What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eels in the media

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,442

Eels Round One 2023 Team List – An Early Call​

sixtiesOctober 24, 2022 News, NRL, Opinion 86 Comments

The 2023 NRL pre-season is due to commence for some players and clubs in early November. Those that didn’t qualify for finals football will be amongst the first to return to the training track.

For the Parramatta Eels, early returns will be restricted to train and trial pathways players and potentially some new recruits. The vast majority of Parra’s NRL squad will either be back in December, or in January for those involved in the World Cup.

Much publicised departures mean that spots will be up for grabs in the top 17, and with just 26 players currently under contract for 2023, there are also roster places to be filled.
Matto.png

Ryan Matterson

Some uncertainty surrounds players on that current 26 man list, especially Nathan Brown. If he stays with the Eels, and has a good preseason, our favourite cyborg is probably a certain selection. However, I expect him to ink a deal elsewhere so I won’t include him in my predicted team list.

Ryan Matterson’s three week suspension will create an opportunity for a forward. For the purposes of this post I’ll bracket him in my Round 1 team list.
Bear in mind that this top 17 only relates to those currently under contract and without one minute of the preseason under anyone’s belt. My opinion will be subject to change based on observations of training throughout the summer.

Predicted Round 1 Eels Team
1 Gutherson
2 Dunster
3 Blake
4 Penisini
5 Sivo
6 Brown
7 Moses
8 Paulo
9 Hodgson
Lane.png

Shaun Lane
10 Campbell-Gillard
11 Lane
12 Hopgood
13 Murchie (Matto from round 4)
14 Arthur
15 Ogden
16 Cartwright
17 Makatoa
18 Matterson (suspended rounds 1-3)
Confirmed extended squad
19 Rodwell
20 Simonsson
Russell.png

Sean Russell
21 Russell
22 Momoisea
23 Loizou
24 Rein
25 Greig
26 N. Brown
Development/Second Tier/Potential Top 30
31 Cini
32 Mataele
33 Rankin (also pathways coaching)
34 Taumoepenu
35 Yates
Awaiting Confirmation
36 El-Zakhem
37 Hands
38 Keir
39 Bain
40 Moretti
41 Betham-Misa
42 Komolafe
43 Williams
A3716E53-2618-4C0D-ACF4-18711877665A-300x296.png

Rankin

I believe that you can lock in both Zac Cini and Toni Mataele as part of the full time squad in 2023, though I’m not sure whether that will be Development or Top 30. Both progressed in leaps and bounds during the year. Mataele’s bounce back from preseason injury was highly impressive and it would not surprise if he pushed for a first grade debut in 2023.

Tevita Taumoepenu should be part of the full time squad in some capacity. He was given a shot at NSW Cup level in 2022 and took it with both hands. Jordan Rankin will revert to a second tier playing role, and continue his transition towards a career in coaching via a role with Eels pathways. Jayden Yates will be part of the group returning to training in early November.

Other regular NSW Cup starters have been listed in spots 35 to 42. I am yet to receive confirmation on their status for 2023, but I hope to be able to provide an update by the start of the preseason.

There will be other players graduating from Jersey Flegg into NSW Cup in 2023, such as Flegg Captain Corey Fenning and probably halfback Ethan Sanders. Expect pathways players not listed above to participate in the NRL preseason. Some of those were involved in the 2022 JETS program.


However, my goal for this post was to identify those who are likely to play NRL this year and those are going to be drawn from the full time squad, either in the top 30 or as Development Contracted players.

Will the 17 players likely to get the early running for first grade be able to at least emulate the performance of the 2022 Eels side?

There is roster space available, so do the Eels need a significant signing or two to maintain the momentum of this last 12 months?

Perhaps the last two questions will be dependent upon finalising the contracts for both Mitch Moses and Dylan Brown. Any upgraded contract might include 2022 to spread the money across more seasons, and if so, that would impact the 2023 salary cap.

Given that so many players have moved on, and with a number of currently vacant roster spots, the obvious question mark lies around depth. As things stand, the starting 13 will be very comparable to 2022, but opportunities exist for some of the younger players to force their way into the top 17.
EEC59E95-8CE8-4017-8921-39AAD613D2C4-288x300.png

Hopgood

Jack Murchie and J’maine Hopgood have both been purchased as NRL players. Neither are anywhere near their potential, but development of such individuals is right in BA’s wheelhouse. Jirah Momoisea could be the surprise packet, and I’ll track his preseason with great interest.

The major selection debate will be around the centre and wing positions and also the bench. Preseason form will go a long way towards determining who gets the first shot. Adding a centre and a back rower to the roster probably remains a priority.

The 2022 salary cap will increase, but the final figure is yet to be confirmed. Having the World Cup in full swing and other players on holidays probably doesn’t help to get contracts sorted, so we will likely get player movement happening a bit later than we normally expect.

Rugby league’s rumour mill isn’t short on suggestions. Jake Simpkin from the Tigers and Jaydn Su’a from the Dragons have both had potential moves to the Eels rumoured on social media. Believe what you will from any of that!
Regardless, my early take is that Parra’s window most definitely remains open. Whether the Panthers allow any other club to get a look in is a topic for another post.
Eels forever

 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,465
You know he only put that in there cos he knew you would lose your shit. Too easy. 🤓
He put him there because he honestly believes he should be there, he was the star of the last pre season and he was a must pick according to 60’s. When he talks about Jakey I think he’s talking about a different footballer because he doesn’t sound like the bloke who has played 20 odd first grade games and given an absolute free ride on his last name.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,442
He put him there because he honestly believes he should be there, he was the star of the last pre season and he was a must pick according to 60’s. When he talks about Jakey I think he’s talking about a different footballer because he doesn’t sound like the bloke who has played 20 odd first grade games and given an absolute free ride on his last name.
So you're a regular listener? Cos that's not what I heard lately.

Who has put their hand up to be that utility, cos I reckon that spot is wide open. I also think that merkins are underestimating the change of thinking that new assistants will bring in 2023.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,124

Eels Round One 2023 Team List – An Early Call​

sixtiesOctober 24, 2022 News, NRL, Opinion 86 Comments

The 2023 NRL pre-season is due to commence for some players and clubs in early November. Those that didn’t qualify for finals football will be amongst the first to return to the training track.

For the Parramatta Eels, early returns will be restricted to train and trial pathways players and potentially some new recruits. The vast majority of Parra’s NRL squad will either be back in December, or in January for those involved in the World Cup.

Much publicised departures mean that spots will be up for grabs in the top 17, and with just 26 players currently under contract for 2023, there are also roster places to be filled.
Matto.png

Ryan Matterson

Some uncertainty surrounds players on that current 26 man list, especially Nathan Brown. If he stays with the Eels, and has a good preseason, our favourite cyborg is probably a certain selection. However, I expect him to ink a deal elsewhere so I won’t include him in my predicted team list.

Ryan Matterson’s three week suspension will create an opportunity for a forward. For the purposes of this post I’ll bracket him in my Round 1 team list.
Bear in mind that this top 17 only relates to those currently under contract and without one minute of the preseason under anyone’s belt. My opinion will be subject to change based on observations of training throughout the summer.

Predicted Round 1 Eels Team
1 Gutherson
2 Dunster
3 Blake
4 Penisini
5 Sivo
6 Brown
7 Moses
8 Paulo
9 Hodgson
Lane.png

Shaun Lane
10 Campbell-Gillard
11 Lane
12 Hopgood
13 Murchie (Matto from round 4)
14 Arthur
15 Ogden
16 Cartwright
17 Makatoa
18 Matterson (suspended rounds 1-3)
Confirmed extended squad
19 Rodwell
20 Simonsson
Russell.png

Sean Russell
21 Russell
22 Momoisea
23 Loizou
24 Rein
25 Greig
26 N. Brown
Development/Second Tier/Potential Top 30
31 Cini
32 Mataele
33 Rankin (also pathways coaching)
34 Taumoepenu
35 Yates
Awaiting Confirmation
36 El-Zakhem
37 Hands
38 Keir
39 Bain
40 Moretti
41 Betham-Misa
42 Komolafe
43 Williams
A3716E53-2618-4C0D-ACF4-18711877665A-300x296.png

Rankin

I believe that you can lock in both Zac Cini and Toni Mataele as part of the full time squad in 2023, though I’m not sure whether that will be Development or Top 30. Both progressed in leaps and bounds during the year. Mataele’s bounce back from preseason injury was highly impressive and it would not surprise if he pushed for a first grade debut in 2023.

Tevita Taumoepenu should be part of the full time squad in some capacity. He was given a shot at NSW Cup level in 2022 and took it with both hands. Jordan Rankin will revert to a second tier playing role, and continue his transition towards a career in coaching via a role with Eels pathways. Jayden Yates will be part of the group returning to training in early November.

Other regular NSW Cup starters have been listed in spots 35 to 42. I am yet to receive confirmation on their status for 2023, but I hope to be able to provide an update by the start of the preseason.

There will be other players graduating from Jersey Flegg into NSW Cup in 2023, such as Flegg Captain Corey Fenning and probably halfback Ethan Sanders. Expect pathways players not listed above to participate in the NRL preseason. Some of those were involved in the 2022 JETS program.


However, my goal for this post was to identify those who are likely to play NRL this year and those are going to be drawn from the full time squad, either in the top 30 or as Development Contracted players.

Will the 17 players likely to get the early running for first grade be able to at least emulate the performance of the 2022 Eels side?

There is roster space available, so do the Eels need a significant signing or two to maintain the momentum of this last 12 months?

Perhaps the last two questions will be dependent upon finalising the contracts for both Mitch Moses and Dylan Brown. Any upgraded contract might include 2022 to spread the money across more seasons, and if so, that would impact the 2023 salary cap.

Given that so many players have moved on, and with a number of currently vacant roster spots, the obvious question mark lies around depth. As things stand, the starting 13 will be very comparable to 2022, but opportunities exist for some of the younger players to force their way into the top 17.
EEC59E95-8CE8-4017-8921-39AAD613D2C4-288x300.png

Hopgood

Jack Murchie and J’maine Hopgood have both been purchased as NRL players. Neither are anywhere near their potential, but development of such individuals is right in BA’s wheelhouse. Jirah Momoisea could be the surprise packet, and I’ll track his preseason with great interest.

The major selection debate will be around the centre and wing positions and also the bench. Preseason form will go a long way towards determining who gets the first shot. Adding a centre and a back rower to the roster probably remains a priority.

The 2022 salary cap will increase, but the final figure is yet to be confirmed. Having the World Cup in full swing and other players on holidays probably doesn’t help to get contracts sorted, so we will likely get player movement happening a bit later than we normally expect.

Rugby league’s rumour mill isn’t short on suggestions. Jake Simpkin from the Tigers and Jaydn Su’a from the Dragons have both had potential moves to the Eels rumoured on social media. Believe what you will from any of that!
Regardless, my early take is that Parra’s window most definitely remains open. Whether the Panthers allow any other club to get a look in is a topic for another post.
Eels forever


That bench... Eep!
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,442
That bench... Eep!
Agree, Averagetown. Time for some young bucks to step up in the preseason and claim a spot. Matto will be return from the naughty corner, so assume he will start and Murchie will be benchy.

14 Arthur
15 Ogden
16 Cartwright
17 Makatoa
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,811
Surely Brown gets a gig on the bench ahead of Makatoa and Ogden if he is still here.
You would like to think so, and with the signings we have already made, I can see the following as an option.
8. Paulo
9. Hodgson
10. RCG
11. Lane
12. Murchie
13. Hopgood/Matterson
14. ???
15. Momoisea/Hopgood
16. Rodwell
17. Nrown

Murchie has proved himself an 80 minute player in 2022 which makes him a suitable replacement for Papali'i.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,025
It got hammered on Twitter with most seeming to think they are both re-signing for the Eels. I've seen an article with quotes from Dylbro saying it's not about the money and he really doesn't want to leave Parra, this was about 6 months ago, posted here some where.

Not sure about Mitch.
 

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,208
I think they will both stay.
Money is one thing but being in a competitive team with the chance of winning a comp opens more doors post footy as well.
With more opportunities also comes more $$$.
Unless players don't want to play in Sept every year then take the $$$ and go to a team who doesn't play finals
 

Incorrect

Coach
Messages
12,603
It got hammered on Twitter with most seeming to think they are both re-signing for the Eels. I've seen an article with quotes from Dylbro saying it's not about the money and he really doesn't want to leave Parra, this was about 6 months ago, posted here some where.

Not sure about Mitch.
Everybody loves BA/Parra/The Club until they don't and go and sign for shedloads of cash with a rival... Mahoney told one of our esteemed colleagues here he was staying put and the next day it was announced he had signed for the Doggies... Talk is indeed cheap. I believe nothing about love of the club or the coach until their extension is there in black and white.....
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,368
I think they will both stay.
Money is one thing but being in a competitive team with the chance of winning a comp opens more doors post footy as well.
With more opportunities also comes more $$$.
Unless players don't want to play in Sept every year then take the $$$ and go to a team who doesn't play finals

If you put Bateman and Klemmer in that Tigers team, and then take Moses out of Parra and put him in the Tigers, who do you think would be the more competitive and likely to play in September, us or the Tigers?

If you take Moses out of that Parra team, we wouldn't get anywhere near the Top 8.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
52,908
Predicted Round 1 Eels Team
1 Gutherson
1666868988653.png
2 Dunster
3 Blake
4 Penisini
5 Sivo
1666868988653.png
6 Brown
7 Moses
8 Paulo
9 Hodgson
1666868988653.png
10 Campbell-Gillard
11 Lane
12 Hopgood
13 Murchie (Matto from round 4)
1666868988653.png
14 Arthur
15 Ogden
16 Cartwright
17 Makatoa
1666868988653.png
18 Matterson (suspended rounds 1-3)
1666868988653.png1666868988653.png
 

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,208
If you put Bateman and Klemmer in that Tigers team, and then take Moses out of Parra and put him in the Tigers, who do you think would be the more competitive and likely to play in September, us or the Tigers?

If you take Moses out of that Parra team, we wouldn't get anywhere near the Top 8.
Disagree that Tigers would still make the 8...even if they were to get those players they wouldn't make it.
We would still go better than them
 

Latest posts

Top