Sutton must have seen this thread and decided to make his best effort to reach the top of every list today

Well done, f**kwit.

 

[besthalfbackPEARCE]

Reece Simmonds :lol:

 

[andrew057]

To be fair sutton gas been the worst player in FG the entire year.

 

[Rudderriffic]

I can only assume the reason that non-Knights fans are not yelling agreement with the selection of Ciraldo for this is that they don't know who he is.

If Ciraldo could be good for anything, it would winning this award.

 

[Tom Shines]

John Sutton. He is f**king useless.

And I'm a lol@50uff$ fan.

 

[Cliffhanger]

John Sutton. He is f**king useless.

And I'm a lol@50uff$ fan.

If you change your avatar I will start seeing you as a human being and not just a 50uff$' fan.

 

[Mr Spock!]

John Sutton. He is f**king useless.

And I'm a lol@50uff$ fan.

Just as well Souths resigned him then. :sarcasm: Because John has potential.:crazy:

 

[anjado]

I think Beau Ryan is the worst player in first grade. Purtell is also up there i think some of the selections have been harsh i think Pomeroy has been decent this season.

 

[Raiders_Premiers]

John Sutton looked absolutely woeful today. I thought he must have been stoned or something and didn't know what was going on around him.

 

[nomis88]

Not bad - for you. That being said, I have to tell you the Dragons took a step towards success when they offloaded Poore to parra and Ryles to.... Easts....

Other shockers through the years include Brett White and Brent Kite.

Yes Brent Kite must be terrible, he has only won one Churchill medal, absolutely terrible.